Unsolved Mysteries Rewind · Unsolved Mysteries Rewind

Unsolved Mysteries Rewind 71: The Mysterious Death of Rae Ann Mossor

August 15, 2023·53 min·35 clips

Mark and Amy are back in the two thrones, joking about money, milk crates, and the noise outside before settling into Unsolved Mysteries Rewind again. They go all the way back into the archives with season 11, episode two, "Suicide Homicide," which covers the case of Ray Ann Mosser. The case stays at the center, and they keep circling the same question: suicide or homicide? They do it by laying out the scene details and then arguing over what those details actually mean. The blaring music outside the house matters to them. They picture what that would feel like on a dark February night, especially if someone had been shot and nobody knew what to touch. That pulls them into the practical mess of whether you turn off the radio, leave the scene alone, or just wait for police to arrive. The conversation drifts into a side joke about Rammstein, but the point stays the same: in a crisis, people make awkward, dumb, and uncertain choices. They also compare the reenactment styles and think the Farina reenactment is a little more dramatic and a little more modern. The segments with the parents feel longer to them, and they seem to think that helps the case land. They also pick apart the show’s ad hoc demonstrations, comparing the broom logic with an expert approach and wondering what any of it really proves. The result is a skeptical, lived-in conversation that keeps Ray Ann Mosser’s death at the center while still leaving room for riffing, backtracking, and jokes in the margins.

As heard by us

A skeptical, funny rewind that keeps the Ray Ann Mosser case unsettled and specific.

Unsolved Mysteries Rewind returns to the Ray Ann Mosser case and spends most of its time checking the show's version of events against what Mark and Amy think would actually happen in the room.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want two friends to pick apart a Unsolved Mysteries episode about Ray Ann Mosser until the details start to wobble.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries Rewind