Audacy
500 episodes listed below
Sports, argued in real time.
The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle treats sports like a live pressure test. Knicks optimism, Mets frustration, Yankees roster math, Giants contract drama, and NBA policy all get worked over in real time.
PRESS PLAY
The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle is a sports room with the door left open. It moves fast. One segment can start with a Knicks Finals declaration, turn into a question about Atlanta, Jalen Brunson, playoff odds, and disrespect from Vegas, then drift into hockey misery before snapping back to the next fight. The show is not trying to sound tidy. Its energy comes from people working through sports in the same jagged way fans do: half certainty, half complaint, and a lot of immediate revision. Recent episodes lean heavily on the Knicks, Yankees, Mets, Giants, and the NBA. The baseball talk gets granular. Mike Trout's Yankee Stadium damage, Aaron Judge heating up, Paul Goldschmidt's awkward roster fit, backup catcher limitations, bullpen order, and a hard liner caught at second all matter because the show treats games as a chain of small irritations and missed chances. The Mets material is more wounded. A scoreless stretch, a double play, a flat offense, and the emotional weight of Dodgers comparisons become fuel for both anger and comedy. Football shows up through Dexter Lawrence trade rumors and contract leverage, with the conversation staying practical about value, money, and whether the Giants can make him happy. Interviews bring a different gear. Adam Silver's appearances let the show ask direct questions about expansion, officiating, sports betting, eligibility rules, and how the NBA handles incentives without losing the fan-facing stakes. The tone can be dry and blunt. It also has room for real enthusiasm, especially when a team gives the panel enough evidence to believe. This is not distant national analysis with a clean thesis at the top. It is sports talk as an ongoing argument: corrections, numbers, jokes, resentment, loyalty, and the occasional oddly perfect tangent. The result is a show for listeners who want sports passion with enough detail to keep the yelling honest.
Made for: For sports fans who follow the Knicks, Yankees, Mets, Giants, and league-wide NBA storylines closely enough to care about lineups, odds, contracts, and embarrassing losses. It fits listeners who like blunt disagreement more than polished recap.
What sets it apart: The show’s edge is its live-room friction: jokes, corrections, fan logic, and specific sports details collide before the take has cooled. Even major interviews get pulled back toward practical questions about money, rules, gambling, lineups, and wins.
The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle is sports talk with a pulse — loud, loose and unapologetically entertaining. Carton’s larger-than-life style and McMonigle’s no-nonsense perspective create a show that blends comedy, controversy and real debate. From Yankees and Mets drama to Giants, Jets, Knicks, Nets and whatever headline is dominating the day, nothing is too serious to laugh at or too big to challenge. Unfiltered and unpredictable, The Carton Show turns sports talk into an event.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
New York sports emotion meets detailed argument about performance, roster choices, playoff matchups and league decisions.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn New York results into arguments about what actually happened and how much it should matter. Yankees and Mets slumps bring close attention to run support, roster fit, hard contact, bullpen work and front-office choices.
A 17-3 game can still keep you in your seat: the chicken might escape.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Cold bats, solid pitching, and enough baseball memory lane to keep Yankees fans leaning in.
The segment stays on the Yankees' cold bats, with Judge still not quite himself, Stanton cooling off, and Rice looking like the steadiest bat before he cooled in the series.
A Mets schedule change, free tickets, and a Steve Cohen tweet that turns turnout into the real story.
This segment follows the Mets, Steve Cohen, and the fallout from a start-time change from 7-10 to 4-10, along with vouchers for future games and a free-ticket offer for Tuesday and Wednesday.
Big Cat and PFT Commenter cover the NFL, March Madness, and NHL for laughs.
Ryen Russillo runs weekly NFL and MLB recaps with beat reporters like Jeff Passan and Mike Sando.
HBCU sports talk with institutional memory.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss Mets owner Steve Cohen's tweet criticizing fans who took free tickets but didn't attend a rescheduled game.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dissect the New York Yankees' offensive struggles after they scored zero runs over 17 innings and nearly got swept by the Oakland A's.