Cozy delivery, sinister true crime.
TrueCrimeIRL treats murder cases, suspicious deaths, and missing-person stories as dark bedtime material. Its recent run moves between “True Crime Sleep Stories” and loose bonus chats with people connected to other true crime projects.
PRESS PLAY
TrueCrimeIRL builds its recent identity around an uneasy pairing: comfort rituals and disturbing crime stories. The “True Crime Sleep Stories” episodes invite a quiet, nighttime setting, then move into murder, suspicious death, occult rumors, mental illness, and brutal violence. That contrast is the point. A listener gets warm blankets and dark material in the same package. The recent case range includes “The Diabolical Dolly Öesterreich,” “The Devilish Death of Jeannette DePalma,” “The Kurt Struebing Story: A Tale of Murder and Mental Illness with Peachy Death,” “The Farmville Murders,” and “The Papin Sisters.” Across that run, the show returns to bodies found in strange circumstances, domestic violence, historical notoriety, rumors that grow around a case, and the difficulty of making sense of extreme acts. The writing can be direct and gruesome. It can also be playful in a macabre, bedtime-story way. Guest-hosted entries bring in different voices without losing the basic setup of a sinister story told in a sleep-friendly frame. The bonus episodes are looser. Morgan from Crimepedia Podcast talks podcasting and ordinary clutter. Jeff Ignatowski discusses Killers, the card game, including how true crime people notice details other players might miss. The Captain from True Crime Garage talks about show identity, social media, and keeping victims closer to the center of true crime work. Those conversations make the show feel connected to a wider true crime community rather than sealed inside case narration. TrueCrimeIRL is not polished into a distant documentary tone. It is informal, theatrical, occasionally odd, and comfortable with tonal whiplash. That can be jarring. It can also be the thing that makes the show distinct. The strongest thread is the collision between cozy delivery and grim subject matter, where “good night” can arrive after a story about secrets, violence, and unanswered questions.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime with atmosphere, not a neutral casefile tone. Best fit for someone comfortable with bedtime framing around very dark material.
What sets it apart: TrueCrimeIRL sets itself apart by combining sleep-story cues with murder cases and informal bonus conversations from the true crime creator scene. The show’s appeal comes from that uneasy mix of cozy ritual, macabre storytelling, and loose community chat.
TrueCrimeIRL is a podcast hosted by native Iowan, Kelli Berens-Brink. Kelli discusses murder and missing persons cases, as well as cold cases from across the nation. You'll enjoy first-hand accounts of crimes, told from Kelli's own unique and quirky perspective. Kelli includes many guests, such as law enforcement, lawyers, victims, perps, and more. Tune into TrueCrimeIRL, and visit TrueCrimeIRL.com for more info. Follow us on social media @ TrueCrimeIRL.
A stalker's letters for bedtime; a burger-is-a-sandwich argument when you need to come up for air.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A relaxed Crimepedia introduction, with cross-border unsolved cases, Santa May Be a Criminal connections, and a Roman Burger detour.
Morgan's visit frames Crimepedia as more than a simple true-crime recommendation. She co-hosts the show with Cherry, who is from England, and their cases usually move between the United States and the UK, with unsolved stories at the center.
A dry, uneasy look at a true-crime card game’s mechanics, appeal, and moral tension.
Jeff Ignatowski, creator of Killers the Card Game, talks through a premise built to invite discomfort: players abduct and kill victims, avoid police, and plant evidence.
A loose bathroom chat turns into a candid reset on purpose, audience, and keeping victims centered.
True Crime Garage's Captain joins Patch from his bathroom, with Bailey's coffee nearby and Yellowstone put on hold, for a casual talk about the messier side of podcasting.
Measured true crime with uneasy questions.
TrueCrimeIRL talks with Morgan from Crimepedia about a show that splits U.S.
Kelly's Cheap Heat Productions interview with Jeff Ignatowski centers on Killers the Card Game, a serial-killer card line that Ignatowski says has sold more than 1,000 units in eight countries.
Patch interviews the Captain from True Crime Garage about a possible new contract, nearly 650 episodes, and the show’s early production history.
TrueCrimeIRL's sleep-story episode examines the June 9, 1912, Villisca, Iowa, axe murders of the Moore family and two Stillinger guests.
The Watcher case centers on 657 Boulevard, a six-bedroom Westfield, New Jersey home bought by Derek and Maria Broaddus for $1.4 million.
TrueCrimeIRL's Halloween special gathers 31 stories from 31 crime podcasts, including a report on Carl Girard's 2020 Quebec City sword attack.
In TrueCrimeIRL’s Halloween anthology, exchange student Yoshi Hatori was shot after arriving at the wrong Baton Rouge address for an October 1992 party.
Shane Waters introduces crime stories from True Crime Island, Based on a True Story, Asian Madness, Sisters Who Kill, and Hometown History.
Host Kelli Berens-Brink continues a deep dive series on the Anthony Garcia murder case, discussing his arrest and background.
Host Kelli Berens-Brink and guests from Defense Diaries examine the Anthony Garcia serial murder case, questioning whether he is a serial killer or a revenge-driven psychopath.
Host Kelli Berens-Brink and defense attorney Bob Mata discuss the Anthony Garcia serial killer case, questioning whether he actually committed the murders.
Host Kelli Berens-Brink interviews defense attorney Bob Mata about the Anthony Garcia case, involving two double murders linked to a former medical resident.