Sharp true crime around a very dark fire.
True Crime Campfire covers murder cases where romance, money, ego, and obsession curdle into violence. Its style is brisk and blunt, pairing clear chronology with skeptical asides when a suspect’s choices deserve the editorial side-eye.
PRESS PLAY
True Crime Campfire treats true crime as both a record of harm and a gallery of catastrophic human decision-making. It is not quiet, but it is organized. Katie and Whitney move through each case with a fast conversational rhythm, building timelines from marriages, affairs, arguments, inheritances, missing-person reports, police work, and the small weird details that make a story stick. A Jill Coit episode turns serial marriage, estate fights, and fabricated children into a portrait of manipulation. The Greg de Villers case starts with youth, attraction, and a risky encounter that becomes something much darker. Josh Niles and Amber Washburn’s story brings in bitter exes, new relationships, and the long shadow of resentment. The Route 40 killer episode shifts into serial violence, sex work, witness sightings, profiles, and the frustrating gap between suspicion and proof. Sue McFarland’s case opens near the end, with detectives searching an abandoned farm after 50 days of absence. The Boczkowski episode lingers on an ugly separation, money pressure, Elaine’s renewed confidence, and the danger hidden inside a supposedly familiar home. Bill McLaughlin’s murder begins in a wealthy gated community, where comfort and charm offer no protection from betrayal. Even the grab-bag episode on motivational speakers keeps the show’s basic obsession intact: confidence can be a mask, and a catchy public persona does not make someone safe. The show’s humor is pointed rather than cozy. It reacts to bad behavior in real time, then gets back to the facts. That combination keeps the pacing high without flattening the victims into plot devices. The editorial stance is clear: motives matter, excuses do not. Listeners get geography lessons, relationship maps, investigative pivots, and enough banter to keep the bleakness breathable. The cases skew toward murder, intimate-partner violence, stalking, manipulation, and predators exploiting trust. It is built for people who want their true crime detailed, skeptical, and alive to absurdity. It is less suited to anyone looking for hushed atmosphere or detached criminology. The draw is the balance: carefully told stories with enough bite to call out the cruelty, vanity, and sheer foolishness around the crimes.
Made for: For true crime listeners who like researched case narratives with fast pacing, conversational analysis, and cleanly delivered gallows humor. Best for audiences comfortable with blunt discussion of murder, manipulation, domestic violence, and predatory behavior.
What sets it apart: The show stands out by pairing case chronology with immediate moral reaction, so the storytelling feels researched without becoming sterile. Katie and Whitney keep momentum high while still naming the emotional and investigative stakes.
Join hosts Katie and Whitney for a different kind of true crime podcast. You can start with season 1, The Puppet Master and the Prince of Darkness, a deep dive into the most bizarre murder case you've never heard of. Or start with season 2, which covers a different stranger-than-fiction story each week. This bingeworthy show combines meticulous research with a refreshing mix of comic relief and seamless storytelling. There's plenty of room around the campfire--come help us roast murderers and marshmallows! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-campfire--4251960/support.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Katie and Whitney make complicated cases legible through careful chronology, close attention to relationships, and an irreverent conversational rhythm.
True Crime Campfire pairs detailed case narration with Katie and Whitney's candid running conversation. Their range stretches from domestic murder investigations and the Route 40 killings to Krystian Bala's crimes and the fraudulent world of self-styled martial arts masters.
Martial-arts frauds share the campfire with killers; your taste for pointed jokes has a place here.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A sharp true crime story about marriages, money, and a case that keeps getting messier.
Jill Coit is one of those names that immediately raises eyebrows, and the episode follows a story that only gets more tangled as it moves through marriages, money, and a case that refuses to settle down.
A fast, dry true-crime ride that keeps the story moving.
True Crime Campfire keeps the attention on Greg's college-era story, from the border run to Tijuana to the flirtation with Kristin as the tone shifts into darker territory.
A volatile split, a new love, and the Texas panhandle shape a case driven by lingering resentment.
True Crime Campfire treats the murders of Josh Niles and Amber Washburn as the fallout from a relationship that never really cooled. The episode tracks Charlene's life with Jace, their daughter Skylar, and Josh's quick bond with Amber, but its most compelling thread is the…
A Route 40 case shaped by missed signals, a blue van, and evidence that never quite settles the question.
After Dark: The Route 40 Killer follows a case built around a 1987 discovery in Newark, Delaware, and the investigative choices that left a possible lead untouched until it no longer had much use.
A grim domestic case told with sharp timing, dry outrage, and no patience for bad excuses.
True Crime Campfire frames a domestic murder story as a brisk, blunt account of a marriage that was already coming apart before the killing. It keeps the chronology clear, resists any urge to smooth over ugly behavior, and stays focused on the practical details that give the…
A literary hook gives this jealous-marriage story extra weight.
True Crime Campfire opens Krystian Bala's story by linking Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment to Christian and Stasha's marriage, then following jealousy into surveillance, threats, and a bar confrontation.
A brisk look at martial arts grift, with Ashita Kim as the episode's strangest anchor.
True Crime Campfire turns its focus to martial arts frauds, from no-touch knockouts and touches of death to mystical masters who cannot manage their own lives.
Australian crime, remembered close up.
True crime with side-eye and velocity.
True crime with real-time reactions.
Part one of a true crime story about the murder of Rozanne Gailiunas in 1983, exploring a love triangle and a twisted investigation.
Hosts Katie and Whitney investigate the murder of Dariusz Janiszewski in Poland in 2000.
Hosts Katie and Whitney investigate the world of martial arts frauds, focusing on three key figures.
A true crime podcast episode about the stalking of a beloved first grade teacher in Pennsylvania in the 1990s, involving anonymous letters, threats, and a bizarre trial.
True Crime Campfire opens on Jerry Boggs dead in his Steamboat Springs kitchen, and Douglas Boggs tells 911 that Jill Coit did it.
True Crime Campfire's "Falling Star: The Murder of Gregory DeVillers" tracks Kristen Rossum from a Memphis academic family to a San Diego murder warrant after a meth run across the San Ysidro border.
["True Crime Campfire covers the October 22, 2018 shooting of Josh Niles and Amber Washburn in Sodus, New York, where neighbor Tiffany Thayer hears the gunfire from her kitchen window.", "Their four-year-old son, Josh Jr., is found in the backseat with a four-piece box of chicken McNuggets while deputies search for a tall, thin shooter in a dark hoodie and green cap.", "Katie and Whitney trace the case through Charlene Childers, Casey Miller, and Tim Dean, including a hot-pink Glock, a Texas custody fight, and a video of Tim screaming at his daughter Maddie.", "The episode follows the Kansas breakdown, the rental-car paper trail, and Braun Bowler's collapse after a polygraph, leading to convictions for Tim and Charlene."]
True Crime Campfire's Katie and Whitney trace the Route 40 killer through Newark, Delaware, starting with Shirley Ellis on November 29, 1987, beside Old Bay Road and Baltimore Pike.
A true crime podcast episode about the murder of Sue McFarland, where detectives search for her body after she goes missing in Texas.
Brenda Vance’s bathtub experiment showed Elaine Buczkowski could not have drowned the way Tim described.
A true crime podcast episode recounting the murder of Bill McLaughlin in Newport Beach in 1994, exploring how physical attraction can lead to fatal danger.
A true crime podcast episode about two killer motivational speakers, starting with the murder of Jeffrey Locker in 2009.
A true crime podcast episode recounting the 1987 murder of Kathy Bonney, whose body was found in the Great Dismal Swamp, with clues from her diary revealing a secret life.