Proof: A True Crime Podcast · Red Marble Media

Murder at the Bike Shop | Ep. 6 – The Boogeyman

·1 hr 1 min·8 clips

Detective Hecht places the investigation on 12-8-09 and names the cold case through its central loss. Scott Baldwin's 2001 conviction sits in the background as the sort of verdict that, most of the time, would have ended the matter. Instead, Kalamazoo police reopen the murder at the bike shop and take up another round of cold-case work. The investigation feels inherited and still active, not like a neat closed file. Silent-observer tips become one of the main threads. Those tips point toward Alan Nutter and a girlfriend connected to him around the time of the murder. Renee is interviewed directly and denies being a getaway driver or knowing anything about the crime. She says she would have spoken up if she had information and that she was not worried about saying something once Alan went to jail. The detectives press her on statements they believe she made to other people, but she pushes back and says Alan lied to her like he lied to everybody else. The interview turns on disagreement about what she knew, what she said, and when. That disagreement matters because the tips had mentioned Alan Nutter's girlfriend by name, and investigators had assumed that meant Renee. Renee says Alan was not limited to one girlfriend in 1988 and had several others. That opens the possibility that the woman in the tips was someone else, perhaps the married woman downtown. The search becomes less about one clean answer and more about sorting one relationship from another. It keeps returning to who knew what at the time and who later tried to make sense of it. It also shows how a cold case can stay active long after a conviction. The result is an investigation that feels procedural and unresolved, with the shape of the dispute still in view rather than a tidy conclusion.

As heard by us

A patient cold-case revisit that finds tension in contradictions, not spectacle.

This episode revisits the cold case homicide involving Earl O'Byrne and moves back through the murder at the bike shop, the 2001 conviction of Scott Baldwin, and the 2009 reopening by Kalamazoo police.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a cold case that keeps reopening its own assumptions.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Proof: A True Crime Podcast