It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

44 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Dark cases, Southern candor, sharp reactions.

The gist

It Wasn’t Me is an indie true crime show built around Cindy and Mercedes comparing research, reactions, and strong opinions. Recent episodes move from serial killers and Scientology to police violence, family violence, competency questions, and the uneasy line between crime, illness, and accountability.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

It Wasn’t Me is an indie true crime show shaped by research, blunt reactions, and a deliberately unvarnished conversation dynamic. Cindy and Mercedes approach each case as a story to be pieced together rather than a script to be recited. The pacing is loose, but the curiosity is serious. They stop often to compare what they know, what they remember, what they cannot verify, and what still bothers them. Recent episodes show a wide range inside the true crime lane. Belle Gunness brings the show into historical serial murder and public spectacle. Lisa McPherson’s two-part story shifts the focus toward Scientology, medical neglect claims, mental health intervention, and institutional pressure. David Bieber’s multi-part case gives them room to talk through violence, steroid use, restraining orders, police risk, recorded statements, appeals, and privacy questions. Katherine Knight’s family history leads into generational violence, youth programs, predatory access, and abuse of vulnerable children. A later episode on competency versus insanity steps back from one case to examine how criminal law handles mental illness, using examples such as Andrea Yates to test the difference between explanation and responsibility. The show is conversational by design. One speaker may bring the research; the other may push back, ask the practical question, or react with discomfort when the material gets too grim. That push and pull gives the show its texture. It can be funny in dark places, but it also admits when certain crimes are hard to handle. The speakers talk like people who know their own limits and still keep returning to the documents, timelines, and testimony. They are not trying to sound neutral. They are trying to make sense of ugly facts in plain language. The result is best suited to true crime listeners who like personality with their case work. It is less formal than a documentary series and more evidence-minded than casual gossip. The appeal is the combination: Southern charm, research notes, legal curiosity, and a willingness to say when a detail feels wrong, sad, absurd, or unresolved.

Made for: For true crime listeners who like researched cases delivered through candid conversation, strong opinions, and occasional dark humor. Best for adults comfortable with graphic crime discussion and informal banter.

What sets it apart: The show stands out by letting the research conversation stay visible: Cindy and Mercedes question each other, revisit legal details, and acknowledge uncertainty instead of sanding every case into a tidy narration.

In their own words

Welcome to "It Wasn't Me: A True Crime Podcast" where your hosts Cindy and Mercedes will dive head first into the gruesome and grizzly details of obscure and even well-known murders. So, put your kids away and join us for a murder. Oh, and don't forget to subscribe! See ya soon.

Why you'd press play

A taped call from jail sends you down Cindy and Mercedes' legal rabbit hole.

Press play if you want

  • to hear Cindy and Mercedes disagree about mental illness in a criminal case
  • to linger on the privacy questions behind a taped confession
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
serial killerscompetency and insanityScientologydomestic violence historiespolice violence and officer riskappeals and recorded statementsmental health and criminal responsibilityhistorical murders

Talks about

Best episodes of It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Competency vs. Insanity Explained - EP101Mar 27, 2026

A grounded, conversational look at competency, insanity defenses, and the hard questions raised by Andrea Yates.

Cindy and Mercedes give competency and insanity a plainspoken legal once-over, separating the ability to take part in a case from an insanity defense.

Belle Gunness: The Belle of Hell - EP100Mar 13, 2026

A grim true-crime case shaped by graphic discoveries, candid reactions, and darkly comic co-host banter.

Mercedes and Cindy give this true-crime case a grim, conversational shape, easing from loose weekly chatter into research built around bodies found in disturbing clusters.

Lisa McPherson: 17 Days Inside Scientology (part 2) - EP99Feb 27, 2026

Joan Wood's findings sharpen a tense account of damage control around the Lisa McPherson case.

Clearwater frames a tight, unsettling look at Scientology's response after Lisa McPherson's death, with Rathbun's account showing how he came to see himself as backup for Miscavige.

Lisa McPherson: 17 Days Inside Scientology (part 1) - EP98Feb 13, 2026

A minor traffic accident becomes the start of Lisa McPherson's troubling medical crisis.

Lisa McPherson's case opens with what first appears to be a minor traffic accident, then quickly turns more alarming. Witnesses describe confusion, disorientation, erratic behavior, and McPherson taking her clothes off in the road before EMTs bring her to the hospital.

