Faculty of Horror is hosted by Andrea Subissati and Alex West, two horror scholars and writers who move between essay-style framing and conversational back-and-forth as they unpack a film's themes. Most episodes center on one or two horror films, using literary-to-film comparison (Stephen King's Apt Pupil novella versus its 1998 adaptation) or thematic pairings (teacher-student power dynamics, rape-revenge, class privilege) as an entry point into broader cultural and historical discussion. The hosts draw on secondary sources — academic books, magazine essays, news commentary — to ground their readings, citing writers like Richard V. Reeves and Alex Ross alongside directors such as David Lynch, Wes Craven, and Stanley Kubrick. Guests appear occasionally; genre critic Stacey Ponder, host of Final Girl After Dark, joined for the Eraserhead episode. Episode subjects span 1970s exploitation horror (Last House on the Left), 1990s teen slashers (I Know What You Did Last Summer), and recent releases covered in yearly best-of roundups (Weapons, Bring Her Back, Sinners). Recurring analytical threads include feminist film criticism, masculinity and patriarchy, American historical violence, class and criminal justice, and auteur theory. The tone mixes personal anecdote and banter with structured critical argument, and episodes often close with a recommendation for the next watch. Production is a two-person co-host format released as a regular series with additional bonus content on Patreon. The show has run past 140 episodes, alternating single-film deep dives with periodic year-in-review installments.