A road story that makes distance feel uncanny.
The Left Right Game starts with a late-night meeting in Phoenix and Myra Simmons, which gives the story a solid human foothold before it slides into stranger territory.

A road legend with no way back.
The Left Right Game follows a journalist into a convoy chasing a ritual of alternating turns. What begins as documentation becomes evidence of a world slipping out of reach, with every road rule carrying a cost.
PRESS PLAY
The Left Right Game is a tightly produced supernatural road thriller about an investigation that stops being an investigation. Alice begins with a recorder, a story, and a convoy of people who believe a turning game can lead somewhere impossible. The early tension is practical. Phones fail. Strangers appear where they should not be. Rob explains the rules with the bluntness of someone who has survived them before, but his confidence never quite makes the road feel safe. That restraint is the show’s strength. It does not rush to name the horror. It lets procedures, warnings, and small human mistakes gather pressure until the landscape itself feels predatory. A hitchhiker in a good suit becomes more alarming than a monster because everyone knows not to speak to him. A forest is frightening because someone once came back from it broken, while someone else stayed behind in a form that may no longer be human. Later episodes push the story into stranger territory: radios, stolen keys, a childlike presence, a woman on a turn, a lake on both sides of the road, and a moon separating into pieces overhead. The show keeps returning to recordings as both proof and confession. People leave messages because there may be no one left to answer. The road strips the characters down to fear, loyalty, obsession, and regret. Its sound design matters to the storytelling, with warnings that the experience can seem to move around the listener. The cast gives the fiction a grounded, bruised quality rather than a campfire-story polish. Tessa Thompson’s Alice is positioned at the center of that uncertainty, while Rob’s history widens the mythology without making it tidy. The series is best for listeners who want supernatural fiction with evidence-board bones and haunted-road blood. It is not cozy. It is controlled, mournful, and increasingly cosmic.
Made for: For listeners who like serialized supernatural fiction, found-audio tension, road-trip horror, and investigations that become personal before they become impossible.
What sets it apart: The show’s power comes from treating the impossible as logistics first: radios, rules, messages, and witness accounts. Its immersive sound and restrained dialogue make the supernatural feel documented rather than announced.
Tessa Thompson stars as an idealistic young journalist trying to make a name for herself by following a group of paranormal explorers, obsessed with a seemingly harmless pastime known as the Left/Right Game. The journey takes her into a supernatural world that she and the other members of the expedition can neither handle nor survive.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
A rigorously staged supernatural serial that turns road rules, fractured landscapes and directional sound into mounting psychological dread.
The Left Right Game turns a paranormal driving ritual into a tightly controlled serial, following journalist Alice Sharman as she records an expedition beyond familiar roads.
A wrong turn becomes an entire universe, and your headphones become the passenger seat.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A road story that makes distance feel uncanny.
The Left Right Game starts with a late-night meeting in Phoenix and Myra Simmons, which gives the story a solid human foothold before it slides into stranger territory.
A road story where grief turns every turn into a warning.
The road in this story feels less like a place than a wound. The episode keeps circling what it leaves behind: a vanished woman, a wrecked man, and a search that never quite settles into easy answers.
A tense radio exchange in the woods turns practical details into escalating danger.
The scene builds pressure through plain logistics: who has the truck, who has the keys, who can still hear, and how the group is meant to find one another again.
A roadside mystery that turns a failed phone call into something quietly menacing.
The episode opens on a small social snag: Bristol makes a failed call to American Stories and gets stopped by a strict policy. That little moment sets the tone well.
A slow burn that turns memory gaps and quiet dread into steady unease.
The Left Right Game starts in a hospital room with a patient waking, a red light still on, and everyone trying to sort out what can be remembered. That plain opening works because the story keeps pressing ordinary details into something uneasy.






Series creator Michelle Rosenfarb introduces Madam Ram, an audio fiction starring Toni Collette as Georgia Frontier, a former showgirl who inherits the LA Rams after the mysterious drowning death of her sixth husband.
The finale of The Left Right Game follows journalist Alice Sharman on her fourteenth day on the supernatural road, beginning with a late-night meeting in Phoenix with Myra Simmons, a paranormal message board operator who has hand-mapped the city's mirror stores to identify Alice's destination.
The road keeps its hold on the people who come back from it.
The episode opens with a soundcheck that already feels wrong.
The Left-Right Game episode "Rob Guthard Takes on London" follows Alice Sharman as she pursues evidence that Alice has been erased from records, websites, and a student newspaper.
In episode 2 of The Left Right Game, journalist Bristol and her convoy receive strict instructions from guide Rob about a hitchhiker they must pick up but never speak to.
Episode 1 introduces two narrative layers: a hospitalized narrator who explains that his missing friend Alice Sharman sent him unexplained audio files before disappearing, and Alice's own recordings of meeting Rob Guthard in Phoenix and joining his convoy to play the Left Right Game.