Shelley Majeres, Lysa Brown and Darryl Brown
303 episodes listed below
Witchy banter with glorious detours.
Good Witch - Bad Witch runs on familiar chatter, quick teasing, and the pleasure of a topic going sideways. Recent episodes drift from music appreciation and 70s-80s nostalgia to car collecting, household chores, comfort happiness, and Double Witch Witch question games.
PRESS PLAY
Good Witch - Bad Witch is a comedy hangout wearing a pointy hat. The show’s metadata may point toward darker curiosities, but the recent episodes behave more like a rolling conversation among people who know exactly how to derail one another. Shelly, Lisa, and Daryl build episodes from prompts, questions, personal stories, and the kind of tiny misunderstandings that can eat half a segment in the best way. It is messy by design. A Double Witch Witch episode can begin as a simple two-person format and become a debate about elevators, house cleaning, chauffeurs, fear of highway driving, and who gets to maintain the household “A.” Another installment turns a question about multi-season shows into confusion over seasons, television, Game of Thrones, Gilmore Girls, and whether somebody needs to call Shelly for clarification. The pleasure is not in efficiency. It is in hearing the group chase the funny thing that just appeared. The full trio episodes widen the table. One music-themed episode asks each witch to approach a genre they do not usually listen to, then lets hip-hop history, disco, funk, rap, opera, jazz, teenage identity, dancing badly, and music appreciation all crash together. A generation episode uses 70s and 80s memories as a doorway into marriage bits, dogs, turtles, weather, and childhood nostalgia. A happiness episode tries, with some success and several detours, to focus on good news, comfort, babies, and things that make life feel less abrasive. The show is affectionate, but it rarely gets sentimental in a straight line. It usually reaches warmth through teasing, flubs, bad impressions, half-sung fragments, domestic confession, and the decision to leave the awkward part in. Daryl’s man witch persona, Lisa’s bad witch label, and Shelly’s good witch role create a simple comic triangle, yet the chemistry matters more than the labels. Episodes often feel like a recorded group text with microphones: quick, familiar, and willing to be ridiculous. The comedy can get crude, especially around bodily jokes and innuendo, but the tone is more playful than mean. It is best for listeners who enjoy group podcasts where the side quest is the main event. Anyone looking for tight true-crime analysis or formal interviews may bounce off it quickly. Anyone who likes household chaos, nostalgia, music tangents, odd games, and friends making each other laugh will understand the appeal fast.
Made for: For listeners who like conversational comedy, friend-group chemistry, nostalgia, music tangents, and everyday stories that keep slipping into absurd side roads. It especially fits people who prefer loose group energy over structured interviews or serious analysis.
What sets it apart: Its hook is not just the witch framing, but the way the group lets mistakes, confusion, and mundane details become the episode. The show’s best moments come from the detours: cleaning metaphors, car collections, old TV, music education, pets, and jokes that grow out of being misunderstood.
Two polar opposite best friends interview fascinating guests and dish the dirt. Topics range from urban legends and the metaphysical to true crime, music history and crazy animal facts. Channel your inner witch and tune in to these comedic buddies - one salty, one sweet and a MannWitch who is quick on his feet!
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Lisa, Shelly, and Daryl turn misunderstandings, personal fixations, and hypothetical games into warm, wandering conversational comedy.
Good Witch - Bad Witch turns loosely framed topics into conversational comedy, with Lisa, Shelly, and Daryl following each other's associations instead of racing toward a tidy conclusion.
Three witches turn hip-hop history and a pom-pom hedgehog into your preferred flavor of chaos.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose domestic comedy about cleaning, driving fear, and back-seat negotiations.
Double Witch Witch gets a lot of mileage out of everyday domestic mess: who cleans, who drives, who gets rattled on the highway, and how a marriage can slide into a back-seat negotiation.
A shaggy, funny hangout where the banter matters more than the structure.
Good Witch, Bad Witch stays loose, which suits the setup. The episode moves through a catch-up, a made-up game show, and a jumble of trivia and misinformation, while Lisa, Shelly, and Daryl trade jokes, Popeye nods, car-collector talk, and a sideways discussion about selling…
A loose, funny hangout built around a TV question.
