Great Detectives of Old Time Radio Volume 2|Mystery Audio Dramas · Adam Graham|Old Time Radio Detective Host

Yours Truly Johnny Dollar: The Open Town Matter, Parts Three and Four (EP1169)

February 18, 2026·29 min·2 clips
Marty Blake orders Johnny Dollar out after he suggests she's involved in her husband's death and knows where Shorty Wells is.
Johnny Dollar goes looking for Joe Cleary. The drunken reporter for the Greensport Daily Herald is not at home, so Johnny calls his paper, gets a list of hangouts, and keeps moving through them until he finds him on a third martini. Joe acts like a man who has already seen too much of the town and too much of the bottle. He points Johnny toward Marty, the woman who hates champagne but always orders it because it costs more, and he talks about her as a four-star tramp and an ex-dancer. Joe links Marty to Shorty Wells, says she used to be Shorty's girl, and says Ed Blake took her away from him. That is enough to make Shorty sound like a man who had reason to threaten Blake, and Joe does not pretend the police in Greensport handled the case well. Some of them are crooked. The rest of them are useless. He gives Johnny the ugly detail that turns the homicide into a mess: Ed Blake was shot with his own gun. The police first took the gun beside the body as proof that he had fired it in a shootout, and only later realized the weapon had been used on him instead. Johnny keeps pressing. He asks whether Shorty Wells and Marty could have planned the thing together, and Joe answers that he would not put anything past that dame. Then he drops the real confession. He does not hate Marty. He says he is in love with her, that he always will be, and that she was his girl before she met Shorty Wells. That confession changes the room. The case is still about a dead man and a gun, but now it also carries jealousy, old possession, and a reporter trying to hold himself together long enough to say what he knows. Joe reaches Johnny again on another phone and says he was trying to get all the dope that way. The exchange keeps the story in motion, with calls cutting across accusations and every answer opening onto another question. Bars, phones, and grudges do most of the work here, and the story keeps moving on quick talk and sharp interruptions. It suits listeners who like old radio detectives at full speed, with a hard edge and just enough romance to make the motive sting.

As heard by us

A barroom-driven Johnny Dollar story where grudges, a badly handled shooting, and Joe Cleary's attachment to Marty keep the suspicion tight.

The Open Town Matter keeps Johnny Dollar on a tense, talk-heavy trail in Greensport, where Joe Cleary, a drunken reporter for the Greensport Daily Herald, comes into focus after Johnny tracks him down through his hangouts and finds him on his third martini.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A bar crawl, a dead man, and one reporter who should never be left alone with a martini.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on