Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas

Adam Graham|Old Time Radio Detective Host

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

In their own words

Adam Graham continues his journey through Old Time Radio Detective programs from their first available adventure to their final bow in Seasons 4-6 which were released between 2012 and 2015, featuring nearly 1,000 Old Time Radio episodes. You can listen to the current podcast feed of The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio here.Picking up where we left off at the end of Volume 1, Volume 2 begins by continuing the Adventures of Frank Race, The Fat Man, Let George Do It, Sherlock Holmes (with John Stanley and later John Gielgud) and Yours Truly Johnny Dollar with John Lund.In this volume, we'll hear...

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Adam Graham pairs complete vintage detective dramas with concise context on their performers, mysteries, humor, and surviving recordings.

Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas lets vintage detective stories do most of the talking, with Adam Graham providing introductions and closing commentary around each production.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A fur coat's stitching might make you want to apprentice under Nick Carter.

Press play if you want

  • to follow clues small enough to hide in a coat's seams
  • to hear Gregory Hood spar with a policeman who won't believe his corpse story
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Talks about

Best episodes of Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Open Town Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1169)Feb 18, 2026

A barroom-driven Johnny Dollar story where grudges, a badly handled shooting, and Joe Cleary's attachment to Marty keep the suspicion tight.

The Open Town Matter keeps Johnny Dollar on a tense, talk-heavy trail in Greensport, where Joe Cleary, a drunken reporter for the Greensport Daily Herald, comes into focus after Johnny tracks him down through his hangouts and finds him on his third martini.

The Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Murder of Gregory Hood (EP1168)Feb 17, 2026

A quiet evening turns into a shooting, and the night gets harder to manage.

This Gregory Hood outing moves quickly from a social evening into a shooting, with a warning to stay low in the back seat and a tense moment at the doorway that leaves Carter down the steps.

Nick Carter: Murder on Mad Mountain (EP1164)Feb 12, 2026

A snowbound train turns into a tight old-school murder puzzle.

This episode turns a snow slide into a tight murder puzzle on the train. Nick Carter works the Queen's car through dead bodies, stolen jewels, and clues that only matter if they are handled carefully.

Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Capetown Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1163)Feb 11, 2026

A bruised lieutenant, a ransacked stateroom, and a diamond that keeps the case moving on a ship.

Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Cape Town Matter, Parts Three and Four keeps the diamond chase brisk across Cape Town and the Southern Empress, with Lieutenant Van Tile still recovering after being knocked out and the ship already gone.

The Casebook of the Gregory Hood: The Black Museum (EP1162)Feb 10, 2026

A banter-led mystery that turns a calm exchange into a knife warning.

Gregory Hood leans on banter and contrast, letting Sandy and Gregory trade dry lines until a stranger breaks in with a warning about a knife. The episode's appeal lies in how a routine social exchange turns faintly ominous, with the easy sparring giving the mystery a clean hook…

Podcasts like Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas

  • Decoder RingSlate Podcasts

    Prunes, protein, and the histories behind familiar assumptions.

  • Radiotopia PresentsRadiotopia

    One feed, many limited-run audio worlds.

  • Ear HustleEar Hustle & Radiotopia

    The relationships and routines incarceration changes.

  • Radio AmbulanteMy Cultura, Radio Ambulante and iHeartPodcasts

    Spanish-language narrative journalism from across Latin America and Latino life.

  • Lex Fridman PodcastLex Fridman

    Technical questions, human stakes, room to think.