David Bieber: Not that Bieber (part 3) - EP97Jan 30, 2026

A taped jail conversation opens up consent, privacy, and a question left off appeal.

The episode stays with Snipes's post-rights statements to officers, including the signed waiver and the officers' account that he never asked for an attorney.

Katherine Knight: A Family Tree of Violence - EP94Jan 9, 2026

A conversational Australian case linking family ties to abuse inside youth programs.

Catherine Knight's family connection is the way into another Australian case, with Cindy and Mercedes focusing on Neville, identified as Knight's half-brother, and the abuse he carried out while working with vulnerable children.

Podcasts like It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Competency vs. Insanity Explained - EP101

    Hidden gem

    EP101 of It Wasn’t Me explains competency versus insanity through Dusky v United States, the 1960 Supreme Court standard for standing trial.

    Mar 27, 2026·1h 12m·5 clips
  2. 2

    Belle Gunness: The Belle of Hell - EP100

    Hidden gem

    Mercedes and Cindy mark episode 100 with a Belle Gunness case built from early-1900s newspaper articles and a murder that is more than 100 years old.

    Mar 13, 2026·1h 11m·4 clips
  3. 3

    Lisa McPherson: 17 Days Inside Scientology (part 2) - EP99

    Lisa McPherson’s death in Clearwater, Florida drives part 2 of It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast, where Cindy and Mercedes follow the Church of Scientology’s response after the death.

    Feb 27, 2026·34m·3 clips
  4. 4

    Lisa McPherson: 17 Days Inside Scientology (part 1) - EP98

    It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast follows Lisa McPherson's 17-day confinement in Clearwater, Florida, after a November 18, 1995 traffic accident.

    Feb 13, 2026·59m·4 clips
  5. 5

    David Bieber: Not that Bieber (part 3) - EP97

    Hidden gem

    It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast closes its David Bieber series by tracing David Snipes' prison appeals and Bieber's sentence for the murder of PC Ian Broadhurst.

    Jan 30, 2026·59m·5 clips
  6. 6

    David Bieber: Not that Bieber (part 2) - EP96

    Hidden gem

    It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast returns to David Francis Bieber after the Boxing Day 2003 shooting of Police Constable Ian Broadhurst in Leeds and the hotel arrest of Nathan Wayne Coleman.

    Jan 23, 2026·51m·3 clips
  7. 7

    David Bieber: Not that Bieber (part 1) - EP95

    Hidden gem

    Mercedes and Cindy open It Wasn’t Me with a warning that their true-crime coverage can be graphic, profane, and full of dark humor.

    Jan 16, 2026·53m·5 clips
  8. 8

    Katherine Knight: A Family Tree of Violence - EP94

    Hidden gem

    ["It Wasn't Me: A True Crime Podcast centers this episode on Catherine Knight's family tree of violence in New South Wales, Australia.", "Cindy and Mercedes recap John Price's murder, Catherine Knight's life sentence at Silverwater Women's Correctional Center, and the claim that she was the first woman in Australian history to get that sentence.", "They then move through Ken Knight, Patrick John Ruffin, Neville Joseph Ruffin, and James Patrick Ruffin, tying child abuse, youth-center exploitation, and murder cases into one family line.", "The episode's sharpest turn is the Morgan Shepard case, where the hosts describe a headless body, 133 stab wounds, and a prison-van recording that shows how brutal the case became."]

    Jan 9, 2026·44m·2 clips
  9. 9

    Lisa Dean Moseley: Murder in the DuPont Legacy - EP93

    Hidden gem

    It Wasn't Me: A True Crime Podcast opens with Cindy saying the audio is an archived recording from around 2022 and Mercedes introducing a DuPont murder story as scandal involving American royalty.

    Jan 2, 2026·51m·3 clips
  10. 10

    Ana Trujillo: The Stiletto Killer, (part 1) - EP90

    Mercedes and Cindy reopen It Wasn't Me with episode 90, a part 1 account of the June 9, 2013 death of University of Houston researcher Alf Stefan Anderson in a Houston condo.

