Tall tales, real history, and a glass on the bar.
Why Whiskey? sets American history at what host Ian calls the Bar of Questionable Life Choices, with whiskey poured and tasted as the stories unfold. Its American Legend Series tests Molly Pitcher, Pecos Bill, Paul Bunyan and John Henry against the record, beside episodes on Aaron Burr's treason trial and activist Clara Lemlich.
PRESS PLAY
Why Whiskey? greets its audience with a question it declines to answer: is this a history podcast with a whiskey problem, or a whiskey podcast with a history problem? The show leaves that one to the room. The setting, at least, is settled. It is a bar that Ian, the host, calls the Bar of Questionable Life Choices, where a stool and a drink are offered before the first story starts. The history in these episodes is American, ranging from cowboy tall tales to the labor fights of early 20th century New York City. The clearest thread is the American Legend Series, in which Ian sets out to pick apart fact from fiction and legend from reality. 'The American Legend Series Part 1 - Molly Pitcher with Alycia from Civics and Coffee Podcast' brings a guest to the bar and weighs another contender for the real Molly: Margaret Corbin, born Margaret Cochran in Western Pennsylvania in 1751. Pecos Bill gets his résumé read out, from being raised by coyotes to taming a wild horse and digging the Rio Grande, and the question of where those stories came from waits until the next pour. Paul Bunyan and Babe the blue ox come with guest Chance Whitmore, and the conversation drifts into Chance's years in education. The John Henry episode is where the digging gets serious. Working from historian Scott Reynolds Nelson's archival research, Ian follows a John William Henry sentenced in April 1866 to ten years in the Virginia Penitentiary for breaking and entering, a charge he says should have drawn maybe a year. Black codes and unchecked racism, Ian says plainly, account for the difference. The trail runs on through railroad records to a likely lease with the C&O Railroad near the Lewis Tunnel. The recap at the top of that episode notes that only Molly Pitcher had so far earned the big red fact stamp. Outside the series, the show turns to a courtroom and a strike. The episode subtitled 'The Aaron Burr Treason Trial' follows Burr from a scheme to raise an army and annex another nation into the courtroom of Chief Justice John Marshall, whose 34-year tenure Ian sets against a 16-year average and judges 'a little extra.' Alycia also joins for an episode on Clara Lemlich, a Jewish immigrant from Russia who fought for better pay and working conditions for women workers in New York City. The whiskey is more than a prop. Pours are numbered and described on air, among them a blend of straight rye whiskeys from High West Distillery in Park City, Utah, and a rye hot enough to need a water chaser. The register stays loose and conversational: Burr's plan is simply 'so weird', and history's odder turns get filed under shenanigans. Episodes sign off with an invitation to email the show with comments or questions, or to join Ian at the bar for an episode. For a first listen, the legend series is the easiest way in, since every installment circles the same fact-or-fiction question.
Made for: Suits a listener who enjoys American history and folklore told in a relaxed, bar-stool register, and who likes hearing whiskey poured and talked about alongside the story.
What sets it apart: Pours are numbered and tasted mid-story, so the drinking sets the pace of the history. The American Legend Series puts folk heroes such as Pecos Bill and John Henry to a fact-or-fiction test against the archive.
This podcast will talk about history, whiskey, and everything in between. Ian McGlynn hosts a light-hearted show that aims to educate and inspire those on a journey through history and whiskey.New cover art by D-Sane https://www.instagram.com/dsane8/
At Ian's Bar of Questionable Life Choices, you can demand receipts from Paul Bunyan.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A railroad legend meets prison records, tunnel dust, and the stubborn machinery of folklore.
Why Whiskey? pushes the John Henry legend past the familiar ballad and into the harsher ground around prison labor, railroad pressure, and the dust of the Lewis Tunnel.
Paul Bunyan's outsized legend gets a warm barroom test of how much truth a tall tale can carry.
Paul Bunyan comes through as both myth and measuring stick: the huge frame, long strides, oversized strength, mighty axe, and blue ox Babe are all part of the fun before the episode turns to whether any of it can bear scrutiny.
Pecos Bill's impossible exploits get tested against history over a rye whiskey pour.
Pecos Bill lands as American folklore at its most outsized, built from impossible feats, shifting endings, and the kind of details that seem designed to outrun fact-checking.
A whiskey-laced look at Molly Pitcher, Margaret Corbin, and the gap between legend and lived history.
Molly Pitcher arrives as a legend with the shine partly rubbed off. Why Whiskey? opens its run on American stories that may have been polished by retelling, then sets the familiar image of a woman pulled into battle beside her husband against the harder question of who she…
Curious facts, kid-sized and quiz-ready.
Ian frames John Henry as a test case for American folklore, contrasting him with Molly Pitcher, Paul Bunyan, and Pecos Bill while centering the Lewis Tunnel and the C&O Railroad.
Paul Bunyan is presented as a late-1800s tall tale that later research by Bernice Stewart and Homer A.
Ian frames Why Whiskey's Pecos Bill episode around the line "toughest critter west of the Alamo," then follows the legend's wagon fall, coyote upbringing, Widowmaker horse, and snake-lasso origin.
Why Whiskey?
John Marshall's opinion turned Burr's treason case on the definition of presence, not politics.
Why Whiskey?
Ian of Why Whiskey?
Ian’s Why Whiskey episode returns after his family moves to Michigan and he prepares to retire from the United States Army in 2022.
This episode covers Clara Lemlich, a Jewish immigrant who led a major women's strike in early 20th century New York City.
Host Ian McGlynn welcomes guest Kevin for a conversation about whiskey and history.
This episode explores the Salem Witch Trials of 1692, discussing the historical injustice and its impact, with guest hosts from the Booze and Bourbon Podcast.
The host discusses the history of talk radio and its transition to podcasting, interviewing a guest with radio industry experience.