Bryan McKenna
15 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Join comedian Bryan McKenna as he dives back into the eerie world of Unsolved Mysteries on Netflix in his podcast, Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch. Each episode, Bryan revisits the chilling tales and bizarre cases that captivated audiences, blending his sharp wit with nostalgic commentary. Expect laughter, intrigue, and a healthy dose of skepticism as he unpacks the show's most puzzling moments, all while sharing his own comedic takes and personal anecdotes. Whether you're a die-hard fan or a curious newcomer, tune in for a hilarious journey through the unknown—because some mysteries are just too good to let go!
Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Brian McKenna turns an Unsolved Mysteries rewatch into a running argument with the evidence, the witnesses, and his own changing theories.
Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch with Bryan McKenna is a loose solo watch-along, with McKenna reacting scene by scene and regularly stopping to challenge the program's implications.
A claimed alien abduction gets an Uber Pool joke; you get Bryan McKenna's company through darker cases.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A brisk, blunt rewatch that keeps the case moving and the tone loose.
This No Ride Home rewatch has a quick, conversational snap. Bryan McKenna says he is recording before heading out to New York City for shows, and that looseness carries through the opening stretch.
A blunt, loose true-crime rewatch that favors reaction over polish.
Brian McKenna's discussion moves through the murder case with a bleak, direct tone, and he treats it as suspicious almost from the start. He keeps circling back to the suspects, the family dynamics, and the count logic, so the episode lands more like an unvarnished true-crime…
A rough, personal rewatch that keeps witness details and family pain in the same frame.
The rewatch is at its best when it stays with the witness cars, the uncertain sightings, and the family pain running through each memory. Brian McKenna comes across most clearly in the moment, when the emotion is allowed to settle and the suspicion stays grounded in the facts…
A scrappy Berkshires UFO revisit that stays loose, argumentative, and rough around the edges.
Volume one, episode five on the Berkshires UFO stays loose and argumentative, with Brian McKenna revisiting the case in a way that feels closer to a live hang than a tidy recap.
Sharp TV arguments, faster than prestige can posture.
Star Trek commentary with the brakes off.
After the episode, inside the scene.
Classic Perry Mason, case by case.
A fannish map of Mindy’s TV universe.
Brian McKenna opens with housekeeping.
Brian McKenna rushes into Volume 1, Episode 4, "No Ride Home." He opens with housekeeping, says he is recording before heading out to New York City for shows, and then moves into the case of Alonzo Brooks, whose night at a party turns into a missing-person search after a ride home falls apart.
Host Bryan McKenna analyzes Part 2 of the Unsolved Mysteries episode 'No Ride Home,' focusing on the 2004 death of Alonzo Brooks.
Brian McKenna comes back to the mic after some time away from recording.
Brian McKenna starts by apologizing for the repeated recording issues and says he is moving past four failed attempts to upload the UFO episode.
Brian McKenna reviews Unsolved Mysteries Volume 5, Episode 3, where cattle across as many as 15 states are found with apparently precise mutilations.