  • Search Engine (PJ Vogt)PJ Vogt

    A question, chased until it gives up its story.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Line Up: The Gasoline Bandit (EP1178)

    ·36m
  2. 2

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Curse of Kamashek Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1199)

    ·32m
  3. 3

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Sea Legs Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1173)

    ·35m
  4. 4

    The Line Up: The Matthews Murray Mish-Mosh Case (EP1172)

    ·33m
  5. 5

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Crystal Lake Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1185)

    ·39m
  6. 6

    Nick Carter: The Funeral Wreath (EP1170)

    ·33m
  7. 7

    Richard Diamond: The Fifty Thousand Dollar Diamond Heist (EP1196s)

    ·35m
  8. 8

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Sea Legs Matter, Part Five and Manhunt: Story of the Accusing Violin (EP1177)

    ·34m
  9. 9

    The Line Up: Good Enough to Eat (EP1202)

    ·39m
  10. 10

    Casebook of Gregory Hood: Death from The Red Capsule (EP1198)

    ·39m
  11. 11

    Casebook of Gregory Hood: South of the Border (EP1192)

    ·34m
  12. 12

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Curse of Kamashek Matter, Part Five and Clue of the Masked Murderer (EP1201)

    ·42m
  13. 13

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Alder Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1179)

    ·30m
  14. 14

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Sea Legs Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1175)

    ·31m
  15. 15

    The Line Up: The Modern Sounds Case (EP1166)

    ·33m
  16. 16

    Casebook of Gregory Hood: Murder in Celluloid (EP1180)

    ·31m
  17. 17

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Kranesburg Matter, Parts Two and Three (EP1193)

    ·34m
  18. 18

    Nick Carter: Murder in a Decanter (EP1200)

    ·35m
  19. 19

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: Curse of Kamashek Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1197)

    ·34m
  20. 20

    Nick Carter: Murder Goes to College (EP1194)

    ·39m
  21. 21

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Kranesburg Matter, Parts 1 and 1A (EP1191)

    ·33m
  22. 22

    Nick Carter: Death Plays the Lead (EP1188)

    ·36m
  23. 23

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Crystal Lake Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1187)

    ·33m
  24. 24

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Open Town Matter, Part Five and Kudos for Khan (PT 4) (EP1171)

    ·32m
  25. 25

    Nick Carter: Murder in the Night (EP1182)

    ·33m
  26. 26

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Crystal Lake Matter, Part Five and Manhunt: The Clue of the Red Thread (EP1189)

    ·36m
  27. 27

    The Line Up: Two Tough Thugs (EP1184)

    ·32m
  28. 28

    The Line Up: Once Upon a Snow Plow (EP1196)

    ·32m
  29. 29

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Kranesburg Matter, Part Four and Five (EP1195)

    ·37m
  30. 30

    The Line Up: The Buggered Bunco Boys (EP1160)

    Hidden gem

    ["The Lineup: The Buggered Bunco Boys follows Lieutenant Ben Guthrie and Sergeant Pete Cogger as they trace a con game built around casualty lists and cheap condolence gifts.", "Adam Graham opens from Boise, Idaho, identifies the show as Great Detectives of Old Time Radio, and frames the broadcast before the drama begins.", "Mrs.

    ·32m·2 clips
  31. 31

    The Line Up: Cowardly Castro (EP1190)

    Hidden gem

    Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents a rehearsal recording of The Line Up's "Cowardly Castro," dated January 1, 1953 for a broadcast that aired on January 2, 1953.

    ·32m·2 clips
  32. 32

    Nick Carter: Death in the Pool (EP1176)

    Hidden gem

    Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents Nick Carter: Death in the Pool, a Gray Bar apartment murder built around Arthur Reeves' body in a lily pool.

    ·37m·3 clips
  33. 33

    Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Derringer Society (EP1186)

    Hidden gem

    The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio episode Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Derringer Society centers on Julia Hayes, who tells the Derringer Society she predicted the Hindenburg disaster and Alfred Chester's death at 11.15.

    ·34m·3 clips
  34. 34

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Alder Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1181)

    Hidden gem

    Adam Graham opens Great Detectives of Old Time Radio from Boise, Idaho, then introduces Bob Bailey as Johnny Dollar in "The Alder Matter, Parts Three and Four." In Caracas, Johnny presses Billy Alder about the earlier shooting, but Alder keeps repeating that he only wants protection and will not explain who threatened him.

