Loose lists, sharp opinions, strange detours.
Top Five is a conversational ranking show built around five-to-one lists. Movies, comics, candy, side dishes, dopamine triggers, and fictional roommate disasters all become excuses for jokes, memory, niche references, and friendly disagreement.
PRESS PLAY
Top Five uses the clean machinery of a countdown to make room for very talky, very opinionated conversation. The premise is simple: pick a subject, move from number five to number one, and argue the case. The execution is looser. A choice can begin as a quick ranking slot and turn into a story about a kid approving a playlist, a breakdown of a card-game crossover complication, or a complaint about Fruit Stripe gum that somehow detours into generational math. That looseness is the point. The show treats lists as social fuel, not homework. Recent topics bounce across everyday life and fandom: dopamine hits, favorite things of a recent year, awful fictional roommates, side dishes, horror movies, monsters in comics, least favorite candy, and movies starting with a specific letter. The pop-culture center is broad but recognizable. Comics, horror, Stephen King, Looney Tunes, Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, and streaming shows all sit comfortably beside family anecdotes and food opinions. The best stretches sound like friends trying to make a ranking defensible in real time. One speaker states the pick. Another pushes back, laughs, remembers something, or adds a detail that sends the conversation sideways. Then the list pulls everything back into shape. There is enough structure to keep the episode moving, but the delivery keeps the rough edges visible. Horror and comics episodes can get darker, with discussion of monsters, violence, death, adult material, and grim story premises. Even then, the tone remains conversational rather than severe. The show is not trying to crown permanent champions of culture. It is more interested in why a person would put Daffy Duck at number three, why a shiny Pokemon sound still works, or why a certain old comic monster leaves an impression. For fans of ranking debates, niche references, and friendly overthinking, Top Five makes the list itself feel like the starting line.
Made for: Built for pop-culture fans who enjoy ranking arguments, conversational tangents, comics and movie references, and everyday topics treated with outsized seriousness. It also suits listeners who like group energy more than polished interview structure.
What sets it apart: The show keeps a clear countdown frame while letting each pick sprawl into anecdotes, side jokes, fandom history, and quick back-and-forth. Its appeal comes from the way ordinary rankings become miniature comic cases.
Top Five is a show where the hosts categorize, rank, compare, and stratify everything… from cars to gadgets to people and movies. From stuff that is hot, and things that are not nearly as interesting - it's Top Five.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Its ranked conversations turn movies, comics, and horror into personal criticism sharpened by disagreement and detailed recall.
Top Five turns ranking into an excuse for argument, with several voices assembling separate lists and defending each choice as the countdown moves. Movies, comics, horror, games, television, food, and everyday preferences all enter the same conversational frame.
A cantaloupe ranking becomes a case for the defense, and your own list will not survive intact.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A warm countdown of dopamine hits finds its clearest spark in a shiny Pokemon chime and a son's approval of a good song.
Top Five frames dopamine as something that sneaks in through ordinary moments: a weekend work message that suddenly clears Saturday, a song that earns approval from the passenger seat, a small sound from a game that still hits with surprising force.
A 2025 favorites list that turns a messy Spider-Man set and Welcome to Derry into the main draw.
Top Five opens 2026 by treating the list as a set of 2025 favorites rather than a hard best-of, which gives the episode room to breathe without overpromising completeness.
A roommate ranking turns sharper once Daffy Duck's rent habits, transportation needs, and self-regard are on the table.
A roommate question turns into a tidy comic ranking by starting with a blunt, useful test: could this character actually pay rent? That gives the discussion its footing when Daffy Duck lands at number three.
A spooky ranking that turns comic monsters into history, argument, and punchline.
Top Five Monsters in Comics leans into spooky-season ranking with a clear swing from a familiar heavyweight to something far more unsettling. Al Ewing and Joe Bennett's Hulk gets the opening spot, and the strongest passage is the way it frames that character as either a big,…
A candy ranking turns into a funny hang around Fruit Stripe, Chico sticks, and memory.
Top Five Least Favorite Candy turns a ranking into a sideways argument about sweets that already feel like jokes. Fruit Stripe gum gets the harshest treatment, and the chat keeps circling back to Chico sticks, 1985, and the sense that some candy belongs to another era entirely.
A fruit ranking that turns into a small, strange argument about taste and habit.
Top Five Fruits (Part 1) uses a ranking frame to turn a simple category into a talk about taste, habit, and what gets eaten at home. Matthew and Rodrigo move from oranges to cantaloupe, honeydew, clementines, bananas, and the odd fact that some fruit shows up year round while…
A ranking show that turns a letter premise into loose, thoughtful movie talk.
The show takes a letter-based premise and uses it as a loose frame for movie talk, with the strongest stretch coming when the panel keeps returning to what actually lands for them.
Fast banter, strange pivots, real hangout energy.
Creative conversations, mostly from the Glasgow theatre scene.
Pop-culture arguments with a loose grip.
Fast friendship, blunt stories, zero polish.
Florida stories, movie tangents, and hundreds of episodes of drift.
Fast banter, old bits, fresh derailments.
A countdown show discussing top five movies that begin with the letter F, starting with Ferris Bueller's Day Off.
An encore episode counting down the top five holiday songs, with sponsor messages at the start.
The host introduces a special early release episode listing the top five things to watch over Thanksgiving weekend, starting with a recommendation for Hellboy the Crooked Man.
Hosts Matthew and Rodrigo count down their top five movies starting with the letter D.
Hosts Matthew and Rodrigo count down their top five fruits in a lighthearted ranking episode.
Top Five counts down everyday dopamine triggers, including unexpected days off, messages from family, forgotten snacks, shiny Pokémon sounds, synchronized schedules, and a giant chicken burrito.
Top Five kicks off 2026 by counting down favorites of 2025.
Top Five's "characters who would be terrible roommates" countdown starts with Rodrigo's rule that a candidate has to be able to pay rent, which immediately knocks out a T-Rex.
Top Five ranks side dishes through personal arguments about green bean casserole, cubed sweet potatoes, chili cheese fries, Brussels sprouts, onion rings, potato salad, and baked beans.
A countdown of the top five horror movies from the 1990s.
Top Five counts down monsters in comics for spooky season.
The panel starts by ranking candy.
A countdown show discussing the top five movies that begin with the letter D, starting with the thriller 'Don't Move'.
A countdown show listing the top five movies that start with the letter C, preceded by sponsor ads.