Proof: A True Crime Podcast

This update episode follows the wrongful conviction case of Jake Silva, convicted for the murder of Renee Ramos 25 years ago.

In this Sidebar episode, hosts Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis discuss episode 14 of Proof's second season, focusing on witness testimonies and rumors in the Renee Ramos murder case.

In this episode, hosts Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis investigate the murder of Earl O'Byrne, focusing on key witness Stacey's changing testimony and the Kalamazoo cold case team's methods.

Hosts Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis reinvestigate the murder of Earl O'Byrne, focusing on overlooked suspects like employee James Long and alternate suspect Alan Nutter, while uncovering potential police misconduct in related cold cases.

The hosts discuss Episode 5 of Proof, focusing on the murder case against Scott Baldwin, where key evidence like bank bags was mishandled and never actually stolen, undermining the prosecution's theft motive.

Proof: A True Crime Podcast investigates the Kalamazoo cold case unit's handling of the Polderman triple homicide — three elderly people murdered in their home, unsolved for seven years.

Proof: A True Crime Podcast opens Season 3, "Murder at the Bike Shop," with Scott Baldwin’s release from Lakeland Prison in Coldwater, Michigan, after 25 years in prison and a terminal prostate cancer diagnosis.

This sidebar closes the season.

Reporters examining Scott Baldwin's 1988 conviction for the murder of Earl O'Byrne at a Kalamazoo bike shop systematically dissect the key witness accounts used against him.

Proof: A True Crime Podcast closes Season 2, Murder at the Warehouse, by revisiting Renee's death, the June 5, 2000 date on her headstone, and the 24th year since her friends last saw her alive.

This sidebar episode analyzes recent interviews with key figures in an ongoing murder investigation, focusing on contradictory statements from Tim Fisher about leaving town after the victim's death and Julie's conflicting accounts about rumors surrounding her house.

This episode provides an update on Jake Silva's wrongful conviction case, focusing on a key court hearing where the DA agrees not to oppose DNA testing on recently rediscovered evidence.

The hosts discuss overlooked tips in Scott's wrongful conviction case, including sightings of a car at the bike shop the morning of the murder, which point to employee James Long as a potential suspect.

This sidebar episode answers listener questions about the murder investigation at Earl O'Byrne's bike shop, covering topics like his hoarding habits, police oversights with evidence, and mysterious elements like a secret resident in the buildings.

Proof: A True Crime Podcast Season 3, Episode 2, 'Kalamazoo Cycle,' centers on the June 3, 1988 killing of 83-year-old Earl O'Byrne inside his Kalamazoo bike shop.

The team has spent more than a year digging through Jake's case and talking to every witness they can track down.

Proof turns its focus to Scott's conviction and the evidence that may have been mishandled around it.

Detective Hecht sets the date at 12-8-09 and frames the cold case homicide involving Earl O'Byrne.

Proof returns to Rome, Georgia.

This sidebar episode discusses Season 3, Episode 4 of Proof, focusing on Scott's murder case, including evidence like Missy Jarzma's statement about a bloody stick and the reliability of witness memory.

The Proof team investigates the murder of Earl O'Byrne at a Kalamazoo bike shop, focusing on James Long, the last person to see O'Byrne alive, who resembles the man seen outside the shop.

Tim Fisher's interview becomes the center of Proof: A True Crime Podcast's "Murder at the Warehouse | Ep.

Proof Sidebar 3 centers on Stacey’s account in the Scott O’Byrne case, including her claim that Scott came through a basement window and confessed that he killed Earl O’Byrne.

The hosts analyze the wrongful conviction case of Scott Baldwin for a 1988 bike shop murder, focusing on the alternative suspect Alan Nutter.

Jacinda interviews Dr.

This episode investigates Scott Baldwin's murder conviction, focusing on flawed evidence like a spray-painted Jeep and a Bondo stick mistaken for blood.

Hosts Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis reinvestigate the murder of 18-year-old Renee Ramos in Manteca, CA, examining potential wrongful conviction.

A true crime podcast reinvestigating the murder of Renee Ramos, exploring potential wrongful conviction.

A serialized investigation into a potential wrongful conviction in the murder of Renee Ramos.

A serialized investigation into a potential wrongful conviction case, hosted by Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis.

This episode reopens a 38-year-old murder case in Kalamazoo, Michigan, questioning the conviction of Scott Baldwin and the reliability of the cold case team's methods.

A serialized investigation into a potential wrongful conviction case, hosted by Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis.

A serialized investigation into potential wrongful conviction, re-examining the murder of Renee Ramos in Manteca, CA.

A serialized investigation into a potential wrongful conviction in the murder of Renee Ramos.

A true crime podcast reinvestigating the murder of Renee Ramos, examining forensic evidence and potential wrongful conviction.

A serialized investigation into a potential wrongful conviction in the murder of Renee Ramos.