True Crime DEADLINE

48 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Murder trials and unsolved cases, from inside the courtroom.

The gist

Matt Johnson covers cases such as the Lori Vallow Daybell trial, the Gilgo Four killings and the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, sometimes describing what he saw from inside the courtroom. Case updates share space with interviews with victims' relatives and FBI recordings of the serial killer Samuel Little.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About True Crime DEADLINE

True Crime DEADLINE is a true crime podcast from Matt Johnson that stays close to specific cases, to the courtrooms where they are tried and to the families left behind. The Lori Vallow Daybell case, labeled CULT in its episode titles, comes up in more than one episode. Johnson says he was at the Ada County Courthouse every day of the trial. He describes a fourth-floor courtroom that was almost standing room only, and cheers erupting in front of the building. Testimony, as he sums it up, took in spells, prophets, gods and goddesses and portals, though he argues that at its root the case was about sex, greed and power. Lori Vallow Daybell was found guilty of killing her children, JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan, and of conspiring to kill Tammy Daybell. JJ's grandparents, Kay and Larry Woodcock, speak after the verdict. His grandfather's memories are the emotional center: the night he calmed a crying, agitated JJ, the bond that followed, and a child who was reading, writing and doing math in his head by three. It is difficult listening. In '43 - CULT: Lori Vallow-Daybell Trial: Lori's Cousin Speaks Out', a family member explains following the trial mostly through the raw courtroom audio rather than other people's commentary, and calls the testimony heartbreaking. The episodes labeled SERIAL take a different angle. Johnson describes Rex Heuermann, charged in the Gilgo Four murders, turning to glance at the media in the front rows, Johnson among them. He puts the open questions plainly: whether Heuermann is guilty, whether he acted alone, and whether more than one killer is involved. Johnson also spoke with Heuermann's wife while covering the case. She filed for divorce after the arrest and is described as working on a documentary project. The Samuel Little episode uses interview recordings the FBI shared from its vault to help close cold cases. An FBI crime analyst explains how Little read a crowd and picked out people whose absence might go unnoticed for days, and Johnson calls the killer's calm, remorseless manner chilling. On the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the discussion covers Savannah Guthrie's emotional interview with Hoda Kotb, the ransom notes and the blood on the porch, and one participant says they thought the notes were bogus from day one. 'EP 3: THIS week in TRUE CRIME with Matt Johnson' works as a roundup: week ten of the Guthrie investigation, a trial date for a former American Idol hopeful accused of killing his wife, and a Hawaii doctor accused of trying to throw his wife off a cliff taking the stand. It also stops on procedure, including a judge's concern that sending a jury home for too long invites outside exposure and a mistrial. Johnson greets listeners as 'Investigators' or as the 'True Crime Fam', asks them in the comments whether they believed the testimony, and presents the show as an independent podcast up against networks, studios and TV channels. One episode signs off in honor of Mr. Gatsby, a crime-fighting canine. More than one ends by telling listeners that tips go to the police.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants trial coverage and case updates from someone who was in the courthouse. It also suits someone ready for hard testimony about murdered children and serial killings.

What sets it apart: What sets it apart is being there: Matt Johnson describes what he saw in court, and the episodes make room for people close to the cases, from JJ Vallow's grandfather to an FBI crime analyst working from Samuel Little's recorded interviews.

In their own words

Dive into true crime with Emmy Award–winning journalist Matt Johnson as he explores cold cases, unsolved mysteries, homicides, and real-life murder investigations. Featuring firsthand reporting and exclusive insights, this podcast uncovers the stories behind the crimes that still haunt him. Perfect for fans of true crime podcasts, criminal justice, and unsolved cases. Follow YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimewithMattJohnson Website: http://www.truecrimedeadline.com/

Why you'd press play

Missing footprints become your next question as Matt Johnson talks through a case with a crime-scene investigator.

Press play if you want

  • to weigh a ransom-note theory against what investigators can see at the scene
  • to hear an FBI analyst explain how Samuel Little chose vulnerable victims
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Lori Vallow Daybell trialSerial killer casesNancy Guthrie disappearanceCourtroom and trial updatesVictims' familiesCold cases

Talks about

Best episodes of True Crime DEADLINE

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Nancy Guthrie Case: "NOT COLD" - CSI Breaks Down "New Clues”Apr 6, 2026

A measured True Crime episode tests the blood, ransom notes, and propped-open back door against what the evidence can actually support.

