Murder, Mystery & Makeup · Audioboom Studios

Trapped & Left to Die...in a suitcase?! WTF was Sarah Boone Thinking?

·54 min·5 clips

Bailey finally goes down the Sarah Boone rabbit hole. She says she waited until the sentencing was done so she could lean on court documents instead of online chatter, and that choice keeps the story grounded even when the facts get wild. The suitcase is at the center of it all. Sarah Boone is shown in the middle of a night that turns frightening, and Bailey keeps circling back to the same baffled reaction: what was Sarah thinking? The recording is hard to shake. Bailey treats the recording as the kind of detail people remember immediately, and she does not sand that down. She walks through the injuries, the blunt-force trauma to his skull, the cuts, the bruises, and the signs that he was fighting for his life. The first explanation falls apart. When Sarah is confronted with the evidence, she shifts and blames alcohol, saying they were drinking a lot and she was not thinking clearly. That does not get her out of it. She is arrested on February 25, 2020 for second-degree murder, and the story stops being a viral clip and becomes a courtroom problem with real consequences. Then the lawyer chaos starts. Bailey says Sarah goes through nine attorneys before trial, with some quitting, some getting fired, and one lasting only about sixteen days before leaving. The case keeps changing shape. The court determines that Sarah qualifies for court-appointed counsel because she lacks the financial resources to hire private legal help, which Bailey pauses to explain before moving on to the next attorney shuffle. Sarah then hires Mauricio Padilla. Bailey treats that turn as one more sign that the case refuses to settle into anything simple, tidy, or remotely normal. By the end, it is a circus. The narrative has moved from one brutal night to a long legal mess, and Bailey closes the story with the same blunt, conversational moral she keeps returning to: do not do this, do not think this is funny, and make better choices.

As heard by us

A suitcase-and-video murder case told with court-doc discipline and stunned disbelief.

Bailey Sarian revisits the Sarah Boone case with a stunned, half-laughing tone that fits the material without trying to smooth it over. She says she waited until sentencing was done and leaned on court documents, which keeps the story grounded even as it gets bleak fast.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a suitcase case told with side-eye and zero dead air.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder, Mystery & Makeup