Faculty of Horror · Andrea Subissati and Alexandra West

Episode 142. Teen Dreams: I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997)

July 25, 2025·1 hr 9 min·4 clips

Alex West connects the film's hit-and-run cover-up to a personal discovery that a decade-long friend had fled sentencing for a DUI that killed two 19-year-olds.

A summer joke opens the trapdoor. Alex and Andrea start with the film's blunt hook: last summer left a secret, and the secret comes back as violence. Alex is close to this movie, and her work on the 1990s teen horror cycle gives the episode some fondness without sanding off the criticism. Andrea is more resistant. Her side eye toward slashers, especially the 1990s run, keeps the conversation from turning into a victory lap for nostalgia. The ethical turn is where the episode gets sticky. A memory about reconciling someone familiar with a serious crime drags the premise out of teen-movie neatness. Suddenly the question is less what should these kids have done and more what makes them think they can survive doing nothing. Money, family backup, booze, and presumed credibility all matter. Ray reads the imbalance before anyone else seems willing to sit with it. His lack of family or money turns into a class warning, even when the others miss it. Barry's summer decadence line hits harder in that light. It sounds less like a throwaway teen boast and more like youth, whiteness, wealth, and consequences treated as something to bargain with. Then the movie slips into folklore. The note in the envelope plays like a campfire warning, the kind of punishment story that gets passed around because it feels nasty and useful. Urban legends do two jobs here: they entertain, and they smuggle in rules about sex, risk, guilt, and crossing lines. The episode does not pretend the moral lesson is clean. It keeps asking who gets judged and who already has protection. By the end, homework, Patreon talk, and summer jokes bring back the banter, but the darker read is still sitting there.

As heard by us

A sharp, lively take on a teen slasher that still knows how to sting.

Faculty of Horror's episode on I Know What You Did Last Summer treats the film as more than a teen-slasher staple. Alex West and Andrea Subisati draw out its urban-legend mood, the privilege and guilt threaded through adolescence, and the class and economic strain running…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a slasher framed as a cautionary tale with teeth, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Faculty of Horror