Nancy Guthrie's disappearance gives this True Crime episode a tight, evidence-led focus: what do the blood on the porch, the ransom notes, and the propped-open back door really support?

50 - CULT: Doomsday Prophet: Victim's Grandfather Speaks OutApr 1, 2024

Larry Woodcock's memories of J.J. bring a family-centered weight to the lead-up to Chad Daybell's trial.

The episode looks ahead to Chad Daybell's next trial through Larry Woodcock, whose family is facing another courtroom chapter after Lori Vallow Daybell was found guilty of killing her children and conspiring to kill Tammy Daybell.

49 - SERIAL: The Long Island Serial KillerMar 18, 2024

A still-unsettled case is measured against the private shock felt by one family and its community.

The Long Island serial killer case is handled less like a solved story than an open wound. Rex Heuermann, charged in the murders of the victims known as the Gilgo Four, is seen briefly facing the media before leaving with his attorneys, but the episode stays with the larger…

Podcasts like True Crime DEADLINE

Episodes

  1. 1

    Nancy Guthrie Case: "NOT COLD" - CSI Breaks Down "New Clues”

    Hidden gem

    True Crime DEADLINE covers the Nancy Guthrie disappearance through Savannah Guthrie's Today interview and a CSI breakdown of the evidence.

    Apr 6, 2026·34m·2 clips
  2. 2

    Nancy Guthrie Case: Did Nancy Text Her Kidnapper? FBI Agent Interview

    Apr 6, 2026·23m
  3. 3

    Nancy Guthrie Case: DAY 60 - Is she Still in Arizona?

    Apr 6, 2026·25m
  4. 4

    EP 3: THIS week in TRUE CRIME with Matt Johnson

    Apr 3, 2026·13m
  5. 5

    EP 2: THIS week in TRUE CRIME with Matt Johnson

    Matt Johnson discusses upcoming court appearances and guilty pleas for accused killers Rex Heuermann and Brian Koberger, along with Savannah Guthrie's first comments on her mother's abduction.

    Mar 28, 2026·27m
  6. 6

    50 - CULT: Doomsday Prophet: Victim's Grandfather Speaks Out

    ["Larry Woodcock repeats 'Where are the children?' as Matt Johnson opens episode 50 with Lori Vallow Daybell's guilty verdict outside the Ada County Courthouse in Boise.", "Johnson then pivots to Chad Daybell's upcoming Idaho trial, where Chad faces the death penalty and the state may add DNA evidence tied to Tammy Daybell.", "Woodcock describes taking JJ Vallow in through Child Services, saying the boy cried during his first bath before calming when Larry spoke to him.", "The interview stays focused on JJ and Tylee Ryan, with Larry calling JJ an autistic savant and saying Tylee acted as his caretaker in practice."]

    Apr 1, 2024·35m·3 clips
  7. 7

    49 - SERIAL: The Long Island Serial Killer

    Hidden gem

    True Crime DEADLINE centers on Rex Heuermann, the Manhattan architect charged in the Gilgo Four murders, and asks whether he acted alone.

    Mar 18, 2024·23m·2 clips
  8. 8

    48 - MURDER: Jared Bridegan. Wife Speaks Out

    Mar 4, 2024·32m
  9. 9

    47 - MURDER: JC McGhee. Daughter Speaks Out

    Feb 20, 2024·17m
  10. 10

    46 - SERIAL: Confessions of Samuel Little: The FBI Interview

    Hidden gem

    Samuel Little's 2012 DNA match connected him to three 1980s Los Angeles cold-case homicides.

    Feb 5, 2024·34m·2 clips
  11. 11

    TRAILER - SEASON V

    Jan 29, 2024·2m
  12. 12

    45 - SERIAL: BTK Serial Killer suspected in more Murders. Daughter Speaks Out

    Aug 28, 2023·46m
  13. 13

    44 - MURDER: Jody LeCornu: Murder Witness Speaks Out

    Aug 14, 2023·38m
  14. 14

    43 - CULT: Lori Vallow-Daybell Trial: Lori's Cousin Speaks Out

    Hidden gem

    Megan Eden explains why she avoided Netflix, Dateline, and commentary while trying to separate facts from speculation.

