Two friends, real crimes, and a running bingo card.
Jake and Dylan walk each other through real cases, from testimony in the Casey Anthony trial to Heidnik's family history, with one telling the story while the other reacts. The facts come in between talk about Grimace toys, a made-up metal radio station and a running chorus of 'Hail Satan.'
PRESS PLAY
Too Scared To Sleep is a true crime show run by two friends, Jake and Dylan, and it sounds like two friends talking. They have known each other for about seven years, and you can hear it in how fast a cold open wanders off. Before any case begins, the talk might cover a four-eyed Grimace toy from a meal in a box, a family party season packed with birthdays, a lip piercing mistaken for ice cream, or one host's new membership in the Satanic Temple. Then the case file comes out. The structure is a storyteller and a listener: one host reads the research while the other supplies the gasps, the questions and the jokes. Sometimes both bring a story, as when each finds a McDonald triad link in his own case and it goes onto the running bingo card, sung to a fast-food jingle. The cases are real, and they vary widely. There is courtroom testimony from the Casey Anthony trial, read out in detail. There is Heidnik's family background, including a mother's suicide and the triad's warning signs. There is an unsolved 1930s murder tied to a Kansas City hotel, where a phone contact, a woman whose fingerprints were found and whoever paid for the funeral were never identified. There is a suspect whose haircut beat a police lineup. And there is a man named Packer, whose free spending at a saloon set the townspeople gossiping while the rest of his party was still unheard from. Another story follows a man born in South Dakota in 1951 who had served in the Air Force. The hosts make no attempt at neutrality. Carelessness gets called out bluntly, and Packer, holding several wallets and more cash than anyone could explain, is labelled a simpleton on the spot. The heavier details still land: after one grim turn, the only reaction is 'I wasn't expecting that,' followed by an admission that this is not a happy story. The in-jokes are what make the show recognisable. 'Hail Satan' works as a greeting, WKRX is a fake Greater Cincinnati station playing all the metal hits, and Boomer gets coaxed on camera. The audience is asked to send in pet photos for 'petty crimes.' The season-five episodes include a lot of talk about being back, staying consistent and making the show a real thing again. Each episode here closes on the same sign-off, hoping the audience has been left too scared to sleep.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants real criminal cases told by two friends who joke their way through them, and who does not mind heavy profanity or irreverent religious humor next to grim details.
What sets it apart: The case research comes through a storyteller-and-reactor friendship, so the facts are surrounded by in-jokes: a made-up metal radio station, a bingo card for the McDonald triad and 'Hail Satan' as a greeting.
A weekly paranormal and true crime podcast where Jake and Dylan tell you scary tales of the paranormal, true crime, cryptids, conspiracy theories, UFOs and alien abductions!
Packer's spare wallets get roasted; your true crime comes with Jake and Dylan's running commentary.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Gary's grim backstory meets Grimace worship in a chaotic true-crime episode built on irreverent, profane banter.
Too Scared To Sleep sets Gary's childhood abuse and later military service against the hosts' fixation on a four-eyed Grimace toy, creating a strange push and pull between bleak material and gleeful nonsense.
Loose banter turns into uneasy Casey Anthony case testimony about evidence, searches, and what can really be proven.
Too Scared To Sleep begins in loose, comic territory, with talk of a mistaken McFlurry stain, a lip piercing, family party season, and a vinyl record, then shifts into testimony connected to the Casey Anthony case.
A 1935 murder mystery where identifying the victim only deepens the unanswered questions.
This loose, darkly comic episode circles a 1935 murder mystery that only gets stranger after the victim is identified. Artemis Ogletree was buried under a fake name, recognized about a year and a half later, and still left behind no solved murder and no official suspect.
A haircut becomes the hinge in a murder story tied to Bingenwald's prison connection.
A haircut turns into the pivot point for this rough-edged return from Too Scared To Sleep. Jake and Dylan begin with jokes about Boomer, a new tattoo, and the show's comeback, then move into the case of Richard Bingenwald.
Packer's cash, frozen feet, and a saloon full of reasons to doubt him.
Too Scared to Sleep shapes the Packer story as grim comedy with a hard edge, watching a fragile survival account start to buckle once the details are tested.
Spooky cases with a loud mouth.
Small talk first, then the case file opens.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
["Too Scared To Sleep S5E4 turns from banter into Gary M.
Too Scared to Sleep S5E3, Don't Go To Church, Kids, spends a long cold open on vinyl records, Morbius, and VelociPastor before turning to Casey Anthony and Kaylee Marie Anthony.
Jake and Dylan open with their Harbor Freight origin story, the donated-plasma money that bought their first gear, and a reminder that early episodes with Annabelle sounded rough.
["Too Scared To Sleep S5E1, Back-to-Back Fuckery, centers on Richard Biegenwald, starting with Sally Bingenwald watching police dig up two 17-year-old victims from her New Jersey yard.", "Jake traces Biegenwald from an age-five arson attempt and a schizophrenia diagnosis through twenty electroshock sessions, a 1958 deli killing of Stephen Sladowski, and a later life sentence.", "The episode then follows his parole at age 35, his relationship with 16-year-old Diane Mercellus, and a failed attempted-rape case that hinged on him showing up bald at the lineup.", "The back half turns to Theresa Smith's testimony about guns, bomb materials, a venomous snake, and snake venom in the basement, plus the dump sites tied to Betsy Bacon, William J.
Too Scared to Sleep S4E5 opens with banter about the Satanic Temple, 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days, and a Batman Little Caesars pizza before pivoting to Alfred Greiner Packer.
Too Scared To Sleep's “S4E4 Patriotic Murder Machine” examines Marvin Heemeyer's decade-long conflict over a concrete plant near his muffler shop in Granby, Colorado.
Too Scared To Sleep presents Jake's account of Daniel LaPlante, a Massachusetts teenager whose 1986–87 crimes became associated with break-ins, moved objects, ketchup messages, and the phrase "folk devil." Dylan and Jake discuss conflicting reports about LaPlante's childhood, dyslexia, social isolation, alleged abuse, and early burglaries.
Too Scared to Sleep S4E1 examines the Berkshire County UFO incident, a reported series of sightings in western Massachusetts on September 1, 1969.
Too Scared To Sleep's episode "Hannah Montana Murder Cabin" spends its main narrative section on Theodore John Kaczynski, whose childhood hospitalization, IQ score of 167, Harvard education, and later isolation in Montana are presented chronologically.
Too Scared To Sleep’s S3E15 centers on the 1952 Flatwoods Monster reports from West Virginia and a later concern about repeated house flies in the host’s Texas home.
Hosts Jake and Dylan introduce a new episode of their paranormal and true crime podcast, sharing personal anecdotes before diving into scary stories.
Hosts Dylan and Jake banter comically before Dylan begins sharing a personal story about his love life, framed as a dumpster fire.
Jake and Dylan introduce a personal story about Dylan's desire to buy a motorcycle, setting up a humorous anecdote.
The hosts return after a year-long hiatus to discuss their new release schedule and upcoming movie podcast, while reaffirming their commitment to telling scary stories.