Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas · Adam Graham|Old Time Radio Detective Host

Nick Carter: Death in the Pool (EP1176)

·37 min·3 clips
Nick traps Sally Reeves with a clothing bill and a furrier's knife photo.
1. Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents Nick Carter: Death in the Pool, a fur-coat murder story set at the Gray Bar apartment lily pool. 2. Adam Graham hosts from Boise, Idaho, while Lon Clark voices Nick Carter, Helen Choate voices Patsy, and Ken Powell closes the Mutual broadcast. 3. The episode asks whether a dead man in a pool, a missing mink coat, and a fur-shop connection all point to one case. 4. Nick and Patsy bring Sally Reeves home after she drinks too much and starts wobbling near the lily pool. 5. Arthur Reeves is discovered in the pool with a knife between his shoulder blades, and Lieutenant Riley immediately treats Sally as the main suspect. 6. Riley leans on Sally's divorce, the $500 monthly alimony, and Arthur Reeves' $50,000 insurance policy in her favor. 7. He also notes that Reeves left his fur shop at about 8:30 to see Sally and never came back. 8. Nick questions Mr. Workman, Reeves' partner, who says the missing man was trying to make ends meet and did not carry partnership insurance. 9. Patsy then opens the next clue when a masked man enters Sally's apartment and orders her to hand over the fur coat. 10. Nick traces that coat to Fishbone Brothers, Perry Long, and a reported theft involving Mrs. Jackson Moody of Boston. 11. Moe identifies the coat's blue mark and stitching as evidence that the garment came through a specific fur trade chain. 12. Nick also notices a scratched cheek on Workman and a package of fur scraps addressed to San Francisco. 13. The furrier's knife at the murder scene becomes the key object because it matches the tools used in the shop. 14. Nick keeps separating the fur-theft trail from Riley's first theory, which prevents the investigation from hardening too early. 15. A postmarked clothing bill and an old tea-party photo give Nick a way to test Sally's story about what happened that night. 16. The strongest moments come from Nick laying out small physical clues, then forcing each suspect to react in front of Riley. 17. The performance is brisk and dialogue-heavy, with Patsy pushing hard and Riley arguing from the evidence he has. 18. Nick moves the format between the apartment-house murder scene, the fur shop, and the final detective briefing. 19. Listeners who like classic radio mysteries, clue chains, and Nick Carter banter will get the most out of it. 20. Listeners who want fast modern editing or no Linax sponsor breaks may skip it.

As heard by us

A costly mink coat gives Nick Carter a hands-on path into a murder mystery.

A costly mink coat gives Nick Carter a pleasingly concrete way into the murder case. With assistant Betsy Bowen alongside him, Carter brings the garment to Moe, whose cutting into the lining and stitches turns craft knowledge into detection.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You can trail an expensive mink coat with Nick Carter as a tiny blue mark, a fur expert, and one counter knife start narrowing the mystery.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on