    Jul 31, 2023·26m·1 clip
  15. 15

    42 - CULT: Manson Murders: Sister of Sharon Tate Speaks Out

    Jul 17, 2023·28m
  16. 16

    41 - MURDER: NEW Details in the cruise ship murders of Tamara Tucker & Shirley McGill

    Jul 3, 2023·18m
  17. 17

    TRAILER - SEASON IV

    Jun 26, 2023·2m
  18. 18

    40 - MURDER: Crystal Rogers mom Speaks Out

    Aug 29, 2022·46m
  19. 19

    39 - SERIAL: Sister of Serial Killer John Wayne Gacy (Killer Clown) Speaks Out

    Jul 18, 2022·20m
  20. 20

    38 - MYSTERY: Death of Jen Myers. Family Speaks Out

    Apr 25, 2022·46m
  21. 21

    37 - MURDER: Lifeguard Molly Bish: Sister Speaks Out

    Mar 28, 2022·58m
  22. 22

    36 - MYSTERY: Sister of Missing Maura Murray Speaks Out

    Feb 28, 2022·51m
  23. 23

    35 - SERIAL: Daughter of the 'San Francisco Witch Killer' Speaks Out

    Oct 6, 2020·1h
  24. 24

    34 - MYSTERY: The Disappearance of Christine Walters. Her mother's LAST INTERVIEW

    Sep 28, 2020·28m
  25. 25

    33 - MYSTERY: The Springfield Three. Mother of victim Speaks Out.

    Sep 22, 2020·32m
  26. 26

    32 - MYSTERY: Death of Ellen Greenberg - MURDER or SUICIDE? Private Investigator Interview.

    Sep 15, 2020·36m
  27. 27

    31 - MURDER: Abby & Libby 'The Delphi Murders'. Libby's sister Speaks Out.

    Sep 8, 2020·38m
  28. 28

    30 - MURDER: The Labor Day murder of Katie Sepich. Victim's mother Speaks Out

    Aug 31, 2020·35m
  29. 29

    29 - MURDER: Elvis killed at Las Vegas 'Graceland' Mansion

    Aug 24, 2020·13m
  30. 30

    28 - SERIAL: Golden State Killer Survivor Kris Pedretti Speaks Out

    Aug 18, 2020·39m
  31. 31

    27 - MYSTERY: Carole Baskin's ‘Tiger King’ Don Lewis goes Missing

    Aug 10, 2020·48m
  32. 32

    26 - MURDER: ‘Cult Mom’ Lori Vallow & Chad Daybell - Case Crash Course

    Aug 3, 2020·36m
  33. 33

    24 - EXECUTION: Interview with the Witness to Lawrence Colwell Jr's Execution

    Jul 26, 2020·41m
  34. 34

    25 - SERIAL: Daughter of the BTK Serial Killer Speaks Out

    Jul 26, 2020·43m
  35. 35

    23 - MURDER: Daughter of Murdered Newlyweds Gary & Stephanie Gillette Speaks Out

    Nov 11, 2019·32m
  36. 36

    22 - MURDER: Leslie & Adriane 'The Halloween Murders'

    Oct 27, 2019·13m
  37. 37

    21 - MYSTERY: Death of Joseph Miranda - Mother Speaks Out

    Oct 21, 2019·32m
  38. 38

    20 - MYSTERY: Death of Jessica Johnson - Mother Speaks Out

    Oct 14, 2019·24m
  39. 39

    19 - TERROR: Killer on the Train - American Hero, Alek Skarlatos Speaks Out

    Oct 6, 2019·32m
  40. 40

    18 - SERIAL: Ted Bundy Survivor Kathy Kleiner Speaks Out

    Sep 30, 2019·53m
  41. 41

    17 - SERIAL: Unmasking the Brockton Killer

    Sep 22, 2019·20m
  42. 42

    16 - MYSTERY: Murder of News Anchor Jodi Huisentruit

    Sep 15, 2019·37m
  43. 43

    15 - SERIAL: The Candy Man's Last Victim, Forensic Anthropologist Speaks Out

    Sep 8, 2019·35m
  44. 44

    14 - MURDER: Betty & Kathryn 'The Labor Day Murders'

    Sep 1, 2019·27m
  45. 45

    13 - STALKER: Kelly Swoboda & His Dungeon Van

    Aug 25, 2019·21m
  46. 46

    12 - MURDER: Jody LeCornu: Sister Speaks Out

    Aug 18, 2019·35m
  47. 47

    11 - MURDER: Shirley McGill & Tamara Tucker

    Aug 11, 2019·20m
  48. 48

    10 - SERIAL: Murders of Amber Dubois & Chelsea King. Mother Speaks Out

    Aug 5, 2019·36m