True Crime Stories Podcast

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Murder cases told plainly, then followed past the verdict.

The gist

The host tells each case in order, from the people involved through the crime and the investigation, then keeps going past the sentence to parole, burials and the documentaries and films the case later inspired. Several of the stories turn on a marriage.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About True Crime Stories Podcast

True Crime Stories Podcast is a narrated true crime show built around single cases, told in order from the people involved to the aftermath. The host is not named here. The voice is plain and conversational, not theatrical. Several episodes carry nothing but a first name after the season and episode number: Carol, Gretchen, Cork. The cases cover a lot of ground. One follows a homemaker who, on a March morning in 1963, made breakfast for her family, went back to bed and was attacked by an intruder; early on, her husband became the prime suspect. Another is set in an Amish community, and the host sets it against how rare such killings are there, pointing back to an earlier episode called Katie that also involved an Amish community. A third centers on a fire that killed a man named Cork, and on Lucille, who was at the scene. 'S4 E9: The murder that inspired the opening scene of the movie Jeepers Creepers' follows a husband who became paranoid and controlling through a 1989 divorce to a police chase that ended before dawn, and it closes on the line 'Sometimes, real life is scarier than fiction.' Several of these stories turn on a marriage. The crimes are described in hard detail. Stabbings, a bludgeoning, sexual assault and the death of a child all come up in recent episodes. 'S4 E6: Halloween Series-Exorcisms' collects more than one story, including that of a young girl who died on a church altar after relatives decided she was possessed. What stands out most is how far past the crime each story runs. The endings cover parole terms and eligibility dates, where victims and killers are buried, that relatives are raising the children, and the debts a killer's mother was left with after paying his legal team. In one case, a daughter is credited with writing a 2006 newspaper article about her own mother's case. The host also lists the print and screen versions each case produced: a 2006 book, episodes of A Crime to Remember and Killer Couples, a Lifetime TV movie. That habit turns the show into a useful map to other coverage of the same case. Occasionally the narration breaks off for a personal aside, such as doubting a shooter's claim that she only meant to scare, or allowing that anyone would bite a finger forced down their throat. The host also speaks to listeners directly, opening one episode by apologizing for a delay after catching COVID. Every episode in this run starts with a sponsor read in the host's own voice, and several end with a simple thank-you for listening. The result is a plain record of what happened and what followed.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime told as a straight, chronological account and cares what happened afterwards: parole, burials, and the families left behind. It also fits someone curious about the real cases behind TV movies and films such as Jeepers Creepers.

What sets it apart: Rather than stopping at the sentence, the show follows each case into its aftermath, recording parole dates, burials and what became of the children. It also names the books, TV episodes and films a case went on to produce, including the murder behind the opening scene of Jeepers Creepers.

In their own words

I love True Crime stories and want to find out what drives people to that place - why murder someone? Love? Money? Anger? Let's find out together! To protect the victims, I only use First Names..*Listener Discretion is advised, strong language describing crime scenes*Follow me on FaceBook - True Crime Stories Podcast

Why you'd press play

A club-kid murder confession goes unreported, and you may find yourself asking how that happens.

Press play if you want

  • to question a crash story alongside the skid marks and the milk cartons that stayed upright
  • to follow what police and reporters did while a victim's brother searched for answers
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
murders within marriagesdomestic violence and controlsentencing, parole and aftermathcases adapted for TV and filmkillings in Amish communitiesdeaths tied to exorcismprime suspects and police investigations

Talks about

Best episodes of True Crime Stories Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

S4 E10: CorkNov 5, 2024

A car fire becomes a careful test of grief, evidence, and the story told beside the wreck.

"Cork" is strongest when it lets the roadside evidence do the work. Lucille's account sits uneasily beside the fire scene: the nail, broken window, branch, short skid marks, upright milk cartons, tipped gasoline can, low gear, and tire tracks dug into gravel all push the case…

Podcasts like True Crime Stories Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Season 4 Episode 14: Carol

    Dec 18, 2024·12m
  2. 2

    S4 E12: Amish Stud

    Dec 3, 2024·18m
  3. 3

    S4 E11: Gretchen

    Nov 6, 2024·20m
  4. 4

    S4 E10: Cork

    True Crime Stories Podcast S4 E10: Cork follows Lucille and Cork from Winnipeg and Walla Walla College to San Bernardino County, where a 1964 nighttime car fire becomes a murder case.

    Nov 5, 2024·22m·1 clip
  5. 5

    S4 E9: The murder that inspired the opening scene of the movie Jeepers Creepers

    Oct 29, 2024·12m
  6. 6

    S4 E8 Halloween Series: Zack and Addie

    Oct 22, 2024·21m
  7. 7

    Bonus Episode: Thanksgiving Murders

    Oct 7, 2024·19m
  8. 8

    S4 E7: Halloween Series: Witches

    Oct 7, 2024·20m
  9. 9

    S4 E6: Halloween Series-Exorcisms

    Sep 23, 2024·20m
  10. 10

    S4 E5: Adrianne

    Sep 23, 2024·10m
  11. 11

    S4 E4 Sophie

    True Crime Stories Podcast examines the September 2017 killing of 21-year-old French au pair Sophie in southwest London.

