Coffee, Murder, & Mystery · Dark and Ominous Entertainment

Murder; Billy Chemirmir - Part 1

October 14, 2025·53 min·1 clip

The day a cult tried to trigger Armageddon in the world's busiest subway

The elderly are the point. The episode opens with a hard question: what do families do when a death feels wrong, but professionals call it natural causes and move on? That unease sits under the whole first part. The hosts keep coming back to the trust people place in care facilities, and the awful thought that someone dangerous may have gotten close to residents. It gets grim fast. Attacks on people who cannot easily defend themselves land as especially cruel, then the episode narrows in on elderly women whose deaths do not sit right. Questions and small checks slow the timeline down, especially once names, relationships, and missing jewelry start to matter. Juanita Purdy becomes the clearest example. Her daughter hears that Juanita died peacefully in her sleep, but the room tells a different story. The teacup was out. The morning paper had been brought in. Nail polish sat open, and the hosts know how odd that feels. They spend time on that detail through everyday memory, the kind where a grandmother would scold you for leaving the cap off even briefly. Then the jewelry hits harder. Juanita had about $33,000 in appraised jewelry, her wedding ring was gone, and the response to family concern sounds far too dismissive. The irritation stays controlled, but it is there. The episode also reaches Leah Corkin, an 83-year-old at the Tradition Prestonwood, whose hair, pillow, makeup, and bruising raise more questions. Part one stops before answers arrive, with Mary Bartell's police interview coming and the sour feeling that families had to keep pushing.

As heard by us

A grim, patient look at how suspicious elderly deaths get dismissed too quickly.

The episode lingers on the quiet unease around elderly deaths that are too quickly treated as natural causes. Family members keep noticing details that do not sit right: missing jewelry, an uncapped nail polish bottle, a morning routine that does not match the account being…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a grim case built from small details that should not have been ignored.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Coffee, Murder, & Mystery