Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas · Adam Graham|Old Time Radio Detective Host

Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Star of Capetown Matter, Parts One and Two (EP1161)

February 9, 2026·31 min·2 clips
Johnny discovers Forbes stabbed to death and the Star of Cape Town diamond missing.
Johnny Dollar gets pulled into the Star of Cape Town matter when Joe McNabb asks him to take a look at the diamond. It is not just valuable; it is a stone about the size of a jumbo olive, the kind of thing that makes a case feel bigger the moment it is mentioned. The story shifts into a party atmosphere, where Forbes shows off the diamond and the room starts to change around it. Agatha watches with firm, cool control. Helen stays close to Forbes. Sheila hangs back and spends much of the evening quietly drinking. Johnny keeps moving through the gathering and reading the people in it. The evening has the feel of a polished social event, but the tension underneath it keeps building. Johnny and Sheila exchange a line about riding the merry-go-round long enough that standing on solid ground no longer feels normal. It is the kind of remark that sounds casual until the room turns serious. Agatha eventually tells Forbes to put the diamond away, and he takes it back to his room. The party goes on. Forbes and Helen dance, then go out onto the terrace. Sheila turns away and stays with her drink. Johnny later goes back to the bar, but the bartender is gone and the room is thinning out. When Johnny realizes Forbes has been missing for ten or fifteen minutes, he checks the terrace and then the bedroom. Forbes is on the floor, dead from a knife wound low under the ribs. The case holding the Star of Cape Town is open and empty. From there, the mystery narrows into a suspect hunt. Johnny speaks with the lieutenant and learns the diamond is still missing. When asked about suspects, the lieutenant says there are many, and Johnny ends up counting himself among them. That leaves the case where old-time radio mysteries often like to live: one dead man, one missing diamond, and a room full of people with something to hide. The episode moves through dialogue, entrances, exits, and careful attention to who is in the room and who is not. Its pace is brisk, and the clues come through conversation rather than explanation. At the same time, the emotional material stays mostly under the surface. The feelings are there, but they are handled through tone, posture, and implication more than deep confession. That keeps the story moving, even if the human fallout remains secondary to the puzzle. The murder lands hard, but the investigation stays controlled and procedural. Johnny probes, checks, and rechecks the situation while the missing diamond and the body become parts of the same problem. The story is less about spectacle than about how quickly a polished social scene can crack once money, vanity, and jealousy start pulling in different directions.

As heard by us

A diamond case turns into a brisk murder mystery with dry wit, sharp pressure, and a room full of suspects.

A diamond the size of a jumbo olive sets the case in motion, and the evening ends in murder, with the star of Cape Town missing from its case.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A diamond, a party, and a murder, with Johnny Dollar walking into all three.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on