Murder, Mystery & Makeup · Audioboom Studios

Murder By Mushrooms?? Or A Big Mistake? The twisted case of Erin Patterson

·1 hr 1 min·2 clips

Bailey opens by saying this story had been sitting heavy on her mind and that a recent filming day finally pushed her to talk about it. She frames the case as unusual even for true crime. The lunch in a quiet Victorian town becomes the center of everything. The people at the table are soon dealing with mushroom poisoning that doctors identify as amatoxin exposure. That toxin attacks the liver and kidneys. Symptoms can take a day or more to fully show up, which makes the case even more chilling. Heather is the first to decline. Her condition worsens too fast for a transplant to be possible. Gail follows soon after. Don receives a liver transplant, but it fails and he dies the next night. Ian survives the initial crisis and slowly improves. He later comes off the breathing tube and eventually moves to rehab. Bailey lingers on how fast the whole family was taken out. Simon’s grief runs through the aftermath. He holds a public memorial for his parents and hundreds of people attend. During that service he shares a final text message from his mother. Bailey keeps reacting to the case as she tells it, mixing disbelief, side comments, and plain explanation. The episode keeps circling back to how strange and old-fashioned the poisoning method feels. It ends with her stunned by the scale of the tragedy and the sheer weirdness of the crime. The tone stays conversational even as the case gets darker. The result is a brisk, personal retelling of a devastating murder case.

As heard by us

A mushroom-poisoning case told with Bailey Sarian's mix of shock, pace, and side-eye.

Bailey Sarian turns the mushroom-poisoning case into a brisk, chatty retelling that still keeps the human cost in view. The episode moves through the deaths, the survivor's hard fight, and the way the danger keeps building as the toxin takes hold, so the story lands with real…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a mushroom-poisoning true-crime story told with Bailey Sarian's chatty, makeup-table energy.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder, Mystery & Makeup