
Horror, odd people, stranger choices.
The gist
Weird but Wonderful follows strange behavior wherever it surfaces: hotel-room horror stories, conspiracy thinking, fragile egos, self-optimization, and slasher-film logic. James keeps the pace casual and sharp, moving from jokes to genuine unease without sanding off the weirdness.
PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
About Weird but Wonderful
Weird but Wonderful sits at the intersection of horror fandom, internet oddities, and real-world strangeness. It is built around the idea that people are rarely as normal as they believe, then tests that idea through cases, stories, and film talk. James is a recurring named voice in its episodes, and the show follows his instinct for the uncomfortable detail. One week that may mean urban legends with grim real-life counterparts. Another week it may mean self-optimization communities, conspiracy thinking, missing-person weirdness, or a news story about a petty argument becoming wildly disproportionate. The show is loose and conversational. It can be sharp. It can be silly. It often lets a joke run until it becomes part of the episode’s texture, then pivots into a genuine question about fear, narcissism, social pressure, or obsession. Horror movies are not just decoration here. The Survive the Fright episodes on Scream and Scream 3 turn slasher films into survival puzzles, character autopsies, and comedy setups. James talks about Wes Craven, Kevin Williamson, Aaron Kruger, David Arquette, Neve Campbell, Courtney Cox, Leif Schreiber, Kelly Rutherford, Patrick Dempsey, Matthew Lillard, and Rob Zombie where the films and references bring them into the conversation. The tone is irreverent, but the curiosity is real. A hotel smell becomes a lesson in checking under the bed. A mid-afternoon nap in Scream becomes a study in how horror steals safety from familiar places. A conspiracy anecdote becomes a way to notice how people sometimes choose the most elaborate explanation available. The show works best for listeners who like a crooked path: story, riff, aside, horror reference, then a sudden clean hit of insight. It is less formal criticism than a running field guide to odd human choices. That looseness is the appeal. The episodes feel like being pulled through a stack of strange tabs by someone who is amused, alarmed, and still taking notes.
Made for: For listeners who like horror criticism with comic detours, real-life urban legends, internet oddities, and stories about people behaving badly or bizarrely. Best suited to an audience comfortable with dark subject matter handled through blunt humor.
What sets it apart: The show does not stay in one lane: Scream survival logic, body-hacking absurdity, conspiracy anecdotes, and grim hotel-room cases can all sit in the same feed. Its edge comes from treating the funny parts and the frightening parts as connected rather than separate.
In their own words
A journey into the minds of strange people doing strange things.
Why you'd press play
Check the backseat; James may have you checking under the bed, too.
Press play if you want
- to hear a self-described horror coward trade Scream survival advice with James
- an actual body-under-the-bed case met with horror, disbelief, and a few jokes
Talks about
Podcasts like Weird but Wonderful
Stay DoomedBad media, carefully exhumed.
Screen DraftsFilm lists with rules, vetoes, and taste.
And the Runner-Up IsOscar history from the almost-winners' side.
Post-MovieBoston repertory listings with critic-banter momentum.
The AwardsWatch PodcastOscar math meets cinephile argument.
Watch With Jen™Long conversations about the movies worth finding.
Episodes
- 1
What's Going Wrong With Men?
Hidden gemJames opens Weird but Wonderful by framing "What's Going Wrong With Men?" around r/cum bigger loads, a Reddit community with 47,000 members chasing semen-volume optimization.
Jan 20, 2026·43m·3 clips - 2
Terrifying Urban Legends That Actually Happened
Hidden gem["Weird but Wonderful opens with a 1999 Atlantic City case in which a German couple slept on a mattress containing Saul Hernandez's body at the Burgundy Motor Inn.", "James connects that story to the Bunnyman Bridge reports in Fairfax County, where Brian A.
Oct 30, 2025·57m·4 clips - 3
Survive The Fright: Scream 4 (2011)
Oct 23, 2025·2h 3m - 4
Survive The Fright: Scream 3 (2000)
["Weird but Wonderful's Survive The Fright episode on Scream 3 (2000) opens with David and James calling the sequel 'half-baked' and 'painfully goofy' while naming Wes Craven, Kevin Williamson, and the returning cast.", "Their summary follows Cotton Weary's phone call, the beachside California murder, and the Stab 3 lot connection to Maureen Prescott, which pulls Gale Weathers and Detective Kincaid into Hollywood.", "The episode spends much of its energy on Sidney's off-grid life as a crisis counsellor, the voice-changer gadget, and the ghost-mom hallucinations that the hosts think blur dream logic and real threat.", "James and David also dig into the reported pre-Columbine Stu-centered script, arguing that the rewrite explains why Scream 3 feels more interesting on paper than on screen."]
Oct 21, 2025·1h 51m·5 clips - 5
Survive The Fright: Scream 2 (1997)
Oct 19, 2025·2h 4m - 6
Survive The Fright: Scream (1996)
Hidden gemWeird but Wonderful's Survive the Fright episode centers on Wes Craven's Scream (1996), with James as the horror expert and David as the lifelong spooky-film coward.
