Exceptional Leadership: Practical Advice for First Time and Emerging Managers

Mathew Hamilton

62 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

In their own words

Exceptional Leadership is the podcast for first-time and emerging managers who want practical guidance on leading people with confidence. If you’ve recently stepped into leadership and find yourself managing former peers, handling difficult conversations, running meetings, or trying to earn trust from your team - this show is for you. Each fortnight we breakdown the real challenges new managers face: giving feedback, setting expectations, building trust, and dealing with underperformance. Mathew is an experienced people leader and holds an MBA from the Australian Institute of Business.

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Matt Hamilton turns leadership dilemmas, workplace culture and personal resilience into direct guidance for managers learning to carry responsibility.

Matt Hamilton treats leadership as a chain of consequential decisions, from choosing and training new managers to confronting harmful conduct inside an organization.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When a promotion makes you question your outfit, Matt Hamilton has time for that.

Press play if you want

  • to hear imposter syndrome treated as a normal response to a real step up
  • to think harder about giving someone a team before giving them leadership training
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Talks about

Best episodes of Exceptional Leadership: Practical Advice for First Time and Emerging Managers

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

#61 The Two Meetings Every Leader Must Master: 1-on-1s and Team MeetingsMar 8, 2026

An episode about one-to-ones, manager touchpoints, and keeping information moving.

The episode opens with a detour into the show's new website, which gives the first stretch a promotional feel, but the core idea lands clearly: one-to-ones and broader team touchpoints help leaders stay visible and keep information moving.

#60 You’re the Boss — Now What? Managing People Older Than YouFeb 22, 2026

Leadership here means making room for the team's expertise, not pretending to have every answer.

Matt Hamilton keeps the episode focused on a plain but useful leadership problem: a new manager may be expected to lead people who know more than she does. The answer is not to pretend otherwise.

#56 The Fire Within - Turn Adversity into FuelOct 24, 2025

Hardship becomes useful when leadership turns it into discipline.

This episode treats adversity as something leaders can put to work, not just endure, and it asks a plain question: what should someone do when pressure shows up? Matt Hamilton makes the case in a calm, practical talk that moves from perception to resilience.

#51 Imposter Syndrome No More: How to Own Your Success as a New LeaderSep 14, 2025

A steady reset for a leader finding her footing.

This episode takes a familiar new-leader anxiety and treats it with more weight than a neat leadership cliché. After 15 years in a support role, she moves into the executive director job and starts noticing how she looks, speaks, and carries herself once the spotlight lands on…

Podcasts like Exceptional Leadership: Practical Advice for First Time and Emerging Managers

  • The Remote ShowTyler Sellhorn, Matthew Hollingsworth

    Tyler Selhorn interviews remote-work founders and researchers on building distributed team culture.

  • HBR IdeaCastHarvard Business Review

    Management arguments, tested against real companies.

  • Safety WarsJames Poesl

    Safety news with the guardrails off.

  • The Tiberius ShowThe Tiberius Show

    Career day with real curiosity.

  • Defining HospitalityDan Ryan

    Hospitality, explained through the people behind it.

  • The Social HotelierSam-Erik Ruttmann

    Hospitality leadership with a human center.

Episodes

  1. 1

    #40 Positive Disruption: Leading Change Without Waiting for Permission

    ·17m
  2. 2

    #38 Why Critical Thinking Is Every Leader’s Edge in 2025

    ·21m
  3. 3

    #34 Three Tips to Help You Manage Team Budgets Effectively

    ·22m
  4. 4

    #46 Handling Colleague Jealousy After Your Promotion – Turning Tension into Trust

    ·21m
  5. 5

    #62 The Power of Storytelling in Leadership: How Great Organisations Build Belief

    Host Matt Hamilton explores how powerful stories, from national dreams to corporate origin myths, form the foundation of organizational identity and culture.

    Mar 16, 2026·15m·1 clip
  6. 6

    #61 The Two Meetings Every Leader Must Master: 1-on-1s and Team Meetings

    The host provides practical, experience-based guidance for leaders on mastering two essential meeting types: one-on-ones and team meetings.

    Mar 8, 2026·19m·2 clips
  7. 7

    #60 You’re the Boss — Now What? Managing People Older Than You

    Matt Hamilton opens with a familiar management problem.

