Audioboom Studios
197 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Detailed case reconstruction meets candid questioning, with Bailey Sarian tracking relationships, evidence, and institutional failures behind widely discussed crimes.
Bailey Sarian tells complicated crime stories while doing her makeup, pairing detailed case reconstruction with an informal, openly reactive delivery.
Bailey Sarian does her makeup while your first take on a notorious case starts looking shaky.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A missing-person case turns submerged restraints and recovered texts into a chilling trail of control.
The episode follows Elaine O'Hara's case through the hard trail of objects found at Vartree Reservoir in County Wicklow, where fishermen pull restraints and BDSM gear from the shallows and one uneasy instinct brings police in.
A trusted doctor, a Demerol confession, and a hometown joke that curdles once the murders come into view.
Murder, Mystery & Makeup's Harold Shipman episode turns on a grim contradiction: a trusted local doctor, liked by people in town, carrying a joke nickname that later sounds far less harmless. That shift gives the story its pull.
A strange public persona and a criminology background frame a grim Bradford case about warning signs noticed too late.
Bailey Sarian's account of Stephen Griffiths tracks a disturbing Bradford case through the uneasy gap between public oddness and private horror.
A grim, tightly focused account of Otis Toole’s alleged crimes and his volatile partnership with Henry Lucas.
Bailey Sarian’s episode treats Otis Toole as a figure defined by arson, murder, and grotesque self-mythology, tracing allegations that move from dismemberment and blood drinking to his bond with Henry Lucas.
A faculty shooting becomes a brisk study of warning signs that kept going nowhere.
A faculty meeting at the University of Alabama in Huntsville opens into a measured portrait of Amy Bishop, with the 2010 shooting set against prior warning signs and a troubling pattern of violence.
A vivid Zodiac retelling that keeps the mystery sharp and the narration personal.
Bailey Sarian's take on the Zodiac Killer is lively and immediate, moving through the hooded sightings, the taunting letters, the unsolved ciphers, and the eerie phone calls without losing momentum.
A poison case with gothic oddity and a steady pulse.
This episode stays with Lydia Trueblood, the picture-perfect housewife figure tied to suspicious deaths, arsenic-laced flypaper, a bad dye job, two gold front teeth, and the gothic nickname Idaho's Lady Bluebeard.
A conversational Memphis true-crime episode that gives Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward real emotional weight.
Bailey Sarian tells this late-19th-century Memphis murder as a true crime story that stays close to Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward. The letters, the proposal, and the plan for a legal marriage give the episode a human center before the violence takes over, which is where the case…
Crime stories with impact and consequence.
Epstein-case coverage with teeth.
Betrayal, evidence, and the breaking point.
The security camera captured everything: her running in fear, him chasing with a crossbow, and him mocking the camera afterward.
Bailey Sarian digs into the case of Shayna Hubers, the woman dubbed the Kentucky Jodi Arias.
Lydia Trueblood looks like a polished housewife.
Bailey Sarian opens with Terri Schiavo and treats the story like the rabbit hole it is.
Bailey Sarian covers a mushroom-poisoning case involving a woman accused of poisoning a bunch of people with mushrooms.
Bailey goes straight at the Josef Fritzl case.
Bailey Sarian opens by saying the recording was made earlier and that updates will come at the end.
Bailey Sarian narrates the mysterious 1996 murder of Kent LePink in Hope, Alaska, involving a love triangle with Michelle Hughes, who was engaged to multiple men.
Bailey Sarian narrates the true crime story of Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward, two Victorian teenagers whose lesbian romance in 1890s Memphis ended with Freda's murder.
Bailey Sarian narrates the tragic story of Aaron Hernandez, an NFL star whose promising career collapsed into violence and murder, driven by a troubled childhood, CTE brain damage, and a series of crimes including multiple shootings.
Charlie realized she was poisoning and left - but left their newborn with her.
Bailey Sarian covers the case of Dr.
Bailey Sarian takes on Robert Pickton.
Bailey Sarian revisits Jodi Arias and says she looked into what Arias has been doing in prison, while also noting Arias’s 45th birthday on July 9th.
Bailey Sarian ties North Fox Island in Lake Michigan to Brother Paul's Christian Mission, a 1975 Port Huron charity that claimed to offer tutoring, counseling, lodging, and emergency care for runaway boys.
Bailey Sarian covers Christine Falling, a Florida babysitter later linked to five infant deaths, one elderly man’s death, and three attempted infant murders between 1980 and 1982.
Bailey Sarian opens on Clara and David Harris, a couple that looks like the full Texas package.
Bailey Sarian digs into the Kelly Cochran case from Iron River, Michigan.
Bailey Sarian takes on the Zodiac Killer, a case she says she had been avoiding because it is such a behemoth of a story.
Bailey Sarian opens the Monday installment of Murder, Mystery, and Makeup with a Q&A pulled from Instagram.
Bailey Sarian frames the Chicago Lipstick Killer case in 1945, when a wall message in red lipstick said, “for heaven’s sake, catch me before I kill more.
Bailey Sarian takes on the Sarah Boone case.
Between the 1960s and 1980s, Otis Toole allegedly killed over 100 people across 26 states.
Prison guard's sexual assault attempt meets violent self-defense with unexpected consequences