    Sep 16, 2024·32m·2 clips
  12. 12

    Bonus Episode: Friday the 13th

    Sep 10, 2024·20m
  13. 13

    S4 E3: Caril Ann

    Sep 9, 2024·13m
  14. 14

    S4 E1: Laurie

    Sep 2, 2024·15m
  15. 15

    The first trial by media case S3 E20

    The episode begins with a HelloFresh ad before diving into a true crime case analysis exploring motives for murder.

    Jan 16, 2024·35m
  16. 16

    Wanda S3 E19

    Jan 9, 2024·19m
  17. 17

    Bridget S3 E18

    Jan 2, 2024·14m
  18. 18

    Bonus Episode: New Year’s S3 E17

    True Crime Stories Podcast examines the January 1, 1998 disappearance of Ben, 21, and Olivia, 17, from Farno Lodge in New Zealand’s Marlborough Sounds.

    Dec 26, 2023·30m·2 clips
  19. 19

    Bonus Episode: Horrifying Holiday Stories S3 E16

    Dec 22, 2023·21m
  20. 20

    Marie, Eric and Butch S3 E15

    Dec 19, 2023·15m
  21. 21

    Lobster Boy S3 E14

    Dec 5, 2023·17m
  22. 22

    Angel S3 E13

    True Crime Stories Podcast examines Andre "Angel"'s disappearance from New York City's Club Kids scene in March 1996.

    Nov 28, 2023·30m·2 clips
  23. 23

    Bonus Episode: 50th episode! S3 E12

    Nov 25, 2023·18m
  24. 24

    Missy S3 E11

    Nov 21, 2023·19m
  25. 25

    Francine S3 E10

    Nov 14, 2023·15m
  26. 26

    Munchausen by proxy cases S3 E9

    The host defines Munchausen by proxy (factitious disorder imposed on another) as a condition in which a caregiver presents someone as sick or injured to gain attention and sympathy, not money.

    Nov 3, 2023·1h 14m·2 clips
  27. 27

    Halloween Series: Ghosts S3 E8

    Oct 24, 2023·16m
  28. 28

    Halloween Series: Sava the Vampire S3 E7

    Oct 17, 2023·8m
  29. 29

    Halloween Series: Halloween Homicides S3 E6

    Oct 10, 2023·20m
  30. 30

    Thanksgiving Murders S3 E5

    Oct 3, 2023·17m
  31. 31

    Steven S3 E4

    Sep 26, 2023·13m
  32. 32

    Marlene and Chuck S3 E3

    The episode recounts the 1975 murder of a couple by their 16-year-old daughter and her boyfriend, known as the Barbecue Murders.

    Sep 19, 2023·27m
  33. 33

    Jasmine S3 E2

    Jasmine S3 E2 of True Crime Stories Podcast recounts the 2009 San Diego murder of 28-year-old model Jasmine.

    Sep 11, 2023·33m·1 clip
  34. 34

    Patricia and Frank S3 E1

    A 1972 Thunderbird found in Chicago led police to Frank and Mary’s home in Elk Grove Village, where they discovered the couple and 13-year-old Michael dead.

    Sep 4, 2023·52m·2 clips
  35. 35

    Nancy / Season 2 Episode 17

    May 15, 2023·14m
  36. 36

    The wrongful Conviction of James / Season 2 Episode 16

    The episode begins with a supplement ad, then introduces the case of James, a man wrongfully convicted and released after 21 years.

    May 9, 2023·31m
  37. 37

    Bonus Episode: When gloves became standard equipment at crime scenes

    May 2, 2023·20m
  38. 38

    Gary’s dungeon

    This episode recounts a 1987 Philadelphia case where police discovered a torture chamber with three women chained in a basement.

    Apr 25, 2023·30m
  39. 39

    Online Dating Murder

    Apr 19, 2023·15m
  40. 40

    Bonus Episode: History of Miranda Rights

    Apr 11, 2023·12m
  41. 41

    Lonely Heart Killers

    Apr 4, 2023·16m
  42. 42

    Bonus Episode: Easter Sunday Massacre

    Apr 4, 2023·15m
  43. 43

    Linda

    The host introduces a true crime story about a murder case, beginning with a sponsor ad for Organic Aromas diffusers.

    Mar 28, 2023·29m
  44. 44

    The Unsolved Murder of Christina

    Mar 21, 2023·20m
  45. 45

    Maria

    Mar 14, 2023·18m
  46. 46

    Pig Farmer Murders

    Mar 6, 2023·17m
  47. 47

    Yosemite Murders Part 2

    Feb 28, 2023·30m
  48. 48

    Yosemite Murders Part 1 - Steven's Story

    Feb 20, 2023·21m
  49. 49

    Bonus Episode: Valentine's Day

    Feb 7, 2023·12m
  50. 50

    Is it Love and or Hate?

    Jan 23, 2023·14m