    ·32m·2 clips
  35. 35

    Rocky Jordan: Man from Damascus (EP1190s)

    Hidden gem

    Rocky Jordan’s “Man from Damascus,” dated June 12, 1949, sends the Cairo cafe owner a 1,000-pound advance and an appointment at 16 Sharia El Nazar.

    ·37m·2 clips
  36. 36

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Alder Matter, Part Five and Manhunt: The Crystal Clue (EP1183)

    Johnny Dollar fakes a $309.80 plane ticket to Hartford to force the hands of Billy Alder's circle in Part Five of "The Alder Matter," ending with an expense total of $833.14.

    ·31m·2 clips
  37. 37

    Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Adventure of the Beeswax Candle (EP1174)

    Hidden gem

    In “The Adventure of the Beeswax Candle,” Gregory Hood investigates Mary Taylor’s disappearance in the foggy Berkeley Hills.

    ·33m·2 clips
  38. 38

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Open Town Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1169)

    Johnny Dollar keeps after Joe Cleary, the drunken reporter on the Greensport Daily Herald.

    Feb 18, 2026·29m·2 clips
  39. 39

    The Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Murder of Gregory Hood (EP1168)

    Gregory Hood and his companions drive into a tense standoff, with Carter already in the doorway and Sherry told to drop down in the back seat if shooting starts.

    Feb 17, 2026·32m·2 clips
  40. 40

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Open Town Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1167)

    The case starts with a dead police chief, a $50,000 policy, and a widow who filed quickly after the death.

    Feb 16, 2026·32m·2 clips
  41. 41

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Capetown Matter, Part Five and Kudos for Khan (PT 3) (EP1165)

    Johnny Dollar wraps up the Star of Cape Town matter.

    Feb 13, 2026·33m·3 clips
  42. 42

    Nick Carter: Murder on Mad Mountain (EP1164)

    Nick Carter is on a train buried in deep snow and starts teasing out a murder hidden inside the whole mess.

    Feb 12, 2026·33m·3 clips
  43. 43

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Capetown Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1163)

    The Star of Cape Town Matter keeps rolling as Johnny Dollar trails the diamond toward the Southern Empress.

    Feb 11, 2026·31m·2 clips
  44. 44

    The Casebook of the Gregory Hood: The Black Museum (EP1162)

    Gregory Hood starts the night in dry company, trading sharp remarks with Sandy after a late round of social calls.

    Feb 10, 2026·33m·3 clips
  45. 45

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Capetown Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1161)

    Johnny Dollar is brought in after the Star of Cape Town, a diamond about the size of a jumbo olive, turns into an insurance problem for Tri-Eastern Indemnity.

    Feb 9, 2026·31m·2 clips
  46. 46

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Midas Touch Matter, Part Five and Kudos for Khan (PT 2) (EP1159)

    Johnny Dollar gets pulled back into the Modest Touch matter, where three million dollars in insurance and a murder claim keep the case burning.

    Feb 6, 2026·31m·2 clips
  47. 47

    Nick Carter: The Slingshot Murder (EP1158)

    Nick Carter is badly wounded, but he still insists on going back to the robbery scene.

    Feb 5, 2026·32m·2 clips
  48. 48

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Midas Touch Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1157)

    Johnny checks on Hardlock Dennis in the hospital.

    Feb 4, 2026·28m·2 clips
  49. 49

    The Casebook of Gregory Hood: The Three Silver Pesos (EP1156)

    Gregory Hood and Sandy get pulled into a murder case that keeps changing shape.

    Feb 3, 2026·33m·3 clips
  50. 50

    Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Midas Touch Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1155)

    Johnny Dollar is taken to Arizona to look into The Modest Touch Matter.

    Feb 2, 2026·31m·2 clips