Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols
279 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Into horror films? Into new, old, obscure, classic AND trashy horror films? To keep from fainting, listen to It's Only a Podcast.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Precise scene analysis and lively co-host chemistry turn horror reviews into arguments about craft, character logic, and franchise continuity.
Christian Estabrook uses horror movies as the start of an argument, then keeps pressing until a scene's logic, performance, or franchise baggage gives way.
A haunted pool gets cross-examined; you might wish the pool itself had been the murderer.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A tarot-driven horror premise gets a fair hearing before the episode digs into its stiff dialogue and thin character work.
Episode 213 takes a tarot-centered horror movie apart with blunt, useful focus, as Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols move from the card readings themselves to whether those readings actually create tension onscreen.
A funny, pointed Immaculate review that finds tension in faith, misogyny, performance, and a late surge.
Episode 210 works best when Estabrook and Nichols keep their attention on Immaculate's uneasy religious-horror setup: a young nun, an Italian nunnery, and a final five minutes they think gives the film a meaningful lift.
A warm, unruly return that turns a four-month absence into fresh horror-podcast momentum.
Episode 215 comes back from its four-month break by leaning into the easy, loose chemistry between Christian Esterbrook and Ian Nichols. It starts with an oddly specific question about Mudang, a tiny baby hippo, then gradually wanders back toward horror.
A haunted-house ranking that makes horror architecture feel vivid, funny, and dangerous.
This bonus episode turns a haunted-house ranking into something both funny and unsettling, using horror architecture as a running joke and a genuine source of dread.
A loose horror hangout that works best when it fixes on the barn creatures and the absurd pitch around the barn itself.
The episode opens on familiar book guilt, with Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols admitting that buying books keeps outrunning reading them. It then settles into There's Something In the Barn, where the discussion gives real attention to the elf creatures' stiff faces and to…
A loose horror conversation that turns typewriter chatter and mansion chaos into a sharp, funny movie discussion.
Episode 212 begins with typewriter banter and easy chemistry before settling into movie talk once Abigail comes up. The best part is the stretch that digs into the mansion setup, the mismatched crew inside it, and Angus Cloud's slurred but convincing performance.
A messy, funny movie review that turns a tiny bear into a full-screen frustration machine.
This episode opens with Oscars chatter before moving into Imaginary and another movie from the crypt, and the hosts are notably tough on the title they spend most of their time on.
A horror chat that enjoys the grotesque side of The Substance while staying skeptical about its length.
Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols keep the discussion loose and funny as they settle into what The Substance is doing. Christian is especially drawn to Margaret Qualley, and Dennis Quaid's ridiculous, grotesque turn gets singled out as the movie's wildest element.
Mike Muncer and a different guest dissect two horror films per episode, by subgenre.
Episode 206 starts in full side-quest mode.
Christian Estabrook and Elle Willers kick things off with a gross joke that sets the mood right away.
They open with typewriters.
Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols open with a bone tangent, then drift into a horror review that hinges on how fast the violence starts and how fast it ends.
Christian and Ian open in full booth-chaos mode, with paint fumes and a twilight-plum office facelift hanging over the conversation.
Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols open with a rough Halloween check-in and admit life has been a mess.
Christian Estabrook opens Overkill by grilling L Willers about Christmas cookies and the best Christmas cookie shape.
Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols open with Game of Thrones talk before drifting into a horror conversation about a haunted pool premise.
Hosts Christian Esterbrook and Elle Willers launch their review of Saw 5 by humorously debating which characters they resemble, with Elle claiming vengeful ties to Detective Hoffman and Christian probing their dark similarities.
Hosts Christian and Ian catch up after Ian's trip to New Zealand, discussing Oscars, travel, and music before reviewing the horror film 'Imaginary' (which they passionately pan) and the slower, atmospheric 'The Long Walk' from Laos.
The hosts of It's Only a Podcast discuss the meaning of the word 'caboodle' in a light-hearted, humorous conversation.
Hosts Christian and Ian review the Christmas horror film There's Something in the Barn, discussing its Norwegian folklore and tonal issues, then analyze the classic Australian horror Wake in Fright, exploring its themes of toxic masculinity and alcoholism.
Christian Estabrook and Ian Nichols open Episode 213 of It's Only a Podcast with a long riff on halitosis, food in teeth, and how social taboos around hygiene should be easier to say out loud.
Episode 208 opens with Christian Estabrook and Elle Willers before the movie talk even gets going.
Christian Estabrook opens with Elle Willers in a loose, joke-heavy exchange about what you would sing into if nobody were watching.
Christian Estabrook opens the bonus episode as the merchant of menace.
Christian Estabrook opens the show a little rusty and almost immediately gets the conversation stuck on pancakes versus waffles.
Christian Esterbrook and Elle Willers kick things off with Oscar jokes, Pedro Pascal praise, and the sort of reaction-noise banter that sends the conversation wandering before it settles into Spiral: From the Book of Saw.