Double Witch Witch turns a listener question about favorite multi-season shows into a loose, funny hangout. Daryl Brown and Lisa Brown keep circling the wording, tossing out guesses like Game of Thrones, Gilmore Girls, Fantasy Island, and The Love Boat.
A shaggy music lesson that turns taste gaps into jokes and real insight.
The episode treats three hosts' different relationships to music as a light, easygoing lesson in how personal taste can be. It works by letting the conversation stay curious and unforced, with honest fumbles and back-and-forth instead of any claim that everyone hears songs the…
A witchy hangout that turns morbid curiosity into a funny, lived-in group chat.
Good Witch, Bad Witch leans into a witchy, beer-and-eggnog hangout to take on true crime, consumerism, labels, status, and plastic surgery. Its appeal comes less from solving a question than from watching Daryl, Lisa, and Shelly work through the same ideas with banter,…
Podcast discovery from the Sherpa Chalet.
Female crime, told with grave attention.
Shelly and Lisa start by sorting out the week’s roles: one good witch, one bad witch.
The witches open with their usual off-kilter catch-up and then drift into trivia, misfires, and a made-up game show kind of energy.
Daryl Brown and Lisa Brown kick things off with a playful double-witch twist on their usual Witch Witch Wednesday setup.
Shelley, Lisa, and Daryl start with a wobble and a laugh.
Two co-hosts discuss their podcast's irregular recording schedule after a three-week break and how it affects their workflow and personal routines.
The hosts introduce themselves and set up a nostalgic discussion about 70s and 80s childhood memories.
Two comedic best friends, one good witch and one bad witch, introduce their podcast and banter about upcoming episodes.
Two witch-themed hosts and their producer share good news and lighthearted banter to uplift listeners.
Two polar opposite best friends host a comedic interview show covering urban legends, true crime, music history, and animal facts.
The hosts introduce a Valentine's Day-themed comedic game show with playful banter and competition.
Two polar opposite best friends and a male co-host kick off season 6 with playful introductions and promises of new segments.
The hosts and their tech witch guest reminisce about 2025 in podcasting with humorous banter.
The witches come in from the holiday chaos, a little too loose on eggnog, joking about the company party, printer butt copies, and Winter Witchy Wednesday before settling into the main topic.
This episode features advertisements for Shopify and Mood.com, followed by an introduction to a trivia game show segment about the TV show Friends aimed at millennials.
This episode of Good Witch, Bad Witch features an 80s trivia game show with segments like It's My Life and Wow, hosted by Shelly, Lisa, and Daryl.
This episode of Good Witch, Bad Witch podcast discusses launching businesses with Shopify and transitions into a lighthearted, witch-themed conversation about post-Halloween entertainment and nail designs.
The hosts discuss the Netflix show 'Monster: The Ed Gein Story', analyzing its portrayal of the serial killer's influence on modern horror and true crime culture.
Two polar opposite best friends interview guests on topics ranging from urban legends to true crime with comedic banter.
Two best friends discuss pet peeves and simple pleasures in a comedic interview format.
The hosts introduce themselves and set up a discussion about the best times in their lives with comedic banter.
Two polar opposite best friends interview guests on topics ranging from urban legends to true crime with comedic banter.
Two witch-themed hosts and their friend discuss celebrity comebacks and dream band reunion tours with humorous banter.
The hosts joke about the challenges and absurdities of moving to a new home or workspace.
Two polar opposite best friends host a comedic interview show covering quirky topics with playful banter.
The hosts play a name game about celebrity real names and banter about the Man Witch's name.
Two polar opposite best friends interview guests on topics ranging from urban legends to true crime with comedic banter.
The hosts joke about a yard sale and introduce a minisode with lighthearted banter.
The hosts discuss the resentencing of the Menendez brothers, debating whether abuse excuses murder, with comedic interludes and Patreon announcements.
This episode features advertisements for Shopify and Mood.com before transitioning into a playful game show segment about witches.
Two polar opposite best friends comically interview guests about paranormal topics and true crime.
Two polar opposite best friends interview guests on topics ranging from urban legends to true crime with comedic banter.