Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

True crime with real-time reactions.

The gist

Stranger Danger is a true-crime case discussion show built around one speaker laying out a case while the other reacts in real time. Episodes move from casual catch-up to grim criminal detail, giving the show a loose, personal rhythm without losing sight of the harm at the center.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

Stranger Danger is a true-crime case discussion show with a casual, reactive style. Brie and Fatina give the episodes the feeling of a private conversation that happens to turn toward crimes, interrogations, fugitives, and the awful patterns that become visible after the fact. The openings are domestic and current. They talk about toddlers, Halloween decorations, holiday food, Christmas lights, documentaries, birthdays, reunions, and the strange pull of true-crime media. Then the story changes weight. A case may begin with relationship red flags, a shattered door, a cold interrogation, a fugitive, or a name that suddenly turns an ordinary life into something much darker. The show is not clinically polished, and that is part of its shape. One voice often brings the case while the other supplies genuine shock, follow-up questions, disbelief, and the kind of uneasy humor people use when the material becomes almost too much to hold. Recent episodes move through domestic violence, murder, child abuse, assisted suicide, missing-person threads, and criminal behavior that raises uncomfortable questions about remorse and intent. The show pays attention to warning signs. It notices people seeing bruises, family members making impossible hospital decisions, people sitting too calmly near disaster, and suspects whose reactions do not match the scale of what happened. It can be blunt. It can be irreverent. It also pauses to warn listeners when a subject is especially heavy, particularly around abuse and violence. The format rewards listeners who like true crime with personality left in: tangents, recommendations, jokes, reactions, and the repeated sense that the speakers are processing the case as people rather than performing distance. There is a recurring tension between fascination and revulsion. That tension gives the show its momentum. It follows the case details, but it also keeps circling the human questions underneath them: what someone ignored, what someone survived, what someone failed to feel, and what others only understood too late. The result is conversational true crime with a sharp edge and a familiar refrain of caution. It is grim, chatty, personal, and often unsettling in the same hour.

Made for: For true-crime listeners who like detailed case talk, candid reactions, and conversational detours through daily life. It especially fits fans who prefer personality-driven discussion over formal narration.

What sets it apart: The show’s strongest hook is its one-speaker-knows-the-case energy: the story lands alongside the other voice’s immediate reactions. That structure keeps familiar true-crime material feeling spontaneous, personal, and emotionally live.

In their own words

A true crime, spook spook, all things creepy podcast. Hosted by Fatina & Brii: two bad bitches with a questionable sense of humor.Only one knows what case is being told so you will experience the genuine reactions of the other co-host being told the details.

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Its conversational case retellings turn timelines, warning signs, and questions of motive into exchanges that are easy to follow.

Brie and Fatina make each case feel like a conversation already in progress: one lays out the timeline while the other questions motives, flags contradictions, and reacts in real time.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Thanksgiving leftovers meet a shattered back door; your tolerance for tonal whiplash gets a real test.

Press play if you want

  • to hear a grandmother's 32-year secret land alongside Brie and Fatina's disbelief
  • to get friendly holiday catch-up before you follow police questions after a violent break-in
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
true crime case discussiondomestic violence warning signsmurder investigationsinterrogation behaviorfugitives and hidden identitieschild abuse casesHalloween and spooky-season chattertrue-crime documentaries

Talks about

Best episodes of Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Case 233. No Rhyme or ReasonJan 12, 2026

A sleepy morning chat turns sharp once the Sherry Papini discussion and interrogation footage take over.

Brie and Fatina open in a sleepy morning register, coffee and tea in hand, then turn to a Hulu documentary about Sherry Papini, revisiting a case that has already been talked over many times.

Case 232. Red FlagsDec 30, 2025

A hard listen about bruises, excuses, and the people who kept noticing.

Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast centers on Lisa and Deandre Holloway's relationship through the injuries, excuses, and repeated conflict that kept surfacing around her.

Case 231. Deadly FriendshipDec 9, 2025

A violent house case, an eerie roadside witness, and a devastating hospital decision carry the episode.

The episode is strongest when it stays anchored in the concrete details: the shattered back door, the 911 call from handyman Mitchell, and the unsettling note that police quickly focus on Michael Bowers, who is still across the street from the two houses after the break-ins.

230. America's Most Wanted GrandmaNov 18, 2025

A quiet grandmother's poolside stop turns out to expose a 32-year fugitive life.

This episode follows Tanya McCarter, later identified as Margo Freshwater, and the tension comes from how ordinary her life appears before officers from the Ohio Bureau of Investigations stop her at a swimming pool in May 2002.

Case 228. Methly in LoveOct 20, 2025

A homicide case narrows after a tense lunch and a police visit to Richard's place.

Case 228 keeps the focus on the case itself, following the homicide investigation as it starts to narrow around Richard after Laurie gets through a tense lunch by staying in survival mode and leaving when she can.

Podcasts like Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Case 233. No Rhyme or Reason

    Hidden gem

    Brie and Fatina open with a Hulu documentary on Sherry Papini that includes Papini, her attorney, and her psychologist on camera.

    Jan 12, 2026·48m·4 clips
  2. 2

    Case 232. Red Flags

    Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast tells the Alton, Illinois case of 22-year-old Lisa Dodd, who was eight months pregnant and calling her unborn daughter Baby Bean.

    Dec 30, 2025·1h 1m·5 clips
  3. 3

    Case 231. Deadly Friendship

    Hidden gem

    Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast moves from Thanksgiving banter and celebrity updates into the 2009 Grovetown, Georgia killing of K Parsons.

