Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Creepy stories with family-room chaos.

The gist

Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast treats creepy stories like group storytelling night: researched, reactive, and frequently derailed. Episodes move from missing-person cases and strange history to ski-resort ghosts, Bigfoot claims, a papal corpse trial, and maple syrup theft.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast

Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast turns crime, murder, weird history, ghosts, and weird phenomena into a family-room storytelling session. The show is loose on purpose. Episodes open with jokes, side conversations, running bits, and people talking over the shape of the day before the central story settles in. Once it does, the subjects can get bleak fast. Evelyn Nesbit, the Yuba County Five, Johnny Gosch, and other missing-person or abuse-related stories sit beside stranger curiosities like the Cadaver Synod, Bigfoot in the Sierra Nevadas, ski-resort ghosts, and the Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist. The research is conversational rather than austere. A speaker lays out timelines, names, disputed accounts, or historical context, while the others react in real time with skepticism, disgust, confusion, jokes, and moral commentary. That gives the show its shape. It is never only a case file. It is also a record of people trying to process disturbing material together without pretending to be detached from it. The group can be blunt about predators, failed investigations, sexism, institutional absurdity, and the way victims get blamed after the fact. It can also veer suddenly into jokes about old punchlines, snack containers, fictional band names, or whether a cat sounds French. The tonal whiplash is not accidental. It softens the edges without sanding them off. The result is a true-crime-adjacent hangout show for listeners who like their creepy stories opinionated, chaotic, and openly human. It is not built for anyone who needs a clean documentary pace. It is built for people who can follow a grim thread through laughter, interruptions, corrections, and the occasional completely unnecessary tangent.

Made for: Best for listeners who like crime, murder, ghosts, weird phenomena, and other creepy stories delivered through informal group banter. It suits people comfortable with dark subjects and frequent comic detours.

What sets it apart: The show’s draw is the collision between grim research and unruly family-table commentary. It treats heavy stories seriously enough to question blame and power, but casually enough to leave in the heat, jokes, tangents, and interruptions.

In their own words

Join our family while we tell some f***ed-up stories about crime and murder; ghosts, aliens and weird phenomenon; and other creepy and f***ed-up happenings.

Why you'd press play

The Yuba County Five gets a 'psychicry' detour; you get room to question the investigation.

Press play if you want

  • to ask why a missing-person search took so long alongside people asking it out loud
  • a maple syrup heist with warehouse security questions and a detour into French pronunciation
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
crime and murdermissing-person storiesweird historyghost storiesweird phenomenafamily banterdark comedy

Talks about

Best episodes of Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Episode 119: Town Ski Ghosts - Tales of Ski Resorts PastApr 11, 2026

A loose mountain-history episode where ski resorts, old deaths, and ghostly possibilities meet on the slopes.

Kelly frames a relaxed paranormal discussion around ski resorts under financial strain and the mountain history surrounding Camp Hale, where hard lives, skiing deaths, and the landscape itself leave space for ghost stories to gather.

Episode 118: Evelyn Nesbit - The Girl in the Red Velvet SwingSep 13, 2025

A lively, skeptical look at Evelyn Nesbit, Stanford White's predation, and the blame placed on women by film and history.

Evelyn Nesbit's story is approached through The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing, with the episode pushing back against the film's implication that she carried blame for what followed.

Episode 115: Syrup Cup - The Great Canadian Maple Syrup HeistFeb 8, 2025

A maple syrup warehouse, a fraudster's opening, and padlock-level security make for a strange little crime story.

Maple syrup turns into the hook for a surprisingly good crime story when Evick Caron, described as a fraudster, troublemaker, and scammer, spots how much syrup is moving through a Quebec warehouse.

Podcasts like Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Episode 119: Town Ski Ghosts - Tales of Ski Resorts Past

    Hidden gem

    A group of friends discuss neck cream and then transition into telling ghost stories about ski resorts.

    Apr 11, 2026·1h 5m·2 clips
  2. 2

    Episode 118: Evelyn Nesbit - The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing

    Hidden gem

    The hosts introduce the story of Evelyn Nesbit, a model and actress involved in a famous early 20th-century murder scandal.

    Sep 13, 2025·1h 11m·2 clips
  3. 3

    Episode 117: No Burgers - The Yuba County Five

    Hidden gem

    The hosts of FdUFF Family Story Time introduce a discussion about the Yuba County Five, a group of men who mysteriously disappeared in California in the 1980s.

    May 16, 2025·1h 14m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Episode 116: Jesus and Jason - The Cadaver Synod of 897

    Hidden gem

    A comedic discussion about the Cadaver Synod of 897, where a dead pope was put on trial.

    Mar 14, 2025·51m·2 clips
  5. 5

    Episode 115: Syrup Cup - The Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist

    Hidden gem

    The hosts of F.D.O.P.

    Feb 8, 2025·1h·2 clips
  6. 6

    Episode 114: Need Practice - The History and Haunting of Nell Gwyn

    Hidden gem

    A gray lady and the smell of gardenias connect Soho's Gargoyle Club to reported sightings of Nell Gwyn.

    Jan 27, 2025·49m·2 clips
  7. 7

    Episode 113: He's Not A Real Boy - To Catch A Predator

    Effed Up Family Storytime the Podcast examines Dateline NBC’s To Catch a Predator, hosted by Chris Hansen, and the sting operations it aired beginning in 2004.

    Jan 11, 2025·1h 7m·2 clips
  8. 8

    Episode 112: Cousin Talk - Queen Bloody Mary

    Hannah tells the story of Mary Tudor, later Queen Mary I, with Salem and Jess reacting to her dynastic and religious conflicts.

