Appalachian true crime with bluntness.
Mountain Murders covers murder cases, missing people, and strange crime stories with a loose, porch-talk rhythm. Heather and Dylan move from everyday tangents into grim case details, keeping the tone personal without sanding off their opinions.
PRESS PLAY
Mountain Murders is a true crime show built around a familiar two-voice rhythm. Heather and Dylan bring a casual Appalachian warmth to stories that are often bleak, violent, and unresolved. The episodes do not hurry straight to the case. They may start with spring weather, birthday teasing, garden supplies, podcast network promos, merch, listener emails, or a joke that goes on just long enough to make the eventual turn feel sharper. Then the story tightens. Recent episodes move through the Freeman brothers, Shirley and Russell Dermond, Karen Beard, the Missing Millbrook Twins, Jamie Fraley, and midweek crime stories with a more headline-driven feel. The show favors timelines, local detail, and motive questions over detached narration. It lingers on ordinary objects at a scene, like a laptop, a calendar, a jewelry bag, or a movie rental envelope, because those details make violence feel closer and more troubling. Dylan often plays the skeptical reactor, pushing back on theories that feel too neat. Heather carries much of the case structure, moving from location to family background to investigation. Their chemistry makes the show feel less like a scripted report and more like two people trying to make sense of cruelty out loud. That can mean sudden jokes. It can also mean real anger. The tone is blunt, sometimes irreverent, but the victim focus still comes through. Mountain Murders works best for listeners who like true crime with personality, regional texture, and a willingness to say when something feels wrong. It is not clinical. It is talky, opinionated, and often surprisingly intimate.
Made for: For true crime listeners who like detailed case timelines, unresolved questions, and voices with a lived-in conversational rhythm. It especially fits anyone who prefers personality and regional texture over sterile narration.
What sets it apart: Mountain Murders stands apart through its Heather-and-Dylan back-and-forth: case narration mixed with skeptical reactions, local context, and everyday banter. The result is true crime that feels informal without losing sight of the victims.
East coast murders covered by Appalachian folks, Heather & Dylan. Who knew mountains could be so deadly? Are you ready to embark on a perilous journey through the treacherous peaks of true crime? Welcome to Mountain Murders True Crime, where chilling tales of mayhem and mystery await! Join our intrepid hosts as they navigate the dark side of nature, exploring crimes that will make your hair stand on end. From mysterious disappearances to shocking homicides, our podcast will have you on the edge of your seat, clutching your hiking gear tightly. So grab your headphones, strap on your adventure boots, and...
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Heather and Dylan pair detailed case chronology with candid debate, testing motives and investigative assumptions without losing sight of victims and families.
Heather and Dylan move between detailed case narratives and a looser midweek format built around current crime news. Their casework ranges from the unsolved killings of Shirley and Russell Dermond and the Caldwell Fields murders to the identification of Tent Girl as Barbara…
Heather lays out the case; Dylan supplies questions, and you get detours no courtroom would permit.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A family fracture story with warm banter and a relaxed setup.
Mountain Murders frames the Freeman family story as a slow break in trust inside one house. Brenda and Dennis Freeman are left trying to hold things together while years of counseling, an attempted hospitalization, heavy metal, drugs, alcohol, and a church dispute all seem to…
A listen built around stubborn details and easy host chemistry.
Mountain Murders opens with spring banter between Heather and Dylan, then settles into a true-crime discussion that keeps coming back to a few details that do not sit right.
A messy local-crime story with trailer-park banter and enough procedural grit to stay interesting.
Mountain Murders follows a case that starts with a self-call to police and then keeps widening out through arrests, warrants, and a brief stretch as a trailer park manager. The hosts keep the tone loose, and the trailer-park banter does a lot of the work here.
A missing mother, a custody fight, and the ache left behind.
The episode follows Karen Beard's disappearance as a custody fight with family tension at the center. Karen is last seen on January 15, 1990, after picking up her daughters in Kingston, Tennessee, dropping them at their grandparents' home, and leaving around 7:30 p.m.
A strange clue, a patient investigation, and a duo that keeps the episode easy to follow.