    Dec 26, 2025·26m·2 clips
  11. 11

    Katherine Knight: Kathy the Cannibal - EP92

    Mar 16, 2022·39m
  12. 12

    Ana Trujillo: The Stiletto Killer, (part 2) - EP91

    Feb 18, 2022·43m
  13. 13

    #75.1 - The Stiletto Killer, Ana Trujillo, part 1

    Feb 11, 2022·32m
  14. 14

    Robert Franklin Stroud: The Birdman of Alcatraz - EP89

    Jul 9, 2021·47m
  15. 15

    Rachel Hoffman: A Tragic Death (part 2) - EP88

    Jul 2, 2021·53m
  16. 16

    Rachel Hoffman: A Tragic Death (part 1) - EP87

    Jun 25, 2021·50m
  17. 17

    Rhonda Belle Martin: A Killer Waitress - EP86

    Jun 18, 2021·41m
  18. 18

    Juana Barraza: La Mataviejitas - EP85

    Jun 4, 2021·47m
  19. 19

    The Moorhouse Murders (part 2) - EP84

    May 28, 2021·36m
  20. 20

    The Moorhouse Murders (part 1) - EP83

    May 21, 2021·33m
  21. 21

    Sarah Pender: On the Run (part 2) - EP82

    May 14, 2021·34m
  22. 22

    Sarah Pender: On the Run (part 1) - EP81

    May 7, 2021·35m
  23. 23

    Sandee Rozzo: A Brutal Murder - EP80

    Apr 30, 2021·29m
  24. 24

    Miriam Rice: Who Killed Miriam Rice? - EP79

    Apr 23, 2021·42m
  25. 25

    Tina Brown: A Trailer Park Fight (part 2) - EP78

    Apr 16, 2021·1h 4m
  26. 26

    Tina Brown: A Trailer Park Fight (part 1) - EP77

    Apr 9, 2021·27m
  27. 27

    Alisha Canales McGuire: Justice for Punky - EP76

    Apr 2, 2021·30m
  28. 28

    Scissor Sisters: A Deadly Duo - EP75

    Mar 26, 2021·34m
  29. 29

    Hassan Bennett: The Case of Hassan Bennett - EP74

    Mar 19, 2021·51m
  30. 30

    Cecil Hotel: A Place of Dark History - EP73

    Mar 12, 2021·48m
  31. 31

    Speed Freak Killers: A Killing Spree (part 5) - EP72

    Mar 5, 2021·37m
  32. 32

    Speed Freak Killers: A Killing Spree (part 4) - EP71

    Feb 26, 2021·41m
  33. 33

    Speed Freak Killers: A Killing Spree (part 3) - EP70

    Feb 20, 2021·44m
  34. 34

    Speed Freak Killers: A Killing Spree (part 2)

    Feb 12, 2021·37m
  35. 35

    Speed Freak Killers: A Killing Spree (part 1) - EP68

    Feb 5, 2021·36m
  36. 36

    Ant Hill Kids: A Cult of Torture (part 4) - EP67

    Jan 29, 2021·42m
  37. 37

    Ant Hill Kids: A Cult of Torture (part 3) - EP66

    Jan 22, 2021·58m
  38. 38

    Ant Hill Kids: A Cult of Torture (part 2) - EP65

    Jan 15, 2021·1h 5m
  39. 39

    Ant Hill Kids: A Cult of Torture (part 1) - EP64

    Cindy and Mercedes introduce their true crime podcast and discuss their personal experiences with COVID-19 before beginning the episode about the Ant Hill Kids cult.

    Jan 8, 2021·45m
  40. 40

    Brandi Bernard: A Brutal Beating Death - EP63

    In this solo episode, Mercedes discusses the brutal beating death of Brandi Bernard, starting with a lighthearted story about a parakeet visiting a prison.

    Jan 1, 2021·27m
  41. 41

    Craig Chandler Price: A Teenage Killer - EP62

    Dec 25, 2020·1h 3m
  42. 42

    Miles City: The Kills On Top Brothers Murders - EP61

    Dec 18, 2020·32m
  43. 43

    Thomas Randolph: A Wife Killer (Part 2) - EP60

    In part two of EP60, hosts Mercedes and Cindy continue discussing the case of Thomas Randolph, who was acquitted in the murder of his wife Becky.

    Dec 11, 2020·47m
  44. 44

    Thomas Randolph: A Wife Killer (Part 1) - EP59

    In this episode of It Wasn't Me, hosts Mercedes and Cindy introduce the case of Thomas Randolph, a wife killer, while sharing personal holiday updates.

    Dec 4, 2020·41m