Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas · Adam Graham|Old Time Radio Detective Host

The Line Up: Cowardly Castro (EP1190)

·32 min·2 clips
Castro is arrested after Harrison's testimony points Guthrie straight at the beating.
1. Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents a rehearsal recording of The Line Up's "Cowardly Castro," dated January 1, 1953, for an episode that aired on January 2, 1953. 2. Adam Graham hosts the wraparound from Boise, Idaho, identifies the episode as a rehearsal, and tells listeners the version is bare-bones without the usual music. 3. The episode exists to show Sergeant Pete Cogger running a numbered police lineup while Lieutenant Guthrie and Sergeant Cargan question suspects for the Younger robbery case. 4. The first suspect, Robert Fuller, admits grand theft auto after being asked where he lived, where he came from, and what car he was driving. 5. Albert Wilson says he and Jimmy Swain wanted money to buy a car, then explains that both men have wives and were never in trouble before. 6. Charles Cole, also called Leonard Colton and Curly Colby, turns a battery charge into a joke about a fly, a pool cue, and a bald head. 7. Frank Castro, charged "open charge," tells Guthrie he has been in Florida and Vegas and says he made "what your salary would be for a couple of years." 8. Castro's confrontation with Guthrie turns openly hostile when he says, "Guys like you never have scared me," and refuses to be pushed around. 9. Guthrie and Cargan then connect Castro to the Younger case through Vern Harrison, the sixty-three-year-old janitor with an Indiana burglary record. 10. Harrison says he and his wife bought a house last year, have been saving every nickel, and need the job to stay afloat. 11. Harrison admits he saw Frank Castro and Anthony Minnelli a couple of weeks earlier and finally stops denying that he gave them information about Younger. 12. He says Castro threatened him and warned that he would make sure Harrison kept quiet. 13. Mrs. Harrison confirms that Vern knew Castro and Minnelli from back home and mentions that he had seen them at wrestling matches. 14. Frances Longworth gives Minnelli an alibi for the night of the robbery, saying he stayed at her place watching television until about 1:00 a.m. 15. Guthrie notes that nobody else in the building saw Minnelli come or go, so the alibi stays weak. 16. Minnelli eventually admits Castro and Harrison met at the wrestling matches and gives up Castro's East Hendrick apartment address when pressure builds. 17. The recording preserves the stage business, including audience-room instructions, prisoner numbers, and Cogger's repeated warnings to identify suspects by number. 18. The sound is stark and procedural, with long stretches of spoken setup, clipped interrogation, and little performance ornament beyond the dialogue. 19. Old-time-radio fans who like police lineups and hardboiled exchanges. 20. Listeners wanting polished sound design or a tidy standalone mystery.

As heard by us

A rehearsal-room interrogation turns the Younger diamond robbery into a pressure test for one worried employee.

A rehearsal recording frames the Younger diamond robbery as a tense house call, with detectives leaning on employees and testing each reply for the possibility of inside help. Mr.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a rehearsal-room glimpse of the Younger diamond robbery, a worried employee trying to protect his steady job, and two old Indiana prison contacts now in town.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on