Unsolved Mysteries Rewind · Unsolved Mysteries Rewind

Who Killed Rhonda Hinson

July 19, 2024·47 min·5 clips

The episode opens with a warning. Amy flags sexual assault before the recap starts, and Mark folds Christmas into the unease. That is pretty much the temperature of the room: serious, unsettled, but still loose enough for jokes and side roads. Rhonda Hinson's case stays heavy because it stays unresolved. Then another case barges in. A question about someone killing a whole family pulls Amy into the Rick Church and Colleen Ritter story from Unsolved Mysteries. It sounds like a detour, but it earns its spot. It gives them another way to talk about obsession, isolation, and danger hiding inside relationships that look normal from the outside. Mark takes it badly. Amy remembers the sleepover, the surviving friends, the police presence, and the feeling that old segment still leaves behind. Then they come back to Rhonda. The reenactment detail about her asking her dad to ride with her is the part they cannot shake. They get almost practical, and very parental. If a child says there is something terrible to reveal, that conversation does not end in the car. It is blunt, tender, and a little desperate. Beneath the riffing is panic over partial disclosures and the way hindsight turns every quiet moment into evidence. By the end, they are still testing what care, violence, love, and obsession might mean here. They do not pretend to know.

As heard by us

A Christmas-season cold case, handled with humor, skepticism, and a little drift.

Rhonda Hinson's case lands as a Christmas-season cold case, and that setting gives the conversation a sharper edge. Amy and Mark keep circling the same stubborn question: how do you sit with a story that never quite adds up?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a cold case discussed by two friends who are still trying to make sense of it.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries Rewind