500 episodes listed below
Dating chaos with a human center.
Nicole Byer talks through dating, sex, attraction, bodies, sexuality, and relationship expectations with guests who do not tidy up the story first. The result is messy, quick, intimate comedy with enough candor to make the jokes land somewhere real.
PRESS PLAY
Why Won’t You Date Me? is a relationship comedy show where dating stories are allowed to be ugly, funny, horny, awkward, and unexpectedly tender in the same breath. Nicole Byer sits with guests and follows the live wire of whatever they bring in: a jealous boat date, a punishing running date, a partner who understands BPD spirals, or the question of whether chemistry matters if the values do not line up. It is fast. The conversations tend to move by interruption, reaction, and clarification, which gives the show the feeling of a table full of sharp friends refusing to let a weird detail pass unexamined. Sex comes up plainly. So do bodies, work, travel, independence, astrology, public attention, reproductive health, gender, sexuality, and the strange little rules couples invent to stay attracted to each other. A guest might talk about being questioned about their body before anyone asks their name, then pivot into what kind of partner could actually handle their life. Another might use a bad matchmaker setup to explain what security and passion looked like before marriage. The show is not tidy advice. It is more interested in the stuff people say after the polite version has failed. That is where it gets useful. Beneath the wild stories is a recurring question about being known without having to shrink: by a date, by a partner, by a crowd, or by someone who has to understand work that happens at night. The comedy stays close to the mess. It can be gross, direct, and chaotic, but the best moments come when the show lets an outrageous story reveal a real standard. A good partner is not presented as a fantasy object. They are someone whose timing, morals, appetite for travel, emotional steadiness, and ability to handle attention might actually fit the life in front of them. For all its bluntness, the show is warm. It makes embarrassment feel like evidence, not failure.
Made for: For listeners who like candid relationship comedy, frank sex talk, guest stories, and conversations that move quickly without sanding off the mess.
What sets it apart: The show stands out by pairing raunchy, highly specific dating stories with real questions about compatibility, sexuality, bodies, work, and emotional safety. It is less polished advice than funny, direct excavation.
Love and dating can be messy—so let’s talk about it! On this multi-award-winning podcast, comedian Nicole Byer explores romantic highs, lows, and all the juicy stuff in between, alongside comedians, experts, and sometimes an ex or two. New episodes every Friday!
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Nicole Byer turns candid guest conversations into sharp, funny observations about intimacy, identity, self-knowledge, and partnership.
Nicole Byer turns dating questions into loose, funny interviews where guests explain the lived mechanics behind attraction, partnership, and self-knowledge.
A boat date takes an air-humping detour; your group chat would want the full report.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A candid relationship-centered look at abandonment fears, balanced by humor, care, and clear self-awareness.
Borderline personality disorder comes through most clearly in the strain it can place on a relationship, especially when fear of abandonment makes a partner feel halfway gone even after three and a half years together.
A chaotic dating conversation finds its sharpest shape in the gap between chemistry and compatibility.
Dating opens the episode onto the less tidy parts of attraction: the spark that shows up before values, morals, timing, or a shared sense of direction have been tested.
A dating conversation where overconfident effort keeps missing the simple need to listen.
A dating chat becomes a sharp little study of confidence landing in all the wrong places. One story centers on a third date shaped around half-marathon training, with the man turning the run into his own coaching session: clapping, placing a hand on her back, sprinting ahead,…
A funny, candid episode about body scrutiny, dating, and the work of being understood.
Known as The Body from Dragula season five and winner of Hot House season one, the guest meets public fixation with a clear, cutting answer: people often skip past who she is and go straight to questions about whether her back hurts or whether her body is real.
A filthy, warm conversation where sexual candor keeps steering the comedy.
Nicole Byer's conversation with Sapphira Cristal is led by sexual openness, with Cristal talking through pansexuality, coming out while dating someone already out, and keeping that relationship physical afterward.
A candid dating conversation where karaoke, drinking, and a Hilton memory sharpen the gap between habit and connection.
Dating becomes a way to ask whether a life still fits the person living it. The episode moves from a blunt admission about binge drinking costing her the next day to a favorite first date built on eating, karaoke, pool, and real conversation.
A raunchy boat story leads into a candid conversation about chemistry, values, and timing.
A chaotic dating story opens the door to a more useful question about romantic compatibility: what is left once chemistry has done its work? The conversation balances attraction against alignment, using the boat-date incident as its loudest hook.
Stockholm hosts James Royal-Lawson and Per Axbom interview UX and accessibility experts.
Monocle's design team tours museums, furniture studios, and landmark houses each week.
Comedian Nicole Byer interviews actor Nathan Mitchell about dating, astrology, and his career.
Comedian Robby Hoffman discusses strategies for attracting wealthy partners, interspersed with personal anecdotes and sponsor messages.
Bobby Berk shares tips on how to subtly improve your partner's taste in home decor without causing conflict.
Comedian Nicole Byer interviews drag legend Adore Delano about dating, relationships, and personal growth.
Ms.
Nicole Byer opens Why Won't You Date Me?
Nathan Mitchell tells Nicole Byer that a woman he was dating crawled over a gay man on a boat and started air humping him, while two women nearby apologized to him.
["Danielle Fishel tells Nicole Byer that she married a high-school acquaintance she first met in 1995, then reconnected with in 2017 after a blue heart on Twitter and a Rebecca Black thread.
Comedian Drew Droege reads hilarious Yelp-style reviews of sexual encounters, then pivots to a serious discussion about the importance of Planned Parenthood and reproductive rights.
Kym Whitley discusses her dating experiences and preferences, followed by a conversation about planning quality trips with friends using Airbnb.
Nicole Byer talks with Fantasia Royale Gaga, known from Dragula season five and Hot House season one, about her body, dating, and life as “The Body.” Fantasia describes 3,400 CC implants, an internal bra from Dr.
Nicole Byer and Sapphira Cristál spend much of the episode on sex logistics, including open-relationship rules, toy categories, and Sapphira's line, "I'm not a bottom." Sapphira also describes how she met her partner on Instagram after liking all of his posts and how a "twink pageant for meatball" became part of their dating story.
Bobby Berk shares tips on how to subtly improve your partner's taste in home decor and design.
Adore Delano shares stories about hooking up with go-go dancers and a wild hookup in Toronto after Drag Race.
This episode features a conversation about bizarre relationships with animals, but the transcript only includes ads and promotional content.