They Mostly Podcast at Night
257 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
The pod returns to live again! Chaos takes you through a different horror movie every episode with additional analysis, info, and trivia! Episodes release every other Thursday!
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Detailed plot talk, production trivia, and unruly humor give horror fans lively company after the credits.
They Mostly Podcast at Night turns horror-movie reviews into detailed guided replays, with Chaos moving through plot beats, production trivia, cast context, and a final rating.
The Changeling's giant cobwebs make Chaos want to meet the spider; you may want the lights on.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A sharp cane and a filthy pool give this sorority-house episode room for loose, cheerful chaos.
The House on Sorority Row gives the episode a clean set of targets: the water bed, the sharp-tipped cane, and a sorority house pool packed with green water, debris, and an old tire. The hosts follow Vicky's anger at Mrs.
A loose, late-night review where the phone book becomes the strangest clue.
Episode 248 treats He Never Died as late-night movie talk with a search bar left open beside it. The discussion tracks a man moving through a spare early routine: church, a cafe, a daughter at the door, thugs asking about Jeremy, a gun tossed away, and Jillian pushing him into a…
A loose horror review where infection rules, grim practicalities, and a sharp Tremors detour carry the conversation.
Cargo gives this horror review a sturdy problem to pick apart: an infection starts a 48-hour countdown, a trip to a mainland hospital becomes the goal, and the group keeps testing what the movie's survival rules actually mean.
A sharp body-horror debate finds Rabid's weird charm in an armpit stinger, Marilyn Chambers' vulnerability, and one host's near-walkout.
Rabid turns into a compact test of horror patience: how long can someone look at an armpit stinger and still take the movie on its own terms? The review moves from one host almost giving up on the film, thrown by the idea that skin grafts could address internal injuries, into a…
A haunted-house review where alarms, money worries, and host-on-host suspicion keep setting each other off.
The hosts frame their Insidious review as a wary, funny argument over whether the haunting can hold up under their own suspicion. They follow the ill family member sent home by doctors with a hospital bed, beeping machines, and a nurse, then keep circling the household alarm,…
A lively recap that keeps the banter moving through an increasingly over-the-top trap story.
Escape Room gives They Mostly Podcast at Night a good excuse to lean into the kind of friendly chaos it does best. The recap stays strongest when the hosts track the puzzle logic, follow each room's trick, and react to the escalating nonsense without trying to force a bigger…
Episode 247 turns sidetracks and argument into the shape of the review.
Episode 247, The Pale Blue Eye, spends much of its run drifting through Titanic arguments, door logic, and other recurring bits before circling back to the movie. That looseness seems intentional.
A banter-first Day Shift discussion that leans into vampire-sunscreen chaos.
This episode starts out in a loose, banter-heavy register, with jokes and swearing carrying most of the early stretch before the conversation settles on Day Shift.
Mike Muncer and a different guest dissect two horror films per episode, by subgenre.
Hosts Carnage and Chaos review the 2022 Hellraiser reboot, discussing its plot, characters, and Cenobite lore.
They Mostly Podcast at Night episode 257 covers Insidious, the 2010 PG-13 horror film that the hosts describe as “a pile of crap” while still walking through its plot beat by beat.
They Mostly Podcast at Night covers David Cronenberg’s Rabid (1977), an hour-and-31-minute horror movie that the hosts say has a 6.3 IMDb score, a 79% Tomato Meter, and a 46% audience score.
They Mostly Podcast at Night opens with the hosts bickering before they settle on Cocaine Bear.
Chaos and Carnage start with sun allergy misery.
They Mostly Podcast at Night opens Episode 261 with a sharp, hostile little riff on going "for the throat" before settling into Day Shift.
In episode 248 of They Mostly Podcast at Night, hosts Chaos and Carnage review the 2015 horror movie 'He Never Died,' starring Henry Rollins as a vampire cannibal.
The hosts discuss their experiences at MonsterFest, including bizarre Bigfoot theories and crowded podcast recordings, before reviewing Alfred Hitchcock's classic horror film The Birds, covering its cast, plot, and behind-the-scenes controversies.
In this episode, hosts Chaos and Carnage review the 1998 found footage horror film The Last Broadcast, discussing its low-budget production, historical significance, and confusing plot.
Chaos and Carnage review the 1996 horror film 'From Dusk Till Dawn', discussing its blend of crime thriller and vampire elements, iconic scenes like Salma Hayek's snake dance, and quirky trivia.
Hosts Chaos and Carnage review the Spanish horror film 'Don't Listen (Voces)', discussing its plot involving a family haunted by voices and a tragic twist where the father drowns his son.
They Mostly Podcast at Night reviews Death Note (2017) and opens with Chaos and Carnage comparing the movie to Final Destination, Donnie Darko, and Mean Girls before digging into why the film split fans.
Chaos and Carnage come in hot.
They Mostly Podcast at Night opens with a joke about whether anyone would even hear them podcast in a huge city.
The episode opens on a Sunday recording.
They Mostly Podcast at Night starts by wandering off course right away.
Episode 267 is the show's goodbye lap.
Chaos and Carnage review the 1982 slasher film The House on Sorority Row, analyzing a prank-gone-wrong narrative that leads to house mother's accidental death and subsequent murders.
The hosts open by joking that the podcast itself has turned into an escape room, with threats, timers, and a whole clue web aimed at the listener.
Hosts Chaos and Carnage review the horror movie M3GAN, discussing its plot, characters, and their thoughts on the PG-13 rating.
Mostly Podcast at Night episode 264, “Orca,” starts with Chaos and Carnage arguing over a misspelled title and then quickly turns into a long recap of the 1977 PG film Orca.
The host Chaos returns for an episode of Mostly Podcast at Night reviewing the 1980 Canadian horror-mystery film The Changeling, starring George C.
They Mostly Podcast at Night reviews Smile, a 115-minute, R-rated horror film with Sosie Bacon as Rose and Cal Penn as Dr.
They Mostly Podcast at Night reviews Hell Baby, a 2013 R-rated horror-comedy that they say has an IMDb 4.9, a 33% Tomatometer, and a 27% audience score.
They Mostly Podcast at Night covers The Rental, the 2020 horror film with an R rating, a 5.7 IMDb score, a 74% Rotten Tomatoes critics score, and a 43% audience score.