The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

True crime, messy notes, sharp side-eye.

The gist

This true crime comedy show pairs case storytelling with chaotic side conversations, abrupt corrections, and blunt reactions. Episodes move from Lyda Southard, Heaven's Gate, Claudine Longet, John Orr, and Kitty Genovese to gym talk, pneumonia, concert plans, and recurring water-bottle hygiene reminders.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

This true crime comedy show treats structure as a suggestion, not a contract. Each episode centers on a case, but the route there is messy, conversational, and full of interruptions. Poisonings, cult theology, suspicious fires, celebrity scandal, courtroom fallout, and famous murders all appear in the recent run. Lyda Southard brings arsenic, illness, and suspicion. Heaven's Gate brings aliens, bodies, doctrine, and contradictions. Claudine Longet brings fame, romance, violence, and sharply divided public narratives. John Orr brings arson investigation, reputation, and the uneasy feeling that expertise can become cover. The show has room for all of that, then suddenly has room for pneumonia, a neurosurgeon visit, Shania Twain, poison ivy, cruise-ship documentaries, and confusion over where the microphone should be. That tonal whiplash is part of its identity. The case summaries are serious enough to follow, but never sealed off from the hosts' reactions. They question sources. They get sidetracked by strange wording. They call out details that seem flimsy, repetitive, or absurd. The pacing is not sleek. It is familiar, jumpy, and openly imperfect. The appeal comes from hearing the research collide with two people who do not pretend to be detached from it. The show is especially comfortable with older cases, grim motives, cult logic, and strange behavioral details. It also keeps a recurring domestic refrain: wash the water bottle. That bit says a lot about the show. Even after death, poison, arson, and legal horror, it lands back in everyday mess. The best fit is a listener who likes true crime with blunt humor, skeptical asides, and casual friendship at the center.

Made for: Best for true crime listeners who prefer casual banter, sarcasm, and imperfectly organized storytelling over solemn documentary polish. It suits audiences comfortable with dark subject matter handled through humor and blunt reactions.

What sets it apart: The show stands out by letting the recording-room chaos remain part of the experience: forgotten intros, health updates, tangents, corrections, and recurring reminders sit beside the cases. Its charm is the friction between grim material and unfiltered conversational drift.

In their own words

Welcome to The Shit Show: A Half-Assed True Crime Podcast, where every week we dive into murder, mayhem, mystery, and the occasional medical malpractice. If you're into true crime but also love sarcasm, F-bombs, and chaotic commentary, this is your jam. We cover the highs, the lows, the WTFs, and everything in between—while being just organized enough to hit “record.” 🎙️ New episodes weekly. 🎧 Follow for half-assed history, weird murders, sketchy suspects, and totally biased theories. 🔎 Keywords: true crime comedy podcast, funny murder podcast, moms who love murder, dark humor podcast, unsolved mysteries, women in true crime

Why you'd press play

An arsenic case can end with a reminder that your water bottle needs washing.

Press play if you want

  • to hear Talisa and Sarah question whether Heaven's Gate had room for the family dog
  • to follow a fire investigation with someone willing to ask how the evidence survived the flames
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
true crime comedypoisoning casescult deathsarson investigationscelebrity scandalunsolved mysteriescourtroom falloutwater bottle reminders

Talks about

Best episodes of The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

86. Lyda SouthardAug 19, 2025

A grim Lyda Southard case gets a loose, macabre treatment, from arsenic and typhoid to squirrel-call detours.

Lyda Southard's story unfolds as a bleak run of deaths, beginning here with Robert's illness: nausea, cramping, diarrhea, weakness, and a diagnosis of typhoid fever before his death on October 12, 1915.

85. Heaven's GateAug 13, 2025

Talisa and Sarah track Heaven's Gate's next-level logic through aliens, animals, death, and uneasy contradictions.

Heaven's Gate lands here as a belief system organized around leaving the human body behind, with aliens, death, and spiritual promotion braided into one unnerving promise.

84. Claudine LongetJul 29, 2025

A conversational Claudine Longet episode shaped by politics, celebrity, uncertainty, and a deliberately untidy true-crime rhythm.

Claudine Longet's story is handled as a loose, conversational reconstruction of the California primary night, with Kennedy giving a televised victory speech while Claudine and Andy waited at the hotel with dinner plans afterward.

83. A Mistress with a Hit ListJul 23, 2025

A loose, attentive case discussion where Michelle's everyday burdens meet suspicion around Jeffrey.

The episode centers on Michelle, whose composed working life sits uneasily beside family pressure, suspicion around Jeffrey, and the lasting image of serious harm marked by a stomach scar.

82. John OrrJul 15, 2025

A fire investigator's reputation becomes the central clue in a case shadowed by arson evidence and uneasy questions.

John's speed at reaching fires and skill at naming their causes turn into the episode's most troubling clue. The case shifts from an L.A. County Sheriff's Department ruling of accidental fire, likely faulty wiring, to John's insistence on arson, then to a 1987 blaze where…

Podcasts like The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    86. Lyda Southard

    Hidden gem

    Lida Southard was convicted of Edward Meyer’s murder after prosecutors traced arsenic to flypaper and cookware.

    Aug 19, 2025·47m·2 clips
  2. 2

    85. Heaven's Gate

    Heaven’s Gate taught that followers could escape Earth through “four methods” and get a “next level body.”

    Aug 13, 2025·1h 9m·2 clips
  3. 3

    84. Claudine Longet

    Hidden gem

    Claudine Georgette Longuet goes from a 1942 Paris birth and a 17-year-old dance job to Las Vegas, where Lou Walters notices her and Andy Williams enters the story after helping with her broken car.

