Unsolved Mysteries Rewind
109 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
...doing the research so you don't have to... Come along as two friends get together to discuss episodes of their (and your) favorite television show, Unsolved Mysteries!
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Mark and Amy revisit unresolved cases by comparing accounts, questioning investigative gaps and keeping speculation separate from what the available details support.
Unsolved Mysteries Rewind gives Mark and Amy room to reconsider cases long after the television episode has ended. Their conversations move from the original account into maps, later reporting, dramatizations and the practical details that can make an official explanation feel…
Two plates in a reenactment, none recalled by responders: your inner TV detective just found company.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A Christmas-season cold case, handled with humor, skepticism, and a little drift.
Rhonda Hinson's case lands as a Christmas-season cold case, and that setting gives the conversation a sharper edge. Amy and Mark keep circling the same stubborn question: how do you sit with a story that never quite adds up?
A suspicious interview and a puzzling dismissal leave Hugh Harlan's wife's disappearance unsettled.
The disappearance draws its tension from details that keep shifting under scrutiny: Hugh Harlan's account of his wife's absence, the dogs reportedly returning with leashes still on, and his first failure to identify a piece of jewelry before correcting himself.
A warm true-crime recap that keeps Susan and the people around her at the center.
This episode stays close to Susan Taraskiewicz as a person, which gives the true-crime story some weight. It moves through her Boston-area background, her job at Northwest Airlines at Logan Airport, and the small details that make her feel real.
A suburban mystery gets skeptical banter and an open-ended read.
Mark and Amy work through a suburban break-in with the skeptical banter that gives the show its shape. They start with jokes about Willy Wacker's name, then move through the stolen possessions, the crayon message on the wall, and the nagging question of what the intruder was…
A creepy abduction case becomes a measured look at what an old television segment leaves unanswered.
A creepy abduction case turns into a close test of how much an Unsolved Mysteries segment can leave unresolved. Mark and Amy revisit the phone call, the scream, the truck, and the desperate chase, staying with details that do not quite settle: why the abductor says he did not…
Mark and Amy take another pass at an Unsolved Mysteries case and keep finding the parts that do not quite add up.
Mark and Amy circle back to an Unsolved Mysteries case and spend most of the discussion on the bits that still do not line up. The reporting from 1987, the CPR, the NyQuil, the towel, and the tray with two plates keep pulling the conversation back into the same knot, which gives…
A locked car, a missing man, and hosts who keep worrying the details until they stop lining up.
Mark and Amy keep circling A.J. Breaux's disappearance from the same stubborn angles: the locked car, the map, and the details that never quite line up.
A skeptical discussion that keeps Jesslyn's disappearance details and cover-up suspicion in view.
Amy and Mark keep the case anchored in Jesslyn's clean work record, her 4.0 GPA, her two kids, and the absence of a body, credit card use, or bank withdrawals. That mix gives the discussion a steady, skeptical tone and keeps the central mystery from drifting into speculation.
NHPR's Jason Moon investigates the Bear Brook barrel murders and a New Hampshire wrongful-conviction case.
Payne Lindsey's season-long investigation into two disappearances from Nome, Alaska.
CBC's true crime feed tracing Cleo's case into cold cases across its investigative podcast network.
Journalists chase a decades-long trail through a coronial inquest and Rick Bloom's dozens of aliases.
A New York Times reporter reinvestigates Laramie's unsolved 1985 murder of Shelley Wiley.
Amy and Mark open with a different intro before landing on Gary Grant Jr.'s case.
Two friends catch up and discuss episodes of the classic TV show Unsolved Mysteries.
Two friends discuss episodes of the TV show Unsolved Mysteries, mixing recap with humorous banter.
Rhonda Hinson's case comes in with Christmas already sitting awkwardly nearby.
Hugh looks older than 51.
Susan Taraskiewicz was 27.
"Cheaper, but we'll do." Mark and Amy use the Wackers' case to poke at neighborly noise, old police scanners, and the odd theft Bill finds after Dorothy is hurt.
Mark and Amy revisit an old Unsolved Mysteries case and immediately start pulling at the pieces that still feel slippery.
Mark and Amy dig into the disappearance of A.J.
Amy and Mark dig into the Unsolved Mysteries case tied to Jesslyn's disappearance.
Mark and Amy cover the 1989 Oregon killing of Michael Frank or Frankie, and they keep calling it a stabbing, a murder, and maybe an assassination because the case never really settles into one clean label.
Hosts Amy and Mark discuss the Elizabeth Carmichael case, focusing on her 1970s scam to sell the Dale, a three-wheel fuel-efficient car that never materialized.
Hosts Amy and Mark analyze the unsolved 1983 murder of Terri McClure in Carson City, Nevada, discussing key suspects like her son Tim, evidence gaps, and theories including premeditation and hitchhiking.
The episode opens in boxing history.
Mark and Amy open by calling this one of the show’s genuinely unsolved cases and pointing out that the episode is season 11, episode 11, with a Dennis Farina version also out there under the title “The Other Intern.” They are quick to object to that title and say it does Joyce no favors.
Mark and Amy return to Virginia for a closer look at the Herndon case.
Mark and Amy return to Unsolved Mysteries Rewind and dig into season 11, episode two, "Suicide Homicide," focused on the case of Ray Ann Mosser.
The episode opens on a rough note.
Two friends recap and discuss an episode of Unsolved Mysteries about the unexplained death of Kurt Sova.
Two friends discuss a murder case featured on Unsolved Mysteries, analyzing the details and suspect's background.
Two friends casually discuss episodes of the TV show Unsolved Mysteries, starting with small talk about weather.
Two friends discuss episodes of the TV show Unsolved Mysteries, starting with the '49 Hugs' case.
Two friends discuss and analyze a true crime case from the TV show Unsolved Mysteries.
Two friends discuss and analyze a true crime case featured on the TV show Unsolved Mysteries.
Two friends discuss and critique a Halloween episode of the TV show Unsolved Mysteries.
Two friends discuss and research episodes of the TV show Unsolved Mysteries, providing commentary and background information.