Pop culture villains get their appeal hearing.
The Villain Was Right treats familiar films and shows like evidence in a very funny appeal hearing. Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds recap the plot, argue character logic, and keep asking whether the designated bad guy had a point.
PRESS PLAY
The Villain Was Right is built on a question that sounds like a bit until the evidence starts piling up. Were the villains actually wrong, or did the movie just have better lighting for the hero? Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds take that premise into movies and TV of different kinds, from superhero releases and stage-musical adaptations to teen melodramas, family animation, rom-coms, and audience-choice nostalgia. The result is part recap, part roast, part moral audit. It moves fast. Plot summaries keep turning into side arguments about boundaries, casting, staging, science fairs, prom behavior, memory machines, cosmic beings, and why a character's supposedly evil plan may be more reasonable than the script wants to admit. The show is especially strong when the movie's logic frays. In What About Bob, the conversation sharpens around therapy, safety, and the point at which charming persistence becomes alarming. In The Fantastic Four: First Steps, the group can bounce from Galactus strategy to speculative universe physics without losing the joke. Jesus Christ Superstar becomes a run at musical choices, modern props, religious framing, and the hosts' own admitted limits as viewers. A Walk to Remember draws out the split between sincere tears and total emotional resistance. Coyote Ugly gives them a reason to talk about reputation, party aesthetics, and the lines people remember long after the plot fades. Guests such as Andrew Ivimey, Michelle Forrester, and Tobi Solebo add extra pressure to the arguments without turning the show into a polite panel. The appeal is not careful film scholarship. It is smart comic instinct applied to messy cultural objects. The hosts like jokes that arrive mid-thought, but the premise gives the chaos shape. Every episode is looking for the alternate verdict. Sometimes the villain is cleared. Sometimes the hero just gets cross-examined until the movie looks much stranger than remembered. Fans of energetic recap shows, comedy podcasts, and affectionate but merciless pop-culture debate will feel at home here.
Made for: For listeners who like movie and TV recaps with jokes, argument, and a strong tolerance for chaotic disagreement. It especially suits fans of cult favorites, nostalgic rewatching, and comedy that treats character logic like evidence.
What sets it apart: The show does not just recap or review; it flips the moral frame and tests whether the villain's case actually holds. That simple shift gives even familiar titles a fresh, combative charge.
Comedians Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds view Movies and TV from the villain's perspective and dare to ask if they were really all that bad. Podcast Produced by Andrew Ivimey for The From Superheroes Network.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds turn familiar screen conflicts into funny, specific arguments about sympathy, responsibility, and who actually behaved reasonably.
The Villain Was Right gives Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds a useful constraint: retry a screen story from the accused character's side and see which moral assumptions survive. The resulting film analysis works as a comic pressure test rather than a contrarian verdict.
The Wicker Man's women get a bee-based defense; your movie-night arguments may never recover.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A sharp movie-club argument about when Bob stops being funny and starts feeling unsafe.
What About Bob? gives The Villain Was Right a clean pressure point: when does Bob stop playing like a comic nuisance and start looking like a real safety issue? Craig Faye and Rebecca Reeds build the discussion around Bob's bus trip to find Dr.
A Galactus ethics debate gets pushed into cosmic physics and universe-sized bathroom humor.
The Villain Was Right takes Fantastic Four: First Steps as the springboard for a clean, strange question: could killing Galactus be ethical, possible, or even on the table?
An Easter rewatch where fighter jets, a stubborn title song, and talk-singing all collide.
Jesus Christ Superstar gets an Easter rewatch built around its strange collisions: fighter jets, tanks, microphones, and a title song that lodges itself firmly in Craig Faye's head.
A prom slight turns a familiar comedy into a lively debate over who is really causing harm.
Romy and Michelle's High School Reunion gets a villain-perspective revisit centered on the movie's social skirmishes. Craig Fay and Rebecca Reeds join guest Michelle Forrester, who chose the film and says she had never seen it before, to look again at how the title pair behave…
A mind-reading machine turns Meet the Robinsons into a brisk comic argument about memory, proof, and self-worth.
The Villain Was Right frames Meet the Robinsons around Lewis's mind-reading invention, treating the science-fair project as both a dazzling feat and a shaky shortcut to being chosen.
A funny M3GAN rewatch where villainy gets tangled in guardianship, engineering, and titanium overkill.
The Villain Was Right treats M3GAN less as a simple killer-doll case than as a problem of responsibility, then keeps widening the circle. Rebecca Rees comes in tuned to the movie's humor, slashing, story, and irritating people, while Craig Fay arrives fresh, drawn by the promise…
A chaotic Wicker Man debate finds ecological stakes inside Nicolas Cage's bee argument.
The Wicker Man turns into a lively test of how far a film can push blame before its supposed villains start to look defensible. Rebecca Reeds and Craig Fay bring Sequoia Simone into a first-time viewing that treats Nicolas Cage's missing-daughter crisis as both a horror setup…
Marvel TV reviews with pub-quiz energy.
Hosts Rebecca Reeds and Craig Fay, with guest Sequoia Simone, analyze the 2006 remake of 'The Wicker Man' starring Nicolas Cage.
Hosts Rebecca Reeds and Craig Fay analyze the 2022 horror film 'M3GAN'.
Episode 395 of The Villain Was Right treats What About Bob as a villain-perspective test for Dr.
Rebecca Reeds, Greg Fay, and guest Andrew Ivimey turn Fantastic Four First Steps into a villain-perspective argument about Reed Richards, Galactus, and Sue Storm.
Craig Faye and Rebecca Reeds cover Jesus Christ Superstar, Andrew Lloyd Webber's movie musical about Jesus's last days, and start by saying Heaven on Your Mind goes hard from the first guitar lick.
Hosts Craig and Rebecca discuss the 2002 film 'A Walk To Remember' from a villain's perspective, debating its emotional impact and religious themes.
The hosts introduce an audience-chosen episode covering the 2000 film 'Coyote Ugly' from a villain's perspective, discussing its nostalgic appeal and cultural impact.
Michelle Forrester joins Craig Fay to discuss Romy and Michelle's High School Reunion, the 1997 film about a 10-year class reunion, Kristine Masters, Billy, and the fake Post-it story.
Rebecca Reeds, Greg Fay, and guest Toby Sholombo revisit Disney’s Meet the Robinsons and treat Lewis’s inventions as a moral problem, not just a plot device.
The hosts discuss the 2004 rom-com 'Win a Date With Tad Hamilton' from a villain's perspective, critiquing its casting and missed potential.
The hosts of 'The Villain Was Right' introduce a guest and discuss their January movie pick, 'Inside Man', a Spike Lee film.
The hosts and guest Kyah Green discuss the TV show Buffy the Vampire Slayer from the villain's perspective, focusing on seasons one and two.
The hosts of The Villain Was Right podcast discuss the movie 9 to 5 with guest Bria Hiebert, exploring its cast, song, and unexpected plot.
The hosts and guest Adam Christie discuss the 1988 anime classic Akira from the villain's perspective.