Coffee, Murder, & Mystery · Dark and Ominous Entertainment

Missing in Michigan: The Disappearance of Danielle Stislicki

·40 min·2 clips

A lie-detector tip led investigators to Danielle’s body, keys, and Fitbit.

Danielle Stislicki disappears after a holiday evening starts to go sideways. Her friend notices she never made it to dinner, finds her car at her apartment, and starts worrying when Danielle stops answering her phone. That sends the hosts into the careful timeline work the show does best. The case tightens quickly. Security footage shows Danielle's car moving toward her apartment, and the hosts follow Galloway through the evening as he shows up at a nearby Tim Hortons, uses the store phone, and asks for a cab with a number already written on a piece of paper in his pocket. That feels planned. The hosts keep circling back to the practical details: how close the Tim Hortons is to Danielle's apartment, why his phone seems to stay off, and how the movement of the car, the cab, and the parking lot fit together. They do not rush past the confusion. Instead, they stop to correct each other, recheck who was where, and sort through what is known versus what only looks obvious in hindsight. The result stays grounded. It also keeps the case from turning abstract, because the conversation stays close to Danielle's family, the friends trying to reach her, and the growing sense that an ordinary night has gone very wrong. The episode widens beyond the first missing-person call. As the investigation continues, the hosts note that police are gathering evidence, local news is still following the story, and earlier June 2016 events come into the picture as the case develops. There is a lot of movement to track. By the time the hosts get to the later camera and location details, the pattern is hard to ignore: Danielle is missing, her effects are still in the car, and Galloway's route keeps pointing back to a sequence that feels planned rather than accidental. The conversation stays blunt. It leaves room for disbelief, a little dark humor, and the plain frustration of watching a case unfold while family members wait for answers that keep getting pushed further away. The ending keeps the grief front and center. The hosts come back to the people left behind, to the wish for a day in court, and to the reality that in Michigan the best possible outcome is prison for life. That is the shape of the episode. It is a careful, conversational walk through a disappearance, built for listeners who want the facts teased apart without losing the human cost.

As heard by us

A missing-persons case built from a worried call, a car trail, and careful timeline work.

The episode tracks Dani's disappearance through the worried call and the evidence around her car, her apartment, and Galloway. It pays off most when the timeline stays tight: the car moving, Galloway using the Tim Hortons phone, and the cab and later vehicle movements lining up.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Holiday plans, a missing phone, and camera footage trace Dani's disappearance in Michigan.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Coffee, Murder, & Mystery