Movie reviews with family-level cross-talk.
Reel Film Nerds turns current movie reviews into a loose panel conversation, with Matt steering Mike and Ma Hinshaw through jokes before the verdicts arrive. Recent episodes bounce from horror and sci-fi to game adaptations and action films.
PRESS PLAY
Reel Film Nerds is a movie-review show with the shape of a weekly hangout and the attention span of a group chat. It moves fast. Matt usually gets the episode pointed toward the film, but Mike and Ma Hinshaw keep pulling the conversation through jokes about birthdays, family status, holiday greetings, drinks, old game systems, and whatever just happened in the room. The reviews cover new releases across horror, sci-fi, thrillers, game adaptations, and action. Recent episodes include horror, sci-fi, game adaptations, thrillers, and action releases. The show does not hide its casualness. It looks up actors, argues about plot clutter, flags spoiler sections, and reacts in plain language when a movie feels overstuffed, ridiculous, scary, clever, or simply worth seeing with a crowd. That informality is the point. Reel Film Nerds has enough recurring structure to stay recognizable, but the real engine is the panel’s willingness to wander and then snap back to the movie. A horror sequel can lead to AI deepfakes and franchise fatigue. A sci-fi release can become a birthday bit about an actor. A game-adaptation movie can become a roll call of old hardware and character worries. The jokes can get crude, though the mood is more teasing than hostile. Family ribbing is constant. So are the little rituals: social plugs, spoiler resets, movie facts, and the sense that the conversation started before the microphones came on. It suits listeners who want movie opinions delivered by people who sound comfortable being wrong, interrupting themselves, and laughing at the tangent before returning to the point. The result is not tidy criticism. It is a durable, unruly record of people talking about the movies they actually went out to see.
Made for: Best for movie fans who like casual review podcasts with spoilers, franchise chatter, and a lot of personality around the edges. It especially suits listeners who enjoy horror, sci-fi, action, and pop-culture detours without needing a formal critic’s format.
What sets it apart: The show’s review structure is constantly jostled by recurring family banter, drink jokes, birthday bits, and abrupt topic resets. That makes each episode feel less like a prepared critique and more like a long-running table conversation with a movie at the center.
Reel Film Nerds is a podcast based on the best thing in the world, movies of course! We discuss films of all kinds new, old, Netflix, Amazon, you name it! Your hosts Mike and Matt are not professional film critics and they have not been trained in any way shape or form, we swear! They are just a couple of dudes one from Prescott, Arizona who are very passionate about films and love to talk about them. Do yourself a favor and take a listen you might enjoy it!
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Candid verdicts, spoiler discussion and a lived-in host dynamic make Reel Film Nerds useful company after a new release.
Reel Film Nerds turns a movie review into a lively argument among people comfortable disagreeing. Mike and Matt move from basic credits and initial verdicts into spoiler discussion, while Ma Henshaw brings her own questions and recommendations.
A dad joke stands between you and a verdict on that movie ticket.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose but focused panel debate argues that The Bride's strongest story gets crowded by its side quests.
The Bride gets a lively, slightly shaggy discussion built around a clear argument: the film works best when it stays with the Bride, Frankenstein, his isolation, her creation, and their Bonnie and Clyde-style flight.
A spoiler-heavy Scream 7 chat finds laughs in AI deepfakes, audience screams, and a franchise that keeps coming back.
Scream 7 gets a loose, spoiler-heavy discussion centered on the movie's use of AI to create deepfakes of previous characters. One speaker sees the idea as creative and right for the moment, while another makes the key distinction: the surprise is not AI behind the filmmaking,…
A sci-fi movie review folded into curling complaints, beer talk, dad jokes, and spoiler-aware comic-book discussion.
Real Film Nerds' Episode #461 treats a sci-fi movie review like a casual group hangout. Before the film takes over, the hosts move through curling frustration, workcation chatter, a cough near formal wear, and a double IPA debate.
A loose panel weighs the theater case, lingering questions, and a more grounded but still chaotic trilogy entry.
Episode #460 frames the third entry in the new Strangers trilogy as a casual panel question: is this one worth the theater trip? The answer stays mixed, but usefully specific.
A flight-themed movie review warmed by family banter, eye-shot stories, and a very specific huckleberry lemonade.
The episode starts as a movie conversation, then loosens into the warmer, messier rhythm of a family table where the side roads are part of the point.
A loose, company-first movie review where blood cookies, pumpkin beer, and Benedict Cucumber Snatch all get a seat.
Real Film Nerds treats The Roses as a hangout as much as a review, letting the panel's chemistry set the pace from a mock "eleventeen" reels verdict into talk of the R rating, Jay Roach, Tony McNamara, and Warren Adler's source novel.
Three friends recap Daredevil, Fallout, and new releases scene by scene, in Spanish.
Slasher talk with sharp teeth.
The hosts discuss the retro technology featured in the movie Black Phone 2, reflecting on rotary phones and phone operators.
Hosts Mike and Matt review the movie 'The Roses', a modern comedic take on 'The War of the Roses'.
Hosts Mike and Matt, along with guests Maniacal Mags and Ma Henshaw, review Mel Gibson's new thriller 'Flight Risk' starring Mark Wahlberg.
The hosts of Nerd Arenas introduce a discussion about the upcoming film M3GAN 2.0 during their Harvest Horror Fest series, with banter about airplane jokes and episode numbering.
The hosts of the Real Film Nerds podcast discuss the Olympics, Canada's cheating in curling, and banter about Mike's recording setup in a closet.
The hosts of Harvest Horror Fest discuss the final installment of their annual event, reviewing Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives.
Reel Film Nerds reviews Heart of the Beast, David Ayer’s Alaska-set survival film starring Brad Pitt and J.K.
The Real Film Nerds podcast hosts discuss the 2017 Netflix satirical war film 'War Machine' starring Brad Pitt.
Reel Film Nerds Episode #468 reviews The Super Mario Galaxy Movie, which the hosts say ran in theaters roughly every 30 minutes over Easter weekend.
The hosts of the Real Film Nerds podcast engage in humorous banter about family dynamics and introduce the topic of the movie Ready or Not 2.
The hosts of the Real Film Nerds Podcast discuss the movie Project Hail Mary, with personal anecdotes and banter.
The hosts of the Real Film Nerds Podcast banter about St.
Reel Film Nerds Episode #464 covers The Bride, directed by Maggie Gyllenhaal and set in 1930s Chicago with Jesse Buckley, Christian Bale, Annette Bening, Penelope Cruz, Peter Skarsgård, and Jake Gyllenhaal.
Reel Film Nerds Episode #463 centers on Scream 7, with the hosts splitting on whether the movie’s kills and logic make the best kind of horror-movie chaos.
The Real Film Nerds Podcast discusses the film 'How to Make a Killing' with hosts Matt, Mike, and Ma.
The film’s AI commentary turns into “in your face social commentary” about screen time and cloning.
Reel Film Nerds episode 460 covers The Strangers: Chapter 3, with Matt, Mike, and Ma Hinshaw disagreeing about whether the trilogy format helped the 2025 horror sequel.