Our True Crime Podcast
483 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Our True Crime Podcast focuses on bizarre, lesser-known crime cases from around the globe delivered with respect, a bit of humor, and a smidge of song. Everything you’ve come to love from Jen and Cam.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Jen and Cam turn dense case records into clear, questioning conversations that keep evidence, uncertainty, and victims in view.
Jen and Cam pair detailed case narration with an informal exchange that pauses over contradictions, unanswered questions, and the human consequences of a crime.
A caller keeps hanging up on 911, and your questions have company.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A truck-key dispute turns into a stark account of violence at a family's home.
Edward Harold Bell's entry in the Christmas countdown is built around a simple, frightening demand: he wants the keys to his truck back. After Dorothy Lang calls police, her 26-year-old son Larry Dean Dickens runs outside, pulls the keys from the ignition, and tries to keep Bell…
A trapped woman's urgent calculation turns a sealed trunk into her only possible way out.
Andrew arrives in a scene built around immediate danger: a woman is trapped inside a trunk, works her hands free, and starts measuring what may happen when he opens it. She pictures being pulled out, the fight that could follow, and the grim odds of surviving without a weapon.
A holiday-framed murder account made chilling by strange money, flat reactions, and one unsettling question about a dog.
The 12 Nightmares Before Christmas frame gives Sarah's murder a bleak holiday setting, but the episode is most effective when it sits with Liam's own words.
A grave true-crime opening steadied by Jen and Cam's familiar, lightly wry studio chemistry.
This single-episode review frames the opening as a careful piece of mood-setting for a grim true-crime show. Edward October's warning gives the start a hard edge, stressing that the crimes discussed are disturbing even for someone used to ghost stories, horror shows, and…
A guilty plea and contested forensic testimony tilt an infamous Waco murder trial.
The Lake Waco Murders episode tracks a prosecution shaped by pressure from every side: graphic crime-scene photographs, emotional family testimony, bite-mark evidence then widely trusted, and prison informants whose detailed accounts did not always line up.
A confession sends investigators from a missing head to a campsite, a trailer, and a troubling childhood history.
Wayne Adam Ford's case centers on a confession that sends investigators searching for a victim's missing head and the evidence that could help identify her. Ford says he buried the head in a river channel, but the search comes up empty.
A grim cover-up story told with skepticism, pace, and a sharp eye for the excuses.
This episode traces Sarah Everard's murder as a grim, deliberate cover-up, and it keeps the sequence easy to follow as it moves from the phone disposal to the body in water, the stress excuse at work, the gas refill at Whitfield, and the return to Hodeswood.
A grim, careful look at Shawcross's case as the pattern becomes impossible to ignore.
Arthur Shawcross's case is presented as a grim, orderly build from body to body, excuse to excuse, until the pattern is impossible to miss. The writing works best when it keeps the timeline moving but still gives space to the details that count: the close dump sites, the…
Grave questions, carefully organized.
Paranormal talk with room to wander.
Oz reimagined, then argued with afterward.
Crime memory with prison-wall detail.
Irish true crime, evidence first.
True crime with forensic bite and blunt banter.
This episode delves into the case of the Sunset Strip Killers, Doug Clark and Carol Bundy, who terrorized Los Angeles in the early 1980s.
Edward October introduces a March special episode featuring Jenny from It's Murder Up North discussing the unsolved murder of Diane Sindall.
Our True Crime Podcast covers the disappearance of Corrie Sagers and her 11-year-old daughter Annette from Mount Holly Plantation in Berkeley County, South Carolina, with dates in November 1987 and October 1988 driving the timeline.
Our True Crime Podcast covers the Lake Waco murders from July 14, 1982, when three teenagers — Jill Montgomery, Raelynn Rice, and Kenneth Franks — were found bound, gagged, and stabbed 48 times near Lake Waco in Texas.
On November 17, 2019, 26-year-old Marshall Iwasa left his mother's house in Lethbridge, Alberta, to retrieve items from a storage unit.
The episode covers the crimes of serial killer Oscar Ray Bolin, detailing his murders of Natalie Holly, Stephanie Collins, and Terry Lynn Matthews in Florida during the 1980s.
Our True Crime Podcast follows the Grace Millane case through the trial arguments around her death.
Our True Crime Podcast follows William Dathan Holbert, called Wild Bill, from a North Carolina real-estate scam to Panama, where he and Laura Reese operated under the names William Aldofo Cortez and Jane Cortez.
Edward October opens with a warning.
Our True Crime Podcast episode 345 follows the 2011 killing of James Craig Anderson in Jackson, Mississippi, and ties it to the state’s history of racial violence.
Arthur Duperrault, a 40-year-old optometrist from Green Bay, Wisconsin, charters the 60-foot Bluebell for a Bahamas trip with his wife Jean, children Brian, Terry Jo, and Renee, plus captain Julian Harvey and Harvey’s wife Mary Deeney.
Our True Crime Podcast covers the 1984 Palm Sunday massacre at 1080 Liberty Avenue in East New York, where eight children and two women were shot in a home while eating snacks and watching TV.
Sarah Everard’s murder is traced through the killer’s movements, the effort to hide the crime, and the evidence that slowly pulled the story apart.
Wayne Adam Ford walked into the Humboldt County Sheriff's Department in November 1998 with his brother Rodney and confessed to murder, then produced a Ziploc baggie containing a severed breast.
The episode follows Paul Steven Mack as investigators put together a murder case against him.
The case opens on Janet Cofer, a 61-year-old first grade teacher who was active in her community.
Part 7 of the Kris Kringle true crime series covering the May 2005 Groene family murders and kidnapping in Idaho.
This true crime deep investigation examines the unsolved 1987 Dardeen family massacre in Ina, Illinois—Russell, Elaine, three-year-old Peter, and newborn Casey killed in their mobile home on November 18.
On March 12, 2004, a Fresno street erupted when desperate mothers tried to retrieve children from Marcus Wesson's home.
Bill and Peggy come into focus through the ordinary life around them.
Arthur Shawcross's killings keep piling up here.
Hosts Jen and Cam detail the South African cold case of Gert van Rooyen and Joey Harhoff, a predatory couple who abducted at least six girls from the Pretoria area between 1988 and 1990.
Our True Crime Podcast covers the case of Michelle Summers McNeil, who was crowned Miss Concord in 1976 and later married Martin Joseph McNeil after meeting him at a Mormon youth singles event.
Lucy Letby’s story begins with a Chester arrest, a neonatal ward at the Countess of Chester Hospital, and a string of infant collapses that put her on the record at every major case.
Our True Crime Podcast introduces Fresh Hell, a weekly show hosted by Annie in America and Johanna in Austria, and says the pair met online about seven years ago.
Wayne Nance is tied to a 1986 attack on Doug and Chris Wells in Missoula, Montana, where he appeared at their Parker Court home, beat Doug with a baton, and was later found with photographs of Chris and handwritten notes.
Mickey Joe West, a 19-year-old nurse’s aide from St.