Unsolved Mysteries Rewind · Unsolved Mysteries Rewind

Unsolved Mysteries Rewind 70: Annie Laurie Hearin and Rogest Cain

February 8, 2023·54 min·2 clips

This was recorded December 11, 2022. Laura passed December 26. This is her final work.

The show starts by looking back at a rough stretch when the previous co-host decided she no longer wanted to work on the show. A Facebook-group message from an Aussie named Laura saves it. The time difference is rough. They end up swapping who is half an hour early and who is half an hour late until the schedule finally clicks. When they do get on mic together, the rapport is immediate. Laura's research stamina becomes part of the show's engine. The host keeps saying how chipper she was, which makes the darker material hit harder. Later, Laura admits she is not doing well, and the episode handles that with care. From there, the case takes over. The discussion keeps circling the Annie story and the paralegal claim without pretending the answers are simple. One thread focuses on a man who had been in severe financial trouble for about seven years after the school pictures lawsuit. Three bankruptcy attempts and a refusal to be evicted make that backstory look bad. The hosts even puzzle through what it means to live upstairs from your own office. A paralegal's claim gets picked apart next. The van story is the kind of detail that feels huge for a minute and then starts to slip. It turns out the white van was being serviced that day, which weakens the easy theory. Even so, investigators still think the people involved are lying about parts of the story. The FBI response adds more pressure, with a satellite command post and a tapped phone in case a ransom call comes through. The hosts keep pointing at the strange texture around the case, not just the timeline. That gives the episode its shape: skeptical, chatty, a little messy, and willing to sit inside the mess.

As heard by us

A warm, banter-filled wrap-up of a co-host change and the work behind the show.

Unsolved Mysteries Rewind ends with a reflective, banter-heavy look at the show itself: a co-host departure, a growing listener base, the pressure of scheduling, and the hunt for someone who could keep the same easy rhythm.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a loose true-crime recap that keeps circling the same odd details.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries Rewind