Murder, Mystery & Makeup · Audioboom Studios

A Victorian lesbian romance ends in madness, jealousy, and MURDER?? - Alice Mitchell & Freda Ward

·54 min·4 clips
Alice planned to cut her hair, grow a mustache, and marry Freda as 'Alvin J. Ward' in a secret Victorian same-sex wedding.
Bailey Sarian narrates the true crime story of Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward, two Victorian teenagers whose lesbian romance in 1890s Memphis ended with Freda's murder. Alice's obsessive love led her to plan a secret marriage, attempt poisoning, and ultimately slash Freda's throat, resulting in an insanity plea and institutionalization. The case sparked early public discourse on lesbianism and forensic psychiatry.

As heard by us

A conversational Memphis true-crime episode that gives Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward real emotional weight.

Bailey Sarian tells this late-19th-century Memphis murder as a true crime story that stays close to Alice Mitchell and Freda Ward. The letters, the proposal, and the plan for a legal marriage give the episode a human center before the violence takes over, which is where the case…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A late-19th-century Memphis story of teen love, murder, and a proposal that went nowhere.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on