Unsolved Mysteries Rewind · Unsolved Mysteries Rewind

The Vanishing of A.J. Breaux

December 19, 2023·1 hr 4 min·5 clips

Mark opens by introducing another Unsolved Mysteries Rewind conversation with Amy. The pair immediately stumble over A.J. Breaux's name and keep joking their way through the pronunciation. They settle on the basic fact that he disappeared in the summer of 1991. The case is set in Alma, Louisiana. They go back and forth on whether the town should be pronounced Huma or Uma before landing on Alma. They also joke around with the name Adam John and keep circling back to how strange the whole thing feels. Mark notes that A.J. was 50 years old. He then throws in that he is 50 and 5'11", which turns the opening into the kind of digressive banter the show leans on. As they get further into the case, the two hosts talk through the layout of the area on a map. One of them says the map is hard to copy and paste, which leads to more frustration and more looking. They wonder whether the street and club area are really where they seem to be, and they describe the place as feeling more like woods than a park, with lots of bayou water around it. They also suspect the area may have changed a lot after 2006, so the old map may not be a reliable guide to how it looked back in 1991. Still, they agree the area is pretty big. The car is found abandoned and locked. His daughters drive to the scene right away. They also mention that someone had called the police and asked them to meet the family there, which adds to the confusion about how the car was first discovered. The daughters cannot get into the locked car and immediately begin crying. The hosts stay unsure about what really happened to A.J. Breaux, but they keep circling the idea that he may have gotten caught up with the wrong person. By the end, they admit they are probably never going to know for sure. The episode closes with their usual thanks, a sign-off, and the same restless feeling that the case still does not make complete sense.

As heard by us

A locked car, a missing man, and hosts who keep worrying the details until they stop lining up.

Mark and Amy keep circling A.J. Breaux's disappearance from the same stubborn angles: the locked car, the map, and the details that never quite line up.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a conversational missing-person discussion from Alma, Louisiana, where two hosts keep circling a 1991 case and never quite land on a clean answer.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries Rewind