
Movie trilogies, argued into existence.
The gist
Trilogy in Theory is a film conversation show built around monthly movie groupings that work as trilogies in theory. Webb and Mike mix close reading, jokes, personal viewing stories, and sharp detours through titles like The Godfather, Scream 7, Clerks, Adventureland, and Nightcrawler.
PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
About Trilogy in Theory
Trilogy in Theory is a movie conversation show organized around the playful pressure of a theme. Each month sets up a trilogy in concept, then lets the movies prove or wreck the idea. Webb and Mike approach that structure with more curiosity than rigidity. A classic can share space with a sequel, a comedy, or a recent crowd-pleaser. The show is strongest when it follows a thought until it turns strange. The Godfather becomes a discussion of rhythm, empathy, home viewing, and why some films pull a viewer straight through. Adventureland opens into talk about stalled adulthood, tonal expectations, Ryan Reynolds, and the difference between affectionate character writing and broader gross-out comedy. Clerks prompts a more uneasy conversation about jokes, misogyny, amateur performances, and why context changes the way abrasive material plays. Scream 7 brings out the show's interest in meta-horror, legacy characters, fan expectations, and the exhaustion of repeating franchise rules. Nightcrawler becomes a way to talk about ambition, social media, American Psycho, and the modern outsourcing of voyeurism to anyone holding a phone. The hosts do not keep the conversation sealed inside film theory. They bring in family viewing stories, streaming habits, old commentaries, theater memories, and whatever comparison happens to make them laugh. The tone is blunt but not careless. They can admire a movie's construction, call out a weak character arc, and still take a ridiculous detour a minute later. That rhythm suits listeners who enjoy criticism that sounds like a long-running friendship rather than a polished lecture. The show has a particular feel for movies that are both loved and compromised. It notices greatness, but it also notices the awkward scene, the dated joke, the unexplained franchise choice, and the side character who should have mattered more. Its canon is elastic. Coppola, Kevin Smith, Scream, Project Hail Mary, and Ready or Not can all enter the same orbit if the month's premise leaves room. The pleasure comes from watching the connective tissue get stretched, argued over, and occasionally abandoned with a laugh.
Made for: For film fans who like conversational criticism, franchise talk, comedy memories, and arguments that can move from scene craft to absurd tangent without losing the movie thread.
What sets it apart: The show’s hook is its monthly trilogy experiment: films are grouped by a proposed connection, then tested through candid, joke-heavy discussion. It treats classics, horror sequels, and messy comedies as equally available evidence.
In their own words
A month of movies meeting movies to form a good trilogy... in theory.
As heard by us
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Webb and Mike connect character, craft and movie history through comparisons that turn each proposed trilogy into a lively critical argument.
Webb and Mike take one film at a time, then test how it speaks to the other choices in their evolving trilogy. The pairing makes room for sharp leaps: Scream 7 (2026) leads into franchise rules and sequel fatigue, while The Godfather (1972) prompts questions about rhythm,…
Why you'd press play
Webb and Mike put The Godfather beside Jay and Silent Bob, and somehow you see the bridge.
Press play if you want
- your film criticism threaded with filthy jokes and genuine affection
- to compare untouchable classics with cult comedies on equal footing
Talks about
Podcasts like Trilogy in Theory
Episodes
- 1
Clerks (1994)
Hidden gemDante confronts his girlfriend about her sexual history, leading to a heated argument over the number of men she has performed oral sex on.
Apr 17, 2026·36m·2 clips - 2
Project Hail Mary (2026)
Trilogy in Theory reviews Project Hail Mary through Webb’s daughter Aria, who explains Grace’s mission and Rocky’s role after watching her first PG-13 film.
Apr 15, 2026·35m·2 clips - 3
Patreon Preview of Ready or Not 2: Here I Come (2026)
A dramatic dialogue between two characters discussing past failures and a strained relationship, set in a podcast preview.
Apr 13, 2026·6m - 4
Adventureland (2009)
Hidden gemWebb and Mike revisit Greg Mottola’s Adventureland, arguing that its reputation suffered from marketing that connected Mottola to Superbad.
Mar 22, 2026·36m·2 clips - 5
The Godfather (1972)
Trilogy in Theory’s Webb and Mike revisit The Godfather (1972) through childhood memories, including Webb’s grandfather and Mike’s conflicting family stories about being named after Michael.
