Studio BOTH/AND
207 episodes listed below
A case file that keeps changing.
True Crime Bullsh** follows the long, shifting investigation into Israel Keyes and the possible victims still outside the official record. It favors documents, interrogation audio, geographic patterns, and careful revisions over neat case-closed storytelling.
PRESS PLAY
True Crime Bullsh** is a long-running serialized investigation centered on Israel Keyes and the unresolved possibility of additional victims. It is not built around quick reveals. The show works more like a case room with the lights left on: FBI files, interrogation audio, missing-person entries, travel routes, maps, sightings, corrections, and outside research all remain in motion. Episodes often begin from one concrete problem, then widen into a larger pattern. A group of spring disappearances may lead to Route 412, Highway 71, Missouri, Arkansas, and Tennessee. A Washington question may turn on how Keyes described victims, incidents, and jurisdictions. An infrastructure-map theory may connect dams, roads, rural landmarks, and older interview details. The pace is measured, and the show expects attention. It also expects doubt. The strongest passages are not about certainty, but about the discipline of revising a theory when new information changes the shape of the evidence. That gives the series a rare editorial honesty. It can spend time with a promising lead, then pull back and admit the case may still have a more ordinary explanation. Raw interview material is a major part of the texture, including FBI questioning, police dynamics, and guest conversations that sometimes unfold with very little smoothing. The result can feel closer to research in progress than a packaged true-crime episode. There are also lighter conversation episodes, but the central engine remains investigative and severe. The show returns often to missing people, unsolved murders, possible Keyes travel corridors, law-enforcement gaps, and the limits of official records. It is especially suited to listeners who want the scaffolding left visible. Nothing here moves quickly for effect. The appeal is in watching a difficult investigation keep changing without pretending that change is the same as resolution.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer patient investigation, primary-source material, and unresolved patterns over tidy narrative closure. It suits people who can follow maps, timelines, interview tape, and evolving theories across a serialized arc.
What sets it apart: The show stands out for treating the Keyes investigation as active research, not a retrospective. It foregrounds corrections, competing theories, raw interviews, and geographic logic in a way that makes uncertainty part of the method.
True Crime Bullsh** is a serialized, investigative podcast that aims to identify the missing victims of serial killer Israel Keyes. Host Josh Hallmark has spent close to a decade combing through FBI files, analyzing interrogation videos, and working with experts in the field in this comprehensive and ground-breaking podcast.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-bullsh-the-israel-keyes-investigation--3588169/support.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
It makes the Israel Keyes inquiry legible by testing new leads against interviews, official recordings, geography, and unresolved gaps.
True Crime Bullsh** keeps returning to the unsettled edges of the Israel Keyes case, building a serialized investigation from interviews, official recordings, missing-person cases, and possible geographic connections. Josh Hallmark treats uncertainty as part of the work.
One killer, shifting evidence, and enough disputed geography to turn your corkboard into infrastructure.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A finale about uncertainty that treats changing your mind as part of the work.
The season seven finale keeps pulling the investigation back into motion, showing how new files, tips, sightings, and points of contact can shift what seems knowable from one moment to the next.
A careful Houston chapter that treats uncertainty as part of the evidence.
This chapter stays with the Houston thread of the Keyes story and keeps the focus where it belongs: on police handling, old field notes, and the nagging possibility that an apparent accident fits a larger pattern. That restraint works.
An honest, self-correcting conversation that favors candor over polish.
The episode is strongest when it turns candid. The host welcomes respectful pushback, owns an early mistake about suicide, and says that criticism led him to find a mental health professional and learn more.
A patient, unsettling chapter that turns roadside details into a wider case map.
This episode follows a grim trail from teenage tinkering in Colville to pipe bombs, Forest Service gates, and the wider case logic around Israel Keyes.
A steady interview that turns family memory into case context.
Part two of the Scott interview stays close to the people and places around Israel Keyes: Rocky Ridge, the main house, the trailers, Oregon, and the family circle around Jeff and Heidi.
A measured, detail-heavy return to the Keyes case that rewards listeners who can sit with the drift.
The episode starts with a travel announcement, then settles into Scott's recollections of Israel Keyes, a childhood friend, and Keyes's February 2004 trip to Utah.
True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.
Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.
Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.
Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.
iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.
A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.
Change drives this finale.
The host explains his hiatus due to depression and burnout, announces a season finale next week, and transitions to Israel Keyes' first interview after his arrest.
Houston becomes the problem.
This episode continues the investigation into serial killer Israel Keys, focusing on his potential involvement in unsolved murders of couples and how his media habits influenced his crimes.
This episode discusses infrastructure maps related to the Keys case, featuring research from Kathy Nation and connections to Nathan's story about Tammy and a hydroelectric dam.
The hosts of a true crime podcast humorously discuss a previous failed recording session and set up their current episode with a lighthearted, conversational tone.
A loose chat suddenly gets useful.
The host analyzes FBI files and interviews to identify missing victims of serial killer Israel Keyes, focusing on his Washington state murders.
This episode of True Crime Bullshit investigates Israel Keyes' potential victims in Washington state, suggesting there may be more than the five he confessed to, with a focus on the Kootenai National Forest area.
True Crime Bullsh** episode 0708 links Hunters, Washington to the Keyes family, Annie, and the Christian identity churches around Colville and Stevens County.
Scott starts close to childhood, not case-file certainty.
Scott, Israel’s childhood friend, describes summers at Rocky Ridge, camping at Israel’s cabin, and riding horses to repair fences without a saddle.
Host announces a listener trip to Iceland and discusses a case detail about an alibi trip to eastern Washington.
Host Josh Hallmark announces a listener trip to Iceland while continuing the investigation into serial killer Israel Keyes and his capacity for love.
The host discusses new information about serial killer Israel Keyes' boat work location in Port Angeles, learned from cold case detectives.
The episode discusses the logistics of charging Israel Keyes and includes a sponsor ad for Ben & Jerry's.
Host Josh Hallmark interviews investigators about new developments in the Brianna Maitland disappearance case.
This episode investigates the disappearance of Roger Jung and explores possible scenarios including accident, suicide, or foul play linked to serial killer Israel Keyes.
Host Josh Hallmark discusses cases of potential victims of serial killer Israel Keyes as part of an ongoing investigation.
The host discusses upcoming live stream and travel event, then describes preparing interview questions for an FBI agent about the Israel Keyes investigation.
Host Josh Hallmark investigates the missing victims of serial killer Israel Keyes, starting with the case of Marble Arvidson in Vermont.
This episode begins with advertisements before diving into an investigation of serial killer Israel Keyes.
Host Josh Hallmark receives a frantic call from Kaz about a potential breakthrough in identifying victims of serial killer Israel Keyes.
A serialized investigative podcast aiming to identify the missing victims of serial killer Israel Keyes through deep analysis of FBI files and expert interviews.
The episode discusses a listener's tip about a possible kill kit linked to serial killer Israel Keyes found in New Orleans.