Caldwell Fields Murders

December 1, 2025·1 hr 20 min·7 clips

A man walking his dogs finds David shot in his car and Heidi lying dead just outside, a scene that shocked investigators.

A network promo comes first. Then Heather and Dylan settle into their usual easy back-and-forth, checking in on post-Thanksgiving food comas and joking about lasagna, Olive Garden, and needing a break. The loose start works because it makes the turn toward Caldwell Fields feel less packaged. The place does a lot of the work here. Caldwell Fields comes through as a group campground tied to George Fields, Milton Fields, and Craig Creek, with cold water nearby and the kind of setup where comfort is limited. No glamping, y'all. Heather makes it clear this is primitive camping, not a spot for hairdryers, roller sets, or a pile of extra gear. Dylan picks up the thread, and they wander through KOAs, expensive campsites, rented cabins, big RVs, outside televisions, air conditioning, and wanting to play PlayStation. The riff is funny, but it also helps. By the time the case takes over, the listener has a good feel for how open and stripped-down the campground is. The ending stays heavy without turning into a speech. The hosts sit with the sadness of lives taken for no clear reason, and one imagines what the victims might have become: missionary work, research, maybe even someone who could have cured cancer. Then the show moves quietly into thanks and Patreon housekeeping. Heather carries the case details while Dylan reacts, jokes, and keeps the tone human. The campground talk is not filler. It shows what kind of place this darkness entered.

As heard by us

A cold case with strong sense of place, easy banter, and a slow build into the details.

Mountain Murders treats Caldwell Fields Murders as a grounded cold case, and the setting does real work: Jefferson National Forest, Craig Creek, and the campground's two meadows give the story shape without overplaying the point.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a candid true-crime fix with a hint of sarcasm, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mountain Murders