    Oct 24, 2024·59m·2 clips
  9. 9

    Episode 111: Dear Readers - The Ryman Auditorium

    Sep 13, 2024·1h 3m
  10. 10

    Episode 110: The Delicate Question - Richard Parker and The Mignonette

    Aug 5, 2024·40m
  11. 11

    Episode 109: Coercenary of the Sea - Captain Kidd & Anne Bonny

    Jul 18, 2024·48m
  12. 12

    Episode 108: Waffles & Boobs - The History & Haunting Of Moon River Brewery

    Jun 14, 2024·1h 10m
  13. 13

    Episode 107: Resting Bike Face - A Brief History Of The Lobotomy

    May 15, 2024·1h 6m
  14. 14

    Episode 106: Death Mall - The Sampoong Department Store

    Apr 25, 2024·1h 1m
  15. 15

    Episode 105: We're a Lot - The Mary Celeste

    Mar 22, 2024·55m
  16. 16

    Episode 104: His Eyes Darkened - The Lake Bodom Murders

    Feb 9, 2024·49m
  17. 17

    Episode 103: Sh*t Bra - The Murder of William Saville-Kent

    Jan 20, 2024·1h 4m
  18. 18

    Episode 102: Two Princes in a Tower - The House of Plantagenet

    Jan 4, 2024·45m
  19. 19

    Episode 101: What's in the walls?! - 657 Boulevard

    Nov 29, 2023·1h 13m
  20. 20

    Episode 100: This Is The One - Another Cop-Out Clip Show

    The hosts celebrate their 100th episode with a chaotic clip show featuring all five members.

    Oct 12, 2023·56m
  21. 21

    Episode 99: Ghost Sex - Spectrophilia

    Sep 25, 2023·35m
  22. 22

    Episode 98: Creamies - Hotel Del Salto

    Sep 12, 2023·52m
  23. 23

    Episode 97: We Like Dix - Timothy Coggins

    Aug 31, 2023·1h 15m
  24. 24

    Episode 96: Beep Beep - The Disappearance of Brandon Swanson

    Aug 18, 2023·41m
  25. 25

    Episode 95: Who Are We - Roadside Attractions

    Aug 9, 2023·42m
  26. 26

    Episode 94: One Margarita - The Killing of Julia Wallace

    Jul 24, 2023·38m
  27. 27

    Episode 93: Jeramera - Dr. Donald Cline

    Jul 17, 2023·1h 8m
  28. 28

    Episode 92: The Old Lady and His Nudeness - The YOGTZE Case

    Jul 8, 2023·1h 7m
  29. 29

    Episode 91: We Have Lift Off - Farts Throughout History

    Jun 25, 2023·57m
  30. 30

    Episode 90: Fruity Little Tube - The Disappearance of Walter Collins

    Jun 10, 2023·40m
  31. 31

    Episode 89: The Casa Bonita Winds - The Dyatlov Pass Incident

    May 27, 2023·1h 32m
  32. 32

    Episode 88: Diarrhea For Life - The Turpin Children

    May 16, 2023·56m
  33. 33

    Episode 87: Living Ghost Town - Keith Reinhard

    May 7, 2023·1h 6m
  34. 34

    Episode 86: Whoop Whoop! - Bigfoot Speaks in the Sierra Nevadas

    A humorous podcast episode where the hosts share a story about Bigfoot in the Sierra Nevadas, interspersed with personal anecdotes and banter.

    Apr 17, 2023·49m
  35. 35

    Episode 85: Keep It Mellow - Music, Weed and Bigfoot on Spy Rock Road

    Apr 8, 2023·1h 1m
  36. 36

    Episode 84: A Dirigible - The Todmorden UFO

    Mar 31, 2023·41m
  37. 37

    Episode 83: The Fun Guy - When Nature Get's Weird

    Mar 19, 2023·1h 2m
  38. 38

    Episode 82: Yuckified - The Twin Flames Universe

    Mar 11, 2023·1h 22m
  39. 39

    Episode 81: Chartreuse Goose - Teal Swan

    Mar 5, 2023·1h 39m
  40. 40

    Episode 80: Host Me! - Cursed Paintings

    Feb 18, 2023·49m
  41. 41

    Episode 79: The Sun Was Down - Johnny Gosch

    The hosts discuss the mysterious disappearance of Johnny Gosch, a 12-year-old paperboy from Iowa who vanished in 1982.

    Feb 10, 2023·1h 7m
  42. 42

    Episode 78: The Jhost - Kipland Philip Kinkel

    Feb 4, 2023·1h 49m
  43. 43

    Episode 77: Shooting Star - The Curse of Glee

    Jan 21, 2023·52m
  44. 44

    Episode 76: Spoil Tits - The Aberfan Disaster

    Jan 13, 2023·1h 7m
  45. 45

    Episode 75: Double the Burps - The Wendy's Chili Finger Incident

    The hosts of F'd Up Family Story Time banter and introduce the Wendy's chili finger incident.

    Jan 7, 2023·51m
  46. 46

    Episode 74: Fatsacks - The Sodder Family Fire

    Dec 16, 2022·1h 17m
  47. 47

    Episode 73: Button Pusher 101 - Jerome, AZ

    Dec 11, 2022·1h 16m
  48. 48

    Episode 72: We'll Be Here - Ronald Gene Simmons

    Nov 23, 2022·59m
  49. 49

    Episode 71: The Fab Four - The Burke and Hare Murders

    The hosts of F'd Up Family Storytime discuss the infamous Burke and Hare murders in 19th century Scotland.

    Nov 13, 2022·58m
  50. 50

    Episode 69.2: A Tiny Sewing Machine - Cassie Stoddart

    Nov 8, 2022·1h 1m