    Feb 22, 2026·21m·15 clips
  8. 8

    #59 How Michael Jordan and Andy Murray Handle Failure - The Ritual of Elite Performers

    Hidden gem

    Host Matt Hamilton explores how elite athletes like Michael Jordan, Serena Williams, Kobe Bryant, and Andy Murray handle failure, then shares his own structured failure recovery ritual involving written analysis and physical reset.

    Feb 8, 2026·16m·1 clip
  9. 9

    #58 David Goggins’ Cookie Jar Theory: Building Mental Strength & Calm Leadership in Times of Change

    The host explains David Goggins' 'Cookie Jar Theory' as a mental tool for building resilience.

    Jan 16, 2026·16m·1 clip
  10. 10

    #57 2025 in Review: Hiring Smarter, Developing Leaders, Managing Stress & Protecting Culture

    Matt Hamilton closes the year with a catch-up and a leadership reminder for 2026.

    Dec 3, 2025·25m·2 clips
  11. 11

    #56 The Fire Within - Turn Adversity into Fuel

    Matt Hamilton opens by framing adversity as something that forges exceptional leaders.

    Oct 24, 2025·25m·15 clips
  12. 12

    #55 Sometimes You Have to Let Them Fail — A Hard Truth About Leadership

    Host Matt Hamilton explores the difficult leadership principle that sometimes you must allow team members to make mistakes and fail in order for them to learn lessons thoroughly.

    Oct 18, 2025·16m·1 clip
  13. 13

    #54 Direct vs Indirect Leadership: Applying Sun Tzu’s Energy Principle to Business

    Matt Hamilton starts with strategy.

    Oct 5, 2025·21m·1 clip
  14. 14

    #53 Think Before You Leap: Leadership Lessons on Avoiding Impulsivity and Costly Assumptions

    Host Matt Hamilton examines the dangers of impulsivity and making assumptions in leadership, using the costly Quaker Oats acquisition of Snapple as a central case study.

    Sep 29, 2025·18m·1 clip
  15. 15

    #52 How Leaders Can Use the 5 Languages of Appreciation to Inspire and Motivate Teams

    Host Matt Hamilton explores how the concept of 'Five Love Languages' was formally adapted for the workplace by Dr.

    Sep 22, 2025·13m·1 clip
  16. 16

    #51 Imposter Syndrome No More: How to Own Your Success as a New Leader

    Matt Hamilton opens with a Reddit question about a new executive director who feels awkward after moving up from a long support role.

    Sep 14, 2025·23m·20 clips
  17. 17

    #50 Authority vs. Approachability: Finding the Sweet Spot in Leadership

    Sep 7, 2025·15m·1 clip
  18. 18

    #49 From Pay Check to Portfolio: Leading by Example in Personal Finance

    Matt Hamilton opens the episode by making personal finance a leadership issue.

    Sep 1, 2025·29m·5 clips
  19. 19

    #48 Why Salary Isn’t Enough: How Purpose and Meaning Drive Long-Term Employee Retention

    Matt Hamilton opens by pointing to the Hayes Financial Year 25-26 Salary Guide.

    Aug 24, 2025·23m·25 clips
  20. 20

    #47 The Courage to Call It Out: Leadership Lessons from The Emperor’s New Clothes

    Matt Hamilton uses The Emperor's New Clothes as a leadership case study.

    Aug 17, 2025·28m·5 clips
  21. 21

    #45 You Are the Company You Keep: How Great Leaders Guard Against Toxic People and Protect Organisational Health

    This episode explores how leaders should guard against toxic people at both individual and organizational levels, using Oprah Winfrey's story as a case study and offering practical advice on hiring, change management, and maintaining positive energy.

    Aug 3, 2025·23m·2 clips
  22. 22

    #44 The Titan Tragedy: When Leadership Silences Truth

    Matt Hamilton frames this episode around the Ocean Gate tragedy and the leadership failure behind it.

    Jul 27, 2025·29m·2 clips
  23. 23

    #43 Stuck in the Middle? Why Middle Managers Face the Toughest Job in Leadership

    The episode starts with pressure.

    Jul 20, 2025·22m·1 clip
  24. 24

    #42 Why Great Leaders Learn to Fail: Mastering the Art of Failing Forward

    Host Matt Hamilton explores how to reframe failure as essential feedback for growth, using the story of Spanx founder Sarah Blakely as inspiration.

    Jul 13, 2025·17m·1 clip
  25. 25

    #41 When Employees Bypass the Chain of Command

    Matt Hamilton opens by tackling a familiar workplace issue: employees who skip their direct supervisor and take a complaint up the ladder.