    Dec 9, 2025·1h 23m·5 clips
  4. 4

    230. America's Most Wanted Grandma

    Hidden gem

    Brie and Fatina trace how Tanya McCarter was identified in May 2002 as Margo Freshwater, a woman who had been on the FBI Top 10 Most Wanted list for women for 32 years.

    Nov 18, 2025·1h 11m·5 clips
  5. 5

    Ep. 229 - Happy 6th Halloween-iversary

    On Stranger Danger's sixth-anniversary episode, hosts Brie and Patina open by recommending Netflix's all-body-camera documentary The Perfect Neighbor, about a Florida dispute in which a neighbor shot through a closed door and hit a mother, AJ, in the chest, then claimed the state's stand-your-ground law.

    Nov 3, 2025·1h 15m·5 clips
  6. 6

    Case 228. Methly in Love

    Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast's "Case 228.

    Oct 20, 2025·1h 4m·5 clips
  7. 7

    Case 227. What to watch

    Brie and Fatina recount Cardi B’s Los Angeles OBGYN encounter with security guard Amani Ellis and Ellis’s $24 million lawsuit claim.

    Oct 6, 2025·1h 9m·2 clips
  8. 8

    Case 226. Down in New Mexico

    Stranger Danger’s “Case 226.

    Sep 22, 2025·1h·2 clips
  9. 9

    Case 225. Textbook Stranger Danger

    Aug 18, 2025·52m
  10. 10

    Case 224. Second Chances

    Aug 4, 2025·1h 18m
  11. 11

    Case 223. "You Want To Kill Her"

    Jul 14, 2025·49m
  12. 12

    Case 222. Red Flags Everywhere

    Jun 30, 2025·1h 24m
  13. 13

    Case 221. Tax Evasion

    Jun 16, 2025·1h 3m
  14. 14

    Case 220. Groomzilla

    Jun 2, 2025·1h 37m
  15. 15

    Case 219. BFF's til the end

    May 19, 2025·48m
  16. 16

    Case 218. Christmas Tour

    May 5, 2025·1h 22m
  17. 17

    Case 217. Familiar Danger

    Apr 7, 2025·1h 4m
  18. 18

    Case 216. Moonshine and Murder

    Mar 24, 2025·1h 17m
  19. 19

    Case 215. Cross Country Confessional

    Mar 10, 2025·51m
  20. 20

    Case 214. Worst Mix Tape

    Feb 24, 2025·1h 15m
  21. 21

    Case 213. Renovation Nightmare

    Feb 10, 2025·1h 8m
  22. 22

    Case 212. Hunter or Hunted

    Jan 27, 2025·1h 23m
  23. 23

    Case 211. Last Good Deed

    Jan 6, 2025·56m
  24. 24

    Case 210. Pour your own beer

    Dec 23, 2024·1h
  25. 25

    Case 209. To Catfish A Murderer

    Dec 9, 2024·1h 20m
  26. 26

    Case 208. Arm & Hammer

    Nov 25, 2024·54m
  27. 27

    Case 207. Attempted Cover-up

    Nov 11, 2024·1h 6m
  28. 28

    Case 206. Scorned Wife

    Oct 28, 2024·1h 28m
  29. 29

    Case 205. Greedy Carmen

    Aug 26, 2024·1h 32m
  30. 30

    Case 204. Andreen

    Aug 12, 2024·59m
  31. 31

    Case 203. Nutty Mother

    Jul 29, 2024·1h 18m
  32. 32

    Case 202. Money Troubles

    Jul 15, 2024·46m
  33. 33

    Case 201. The Mystery of Presh

    Jul 1, 2024·47m
  34. 34

    Case 200. Blood Pizza

    Jun 18, 2024·1h 3m
  35. 35

    Case 199. Kevin is on the case

    Jun 3, 2024·53m
  36. 36

    Case 198. The Librarian's Day Off

    May 20, 2024·1h 7m
  37. 37

    Case 197. Stranger than Stange

    May 6, 2024·1h 13m
  38. 38

    Case 196. Awful wig

    Apr 22, 2024·1h 9m
  39. 39

    Case 195. Lonzie Barton

    Apr 8, 2024·42m
  40. 40

    Case 194."Then do it, Bitch"

    The hosts discuss a recent child abuse case involving a 15-year-old boy killed by his mother and brother.

    Mar 26, 2024·37m
  41. 41

    Case 193. Delulu Davaloo

    Mar 11, 2024·42m
  42. 42

    Case 192. Imagine

    Feb 26, 2024·52m
  43. 43

    Case 191. Legos and Diarrhea

    Co-hosts play a humorous 'Would You Rather' game before diving into a true crime case.

    Feb 12, 2024·38m
  44. 44

    Case190. Seeing Double

    The hosts discuss a recent development in the Alec Murdoch case regarding potential jury tampering and a rejected appeal.

    Feb 5, 2024·38m
  45. 45

    Case 189. Bloxom

    Jan 29, 2024·1h 8m
  46. 46

    Case 188. World’s Worst Teacher

    Jan 15, 2024·40m
  47. 47

    Case 187. Bad Grades

    Two co-hosts discuss recent strange news events before diving into a true crime case, with one host unaware of the details.

    Jan 8, 2024·51m
  48. 48

    Case 186. Brittani’s Attack pt 2

    Jan 2, 2024·42m
  49. 49

    Case 185. Brittani’s Attack part 1

    Dec 25, 2023·43m
  50. 50

    Case 184. Youngblood

    Dec 6, 2023·32m