Dark and Ominous Entertainment
64 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
We are a podcast that focuses on True Crime, supernatural, history, and mysteries.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Detailed case narration meets candid host discussion, with close attention to victim testimony, survivor decisions, and the small facts that redirect investigations.
Melissa, Mandy, and Kelly pair detailed case narration with an informal three-way conversation, pausing over suspicious timelines, investigative failures, and the decisions that helped victims survive.
An uncapped nail polish bottle is enough to make you doubt a peaceful-death explanation.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A grim follow-up that gives the aftermath room to breathe.
Part two of Coffee, Murder, and Mystery returns to Mary Bartell, the open apartment door, and a morning that ends in the hospital. It lands best when it stays close to the plain facts: the rapping Mary heard, Jackie finding her on the floor, and the hosts keeping the story…
A grim, patient look at how suspicious elderly deaths get dismissed too quickly.
The episode lingers on the quiet unease around elderly deaths that are too quickly treated as natural causes. Family members keep noticing details that do not sit right: missing jewelry, an uncapped nail polish bottle, a morning routine that does not match the account being…
A grim Alaska case told with enough care to make the pressure and chaos land.
Robert Hansen's Alaska crimes land in a 1970s and 80s Anchorage shaped by oil money, rapid growth, and a harder edge than the postcard version suggests.
A grim Detroit case told with patience, anger, and a strong sense of place.
Coffee, Murder, and Mystery looks at the Bigfoot killer case in Detroit in 1975, tracing the Cass Corridor, the victims, and the murders between February and October that were never solved.
An ordinary-looking man, a roadside escape, and the clues that led to a life sentence.
The episode frames Jeffrey Willis as the kind of ordinary-looking man whose public image does not fit the violence described later. It starts with his Michigan background, then moves into the gap between how others described him and what happened when Madison Nygaard crossed his…
A conversational Ouija history that blends folklore, business, and grim true-crime anecdotes.
The episode treats the Ouija board as more than a spooky prop, tying folklore, business history, and a few grim real-world consequences into one easy-to-follow story.
A patient missing-persons case study that keeps the focus on detail, urgency, and a local tone.
Layla Santanello's disappearance is handled with patience and care, with the family angle kept front and center instead of treated as background detail.
A haunted-house story that gets stranger once the court starts explaining it with Ghostbusters.
A haunted Victorian in Nyack, New York is the kind of story that sounds half like folklore and half like a paperwork problem once the law gets involved.
Crime stories with impact and consequence.
Epstein-case coverage with teeth.
Betrayal, evidence, and the breaking point.
Coffee, Murder, & Mystery opens with the Ghostbuster ruling, the strange court case that earned its nickname because Ghostbusters was explicitly referenced to explain a legally haunted house.
Coffee, Murder, & Mystery covers the disappearance and killing of 22-year-old Chelsea Ellen Brock, who went to Big Mike’s annual Halloween party in Newport, Michigan, wearing a handmade Poison Ivy costume.
Coffee, Murder, & Mystery follows Kathy Hobbs, a 16-year-old girl from Oakland who loved reading, writing, and drawing.
Danielle Stislicki disappears after a holiday dinner plan starts to fall apart.
Mary Bartell was supposed to exercise.
Elderly victims are at the center here.
Six months out of five years for rape and kidnapping—the system's catastrophic failure.
The hosts of Coffee, Murder, and Mystery investigate the unsolved case of the Bigfoot Killer, also known as the Cass Ripper, who terrorized Detroit's Cass Corridor in 1975, raping at least four women and murdering seven others.
Hosts investigate Jeffrey Willis, charged with multiple felonies including murder.
Coffee, Murder, & Mystery spends this episode tracing the Ouija board back to its older talking-board roots.
The host returns from hiatus to focus on two missing-person cases in Kingsport, Tennessee, after seeing a TikTok from a missing girl’s mother.