Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch with Bryan McKenna · Bryan McKenna

Unsolved Mysteries Rewatch Volume 1 Episode 2- 13 Minutes

December 21, 2024·58 min·20 clips
Brian McKenna opens by saying this is the second time he is recording and that he has been fighting upload problems again. He says he tried four different times to post the UFO episode, but it would not upload, so he is moving on. He says he is going back to Volume 1 and redoing the earlier shows, then later returning to the older episodes after traveling and dealing with one recording problem after another. He is trying a new computer program and hopes this one works. He then moves into the case. He goes through witness details about vehicles seen near the scene, including a Ford Taurus, possibly a Malibu, and a Lumina. The witness descriptions stay messy, with mention of two ladies in front of the car and another witness who thinks he saw a man with shoulder-length hair. McKenna keeps coming back to the uncertainty and the guilt, pointing out how witnesses often beat themselves up afterward and wonder why they did not stop or say something sooner. From there he follows Pistol and the search in the woods, where people walk for hours calling her name. He says it is natural to go to the worst-case scenario in a situation like that. He also says Pistol was about 15 going on 16 and that the experience forced him to grow up fast, which connects with McKenna’s own memory of losing his father and how that changes you. The empathy comes through clearly. McKenna then returns to the house where Pistol had lived with her, noting that the last time he slept there was the night before she went missing. He describes that as bittersweet and says there had been issues with her husband. He closes with an update that Pistol eventually got his mother’s ashes after Rob died, and he adds his personal opinion that Rob probably did it, while acknowledging that nothing technically connects him. He signs off saying he hopes to keep doing the rewatch and invites listeners to message him on Instagram.

As heard by us

A rough, personal rewatch that keeps witness details and family pain in the same frame.

The rewatch is at its best when it stays with the witness cars, the uncertain sightings, and the family pain running through each memory. Brian McKenna comes across most clearly in the moment, when the emotion is allowed to settle and the suspicion stays grounded in the facts…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a rough rewatch that keeps circling Pistol's grief and the host's read on Rob.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on