Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch with Bryan McKenna · Bryan McKenna

Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch Volume 1 Episode 4- No Ride Home

April 16, 2025·38 min
Brian starts by joking that he botched his first sentence. He does not restart the recording and instead leans into the loose, off-the-cuff rhythm that defines the show. He says he is recording before heading out to New York City for shows, so he keeps the housekeeping brief and gets straight into Volume 1, Episode 4, "No Ride Home." The case centers on Alonzo Brooks. Alonzo goes to a party and expects a ride home, but things start to unravel when a friend steps outside for cigarettes and then heads off on his own. That friend gets lost in the woods and on gravel roads, gets his car stuck, and only gets it out about 30 minutes later. He calls a buddy at the party, who says he can hear Alonzo talking shit in the background and that someone is supposed to make Alonzo back home. Brian keeps circling the obvious question: if you were able to get yourself back, why not turn around and pick up the friend you left behind an hour away? The next day, the panic starts. Someone calls to ask whether Alonzo is home, his mother checks the house, and he is nowhere in his room or the basement. Brian lingers on the mother's reaction and treats that fear as the most human part of the story. He notes that this happened in 2004, when cell phones were only just becoming common. From there, the case shifts into witness accounts about fights at the party, including a version where a white girl starts the argument and Alonzo is the only Black kid there. One account says Alonzo may have been jumped by four or five people. Brian says that kind of group violence is believable, and he closes on the simple fact that a four-on-one fight is not a fair fight.

As heard by us

A brisk, blunt rewatch that keeps the case moving and the tone loose.

This No Ride Home rewatch has a quick, conversational snap. Bryan McKenna says he is recording before heading out to New York City for shows, and that looseness carries through the opening stretch.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A messy missing-person case told by a host who is clearly talking it through, not polishing it up.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on