The Mystery of Tent Girl turns on one unusually specific clue: a tarp investigators linked to carnival tents. Mountain Murders follows that thread with an easy, unforced pace, and Heather and Dylan settle into the kind of back-and-forth that gives the story shape without…
A cold case with strong sense of place, easy banter, and a slow build into the details.
Mountain Murders treats Caldwell Fields Murders as a grounded cold case, and the setting does real work: Jefferson National Forest, Craig Creek, and the campground's two meadows give the story shape without overplaying the point.
A blunt, banter-heavy crime-news roundup with sharp edges and little patience for predators.
Mountain Murders spends its midweek check-in on the Epstein document release, the committee fight over thousands of files, and the three emails that mention Donald Trump.
A darkly funny look at the risks of real estate work in empty houses.
Mountain Murders turns real estate work into a darkly funny reminder that empty houses can be a bad place to meet strangers. Heather and Dylan keep the conversation loose and conversational, but they keep landing on the same uneasy point: a showing leaves room for bad judgment,…
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
Patrick Radden Keefe investigates whether the CIA secretly wrote a Scorpions hit.
Jake Halpern and the Snowball team track a con artist who defrauded a family.
A city-by-city true-crime documentary, from Detroit's Kwame Kilpatrick scandal to mob confessions.
A murder rumor in rural Alabama unravels into a clockmaker's suicide and estate feud.
The Freeman boys were already worrying their parents.
Spring banter gives way fast.
Garden season opens the porch talk.
This episode introduces the true crime podcast Love and Murder, which explores cases where relationships turn deadly with mystery and suspense.
Mountain Murders centers on Karen Farmer Beard, a 35-year-old mother of two from Harriman, Tennessee, who was seven and a half months pregnant when she disappeared in January 1990.
The hosts engage in irreverent banter about St.
This episode of Mountain Murders introduces a podcast about debating conspiracy theories, ranging from silly to serious topics like aliens and murder, with hosts Heather and Dylan discussing Dylan's new optimistic attitude.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
Hosts Heather and Dylan introduce a true crime podcast focused on murders in the Appalachian region, with casual banter about spring and childhood.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
Hosts discuss a bizarre crime news story about a woman driving through a crime scene and running over a deceased victim.
Hosts Heather and Dylan discuss a recent arrest in a South Carolina cold case on their true crime podcast Mountain Murders.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
Hosts Heather and Dylan discuss a murder case in Staunton, Virginia, with a lighthearted intro about their break and ice cream preferences.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
This episode discusses a former NFL player charged with murdering his girlfriend, exploring the connection between professional athletes and domestic violence crimes.
The episode introduces the podcast Mountain Murders, which covers lesser-known true crime cases from the Appalachian region, with hosts Heather and Dylan discussing a case.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
This episode introduces the podcast 'Conspiring to Argue' where hosts debate the validity of various conspiracy theories, ranging from silly to serious topics like aliens and murder.
Hosts Heather and Dylan discuss true crime cases involving murders in the Appalachian region.
This episode introduces the podcast 'Missing in the PNW', which focuses on missing person cases from marginalized communities in the Pacific Northwest region of Oregon and Washington.
The hosts discuss their personal experiences with bad haircuts and mustache mishaps at barbershops and salons, emphasizing the challenges of finding a good stylist.
Heather and Dylan open with jazz hands.
A primitive campground sets the scene.
Hosts Heather and Dylan introduce their true crime podcast focusing on murders in the Appalachian region, with a brief ad for another podcast before starting the episode.
This episode begins with an advertisement for AutoCamp and a promo for another podcast before transitioning into the true crime content.
Real estate gets risky fast.
Midweek recrap time.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
A married couple hosts a folklore podcast exploring the myths, legends, history, and customs of England's historic counties.
A true crime podcast covering murders and mysteries in the Appalachian region, hosted by Heather and Dylan.
Hosts Heather and Dylan discuss a spooky movie versus true life comparison and wrap up their October series.
Hosts Heather and Dylan introduce a Halloween-themed episode featuring listener-submitted true crime stories.
A promo for the podcast True Crime Connections, an advocacy show for survivors of toxic relationships, followed by a teaser for Mountain Murders, a true crime podcast about murders in mountainous regions.
Hosts Heather and Dylan share a personal anecdote about feeling sick after eating fast food before transitioning into a true crime case.