Mar 18, 2026·36m·2 clips - 6
Scream 7 (2026)
Hidden gemThe Trilogy in Theory hosts argue that Scream 7 is the first Kevin Williamson-directed Scream feature and that his second directing credit after Teaching Mrs.
Mar 8, 2026·40m·2 clips - 7
Patreon Preview of High and Low (1963)
Feb 26, 2026·8m - 8
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975)
Hidden gemWebb and Mike revisit One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, a film they place alongside The Silence of the Lambs and It Happened One Night as an Oscar heavyweight.
Feb 23, 2026·39m·2 clips - 9
Nightcrawler (2014)
Hidden gemWebb and Mike revisit Dan Gilroy's Nightcrawler, with Jake Gyllenhaal's Lou Bloom framed as a "success story" that the hosts mostly reject.
Feb 19, 2026·27m·1 clip - 10
Send Help (2026)
Feb 18, 2026·25m - 11
Patreon Preview of Hellraiser (1987)
Feb 17, 2026·6m - 12
The Fisher King (1991)
Feb 16, 2026·30m - 13
Wake Up Dead Man (2025)
Jan 25, 2026·31m - 14
28 Years Later: The Bone Temple (2026)
Jan 20, 2026·37m - 15
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011)
Hidden gemA podcast episode reviewing the 2011 film The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, discussing its dark themes and Christmas setting.
Dec 25, 2025·37m·2 clips - 16
Gone Girl (2014)
Dec 20, 2025·33m - 17
You've Got Mail (1998)
Dec 12, 2025·35m - 18
Vertigo (1958)
Dec 5, 2025·41m - 19
Patreon Preview of X2 (2003)
Nov 3, 2025·7m - 20
Jerry Maguire (1996)
Oct 17, 2025·31m - 21
Broadcast News (1987)
Sep 25, 2025·38m - 22
Superman (2025)
Sep 23, 2025·39m - 23
The Martian (2015)
Sep 21, 2025·29m - 24
The Avengers (2012)
Jul 10, 2025·35m - 25
A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors
Jul 8, 2025·33m - 26
Patreon Preview of Daredevil (2003)
Jul 3, 2025·7m - 27
Captain America: The First Avenger (2011)
Jun 26, 2025·30m - 28
A League of Their Own (1992)
Jun 19, 2025·37m - 29
All the President's Men (1976)
Jun 12, 2025·30m - 30
Patreon Preview of Spider-Man (2002)
Jun 5, 2025·7m - 31
Thor (2011)
May 1, 2025·37m - 32
Gattaca (1997)
Apr 28, 2025·32m - 33
The Game (1997)
Apr 17, 2025·31m - 34
Patreon Preview of Blade 2 (2002)
Apr 3, 2025·6m - 35
Iron Man 2 (2010)
Mar 27, 2025·33m - 36
Big Fish (2003)
Mar 19, 2025·29m - 37
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade (1989)
Mar 12, 2025·35m - 38
Patreon Preview of X-Men (2000)
Mar 5, 2025·7m - 39
The Invisible Man (2020)
Feb 27, 2025·35m - 40
The Incredible Hulk (2008)
Feb 16, 2025·33m - 41
The Fly (1986)
Feb 13, 2025·32m - 42
Patreon Preview of Blade (1998)
Jan 29, 2025·6m - 43
The Wild Robot (2024)
Jan 23, 2025·32m - 44
Iron Man (2008)
Jan 16, 2025·28m - 45
Goldfinger (1964)
Webb and Mike introduce a new series on the James Bond franchise, starting with the 1964 film Goldfinger.
Jan 10, 2025·30m - 46
Patreon Preview of Best Movie Year Ever: MAGNOLIA
Jan 2, 2025·8m - 47
Love Hard (2021) with Reindeer Games (2000)
Webb and Mike discuss the Netflix film Love Hard and the Ben Affleck movie Reindeer Games, debating their merits as Christmas films.
Dec 25, 2024·49m - 48
The Informant! (2009)
A podcast episode reviewing the 2009 film The Informant as part of a Steven Soderbergh whistleblower trilogy.
Dec 22, 2024·30m - 49
Patreon Preview of Best Movie Year Ever: BOYS DON'T CRY
Dec 19, 2024·6m - 50
Erin Brockovich (2000)
A podcast episode analyzing the film Erin Brockovich, focusing on a scene where Erin memorizes plaintiff details to prove her dedication.
Dec 16, 2024·30m