Oct 7, 2025·1h 26m·5 clips - 7
The science of conspiracies, cool & creativity
Hidden gem["James opens with a delivery-worker story about LA wildfires, DARPA, sky lasers, and underground tunnels, then uses it to frame a conversation about strange belief systems.", "He turns to a 12-country coolness study with nearly 6,000 participants and says the key traits are extroversion, hedonism, adventure, openness, power, and autonomy, with Keanu Reeves as his example.", "The episode then summarizes two longitudinal conspiracy studies from Australia, New Zealand, the UK, and Germany showing that one conspiracy belief can slightly nudge later belief in others.", "It closes with a UC Merced creativity paper from Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, where six PhD-level mathematicians became less predictable before an 'aha' moment."]
Sep 2, 2025·34m·2 clips - 8
A Tale of 3 Crash Outs
The host discusses three bizarre news stories, starting with a nursing home fight over stolen Vienna sausages.
Jul 18, 2025·27m - 9
Christmas Chaos: A Christmas Day Special
Dec 24, 2024·1h 32m - 10
Doritos Make Mice Invisible & Cheaters Regret Nothing
Sep 30, 2024·43m - 11
Gone without a trace: Missing man, missing skull
A true crime podcast episode discussing a mysterious case of a missing man and a missing skull.
Sep 10, 2024·46m - 12
Bigfoot blamed for murder
Jul 21, 2024·34m - 13
Nude Heroes, Booty Brewin’ and the 2025 Apocalypse
Jul 16, 2024·33m - 14
Kidnapped by a witch
May 25, 2024·28m - 15
Pokémon Gangsters & The Candy Crush Cleric
May 13, 2024·30m - 16
FOMO no mo and how to stop saying “Yes”
The host rants about Blumhouse Productions' decline in horror movie quality, citing being duped by marketing and the film 'Imaginary'.
Apr 15, 2024·46m - 17
Crypto Kingpins, Feet for Fraud & the Folk Singing Assassin
Mar 29, 2024·33m - 18
Love in the age of artificial intelligence
Mar 13, 2024·57m - 19
You've got a secret admirer
Feb 29, 2024·1h 27m - 20
We've lost control of the animals
Feb 20, 2024·44m - 21
What's happening with men?
A podcast host discusses the state of men in 2024, including a study about men becoming less aggressive when they smell women's tears.
Feb 13, 2024·42m - 22
Is America okay? Also, there's an appendage detachment in this one
Feb 6, 2024·47m - 23
Spoiler Alert: Why We Secretly Love to Know the Ending
Feb 6, 2024·37m - 24
The Bouncy Castle Kingpin & Other Criminal Masterminds
Jan 21, 2024·51m - 25
The Unseen Legal Consequences of Emojis
Jan 19, 2024·33m - 26
A Year in Review: The Searches That Defined 2023
The hosts analyze Pornhub's 2023 year-in-review data to understand societal trends and human behavior.
Jan 9, 2024·48m - 27
Sadfishing: Why We Seek Negative Attention Online
Aug 24, 2023·26m - 28
YouTube Mobsters & Killing The Internet
Aug 1, 2023·25m - 29
Won't Somebody Please Think of the Children
May 9, 2023·28m - 30
Fart Fuelled Rage
Apr 14, 2023·39m - 31
Why Gossip is Good: The Social Bonding Tool We’ve Misunderstood
Mar 15, 2023·30m - 32
Crabby Daddy's Revenge: A Tale of Violence, Hot Chicken and Suds Drugs
Feb 22, 2023·34m - 33
Death By Selfie
Apr 26, 2021·32m - 34
Trash so good you'll kill for it
Feb 2, 2021·26m - 35
Kinky Communities & Sus Sword Owners
Aug 3, 2020·42m - 36
Teens Run Wild: The Death of the Golf & Games Family
Jul 27, 2020·30m - 37
The One Where I Expose My Soul
Jul 7, 2020·37m - 38
I've Done A Number On Myself
Jun 24, 2020·35m - 39
Brand Deals for Dealers
Jun 2, 2020·33m - 40
The Great Snack Debate
May 26, 2020·1h 6m - 41
Mid-Cov Solutions To Mid-Cov Problems
May 19, 2020·40m - 42
The $517,000 Game of Rock Paper Scissors
May 8, 2020·52m - 43
The Ultimate Way To Make Money, Catch Liars And Hide
Apr 29, 2020·55m - 44
Adapting to a New Way of Life
Apr 21, 2020·36m - 45
It's Not Yours To Give Away!
Apr 15, 2020·55m - 46
No Takesy Backsies and the Weird Wingman
Apr 9, 2020·45m - 47
Why It's So Easy To Rob Your House
Mar 27, 2020·31m - 48
My 43 year old boyfriend's failure to launch
Mar 18, 2020·59m - 49
The Remarkable Art of The Gradual Ghost
Mar 10, 2020·32m - 50
New study finds rich people are trash
Mar 3, 2020·32m