    Jul 6, 2025·20m·1 clip
  26. 26

    #39 Overcoming Decision Paralysis in Leadership: How Great Leaders Make Confident Choices

    This episode explores the dangers of decision paralysis in leadership, using Kodak's failure to capitalize on the digital camera invention as a central case study.

    Jun 22, 2025·15m·1 clip
  27. 27

    #37 Why Real Leaders Don’t Do It All

    This episode explores why effective leaders must delegate rather than trying to do everything themselves.

    Jun 8, 2025·16m·1 clip
  28. 28

    #36 Hesitation is Fatal: Take Charge

    Hidden gem

    Host Matt Hamilton uses the infamous Kitty Genovese murder case and a personal hospital story to explain the psychological 'bystander effect,' where people fail to act in emergencies when others are present.

    Jun 1, 2025·17m·1 clip
  29. 29

    #35 Leadership Without The Title

    May 25, 2025·15m·3 clips
  30. 30

    #33 Leadership Approach: Five Focus Points for the First 30 Days

    Host Matt Hamilton outlines five practical focus points for leaders to implement in their first 30 days in a new role or to refresh their current approach.

    May 11, 2025·19m·2 clips
  31. 31

    #32 From Chaos Comes Opportunity

    May 4, 2025·24m
  32. 32

    #31 Build Good Culture to Drive Performance

    Apr 27, 2025·19m
  33. 33

    #30 Self Optimisation

    Apr 20, 2025·17m
  34. 34

    #29 Who Are You?

    Apr 13, 2025·21m
  35. 35

    #28 Emotion vs Logic in Leadership

    Apr 6, 2025·17m
  36. 36

    #27 Be Like Water - Maintain Composure in Chaos

    Apr 2, 2025·19m
  37. 37

    #26 Get Out of Your Own Way

    Mar 30, 2025·20m
  38. 38

    #25 Managing Expectations

    Mar 26, 2025·15m
  39. 39

    #24 Leading Men vs Leading Women - Is There a Difference

    Mar 23, 2025·28m
  40. 40

    #23 Harness Competitive Spirit to Drive Performance

    Mar 19, 2025·17m
  41. 41

    #22 Starting Your Own Business - Leadership as an Entrepreneur

    Mar 16, 2025·49m
  42. 42

    #21 Should You Stay or Should You Go?

    Mar 12, 2025·19m
  43. 43

    #20 Stepping out of Your Predecessors Shadow

    Mar 9, 2025·23m
  44. 44

    #19 Don’t Bite The Hand That Feeds

    Mar 5, 2025·23m
  45. 45

    #18 Develop a Thick Skin

    Mar 2, 2025·26m
  46. 46

    #17 Maintaining Composure Under Fire

    Feb 26, 2025·24m
  47. 47

    #16 Warpaint

    Feb 23, 2025·16m
  48. 48

    #15 Conceive Believe Achieve - Realise Your Vision as a Leader

    Feb 19, 2025·28m
  49. 49

    #14 Is Your Personality Suitable for Leadership

    Feb 16, 2025·18m
  50. 50

    #13 Learn to Growl

    Feb 12, 2025·22m
  51. 51

    #12 Know Your Enemy

    Feb 9, 2025·16m
  52. 52

    #11 Earn Trust, Respect, and Loyalty as a New Leader

    Feb 5, 2025·19m
  53. 53

    #10 This Approach Will Set You Apart From the Rest

    Feb 3, 2025·14m
  54. 54

    #9 What if I’m not Better Than Those I Lead?

    Jan 28, 2025·10m
  55. 55

    #8 I’m Terrified of Public Speaking - Can I Still Lead People?

    Jan 27, 2025·15m
  56. 56

    #7 This Trait Will Destroy Your Leadership Credibility

    Jan 24, 2025·13m
  57. 57

    #2 Leading Effectively Through Change - Focus on This

    Jan 20, 2025·9m
  58. 58

    #6 Do You Need a Degree to Lead People?

    Jan 20, 2025·9m
  59. 59

    #5 Choosing a Leader - It’s a Big Deal!

    Jan 20, 2025·18m
  60. 60

    #4 Advice for New Leaders - Avoid These Mistakes

    Jan 20, 2025·11m
  61. 61

    #3 Leading Up - The Art of Timing

    Jan 20, 2025·10m
  62. 62

    #1 Having the Difficult Conversations - Not Many do This

    Jan 20, 2025·14m