    Jul 29, 2025·1h 2m·4 clips
  4. 4

    83. A Mistress with a Hit List

    Hidden gem

    Talitha and Sarah cover the 2010 shootings at Jeffrey and Yvonne Stern's Bel Air house in Houston, including a February drive-by and a later gunman at a Meritage apartment garage.

    Jul 23, 2025·53m·2 clips
  5. 5

    82. John Orr

    Hidden gem

    The Shit Show covers John Leonard Orr, a Glendale Fire Department captain and fire investigator born April 26, 1949 in Los Angeles, California.

    Jul 15, 2025·37m·2 clips
  6. 6

    81. The Lipstick Killer

    A message reading "For heaven's sake, catch me before I kill more" links the Lipstick Killer nickname to Frances Brown's Chicago murder scene.

    Jul 8, 2025·1h 24m·2 clips
  7. 7

    BONUS Re Release: Anjanette Piotrowski & Sarah Elizabeth Avon

    Hidden gem

    Talesa and Sarah of The Shit Show present two lesser-known missing-person cases, Anjanette Piotrowski in Buffalo and Sarah Elizabeth Avon in Joliet.

    Jul 3, 2025·29m·2 clips
  8. 8

    80. RE Release: Mary Olenchuk & Pam Zimmerman

    Talesa and Sarah recount the 1970 disappearance of 13-year-old Mary Olenchuk from Agunquit, Maine.

    Jul 2, 2025·1h 15m·2 clips
  9. 9

    79. Spree Killer Charles Starkweather

    Jun 25, 2025·56m
  10. 10

    78. The Springfield Three

    Jun 18, 2025·55m
  11. 11

    77. The Derby Poisoner

    Jun 10, 2025·45m
  12. 12

    76. The Deaths of Glenn Turner & Randy Thompson

    Jun 6, 2025·1h 12m
  13. 13

    75. RE RELEASE Martha Wise & The Double Initial Murders

    May 27, 2025·1h 26m
  14. 14

    74. Evelyn Nesbit

    May 20, 2025·1h 9m
  15. 15

    73. Lizzie Borden

    May 13, 2025·1h 24m
  16. 16

    73. Lizzie Borden

    May 13, 2025·1h 24m
  17. 17

    72. Judy Buenoano

    May 6, 2025·57m
  18. 18

    71. The Axeman of New Orleans

    The hosts banter about matching outfits and plan to restructure their true crime podcast before diving into the case.

    Apr 29, 2025·55m
  19. 19

    70. Virgina Rappe

    The hosts banter about spring break plans before diving into a true crime case with sarcastic commentary.

    Apr 22, 2025·1h 10m
  20. 20

    69. RE RELEASE: Michael Swango & The Murder of Jason Bass

    Apr 16, 2025·1h 38m
  21. 21

    68. Mormonism & The Dallas Ripper

    Apr 8, 2025·2h 9m
  22. 22

    67. The North Pond Hermit & Typhoid Mary

    Apr 1, 2025·1h 23m
  23. 23

    66. Jolly Jane Toppan

    Mar 25, 2025·1h 6m
  24. 24

    65. The Hall-Mills Murders

    Mar 18, 2025·1h 32m
  25. 25

    64. The Zanesville Zoo Massacre & Clara Phillips

    Mar 11, 2025·2h 1m
  26. 26

    63. The Starvation "Doctor"

    Mar 4, 2025·1h 8m
  27. 27

    62. Delimar Vera

    Feb 26, 2025·1h
  28. 28

    61. Dorothea Puente & The Murder of Barbara Gibbons

    Feb 18, 2025·1h 21m
  29. 29

    60. Elmer McCurdy & The Murder of Ryan Poston

    Feb 11, 2025·1h 20m
  30. 30

    59. John Andrew Murrell & The Murder of Greg Fleniken

    Feb 4, 2025·1h 19m
  31. 31

    58. The Mad Bomber of NY & The Murder of John Dick

    Jan 28, 2025·1h 25m
  32. 32

    57. The High Priestess of Blood & The Disappearance of Katelyn Markham

    Jan 21, 2025·1h 14m
  33. 33

    56. The Murder of Florence Small & The Ice Box Murders

    Jan 14, 2025·1h 18m
  34. 34

    55. Patreon Rerelease: Velma Barfield & The DUMBbell Murder

    Jan 7, 2025·1h 28m
  35. 35

    54. *REDO* The Murder of Kimberly Simon

    Dec 31, 2024·44m
  36. 36

    53. The Martin Family Disappearance

    Dec 24, 2024·47m
  37. 37

    52. William Johnston & The Circleville Letter Writer

    Dec 17, 2024·1h 14m
  38. 38

    51. A Texas Love Story & Blanche Moore

    Dec 10, 2024·1h 42m
  39. 39

    50. The Murder of Katrina Smith & MGK

    Dec 3, 2024·1h 29m
  40. 40

    49. Patreon Rerelease Brides in the Baths & The Murder Factory

    Nov 26, 2024·1h 10m
  41. 41

    Patreon Rerelease: The Murder of Helen Jewett & The Kirtland Cult Murders

    Nov 19, 2024·1h 23m
  42. 42

    48. NJ Shark Attacks of 1916

    Nov 19, 2024·38m
  43. 43

    Quicky 37. The Robison Family Murders

    Feb 19, 2021·30m
  44. 44

    47. The Valentine's Day murders of Tiana Notice & Denise Leuthold

    Feb 17, 2021·1h 25m
  45. 45

    Quicky 36. Unsolved Tyarra Williams and The Mary Morris Murders

    Feb 12, 2021·37m
  46. 46

    46. Awkward Love Square & The Murder of Mattie Hackett

    Feb 10, 2021·1h 24m
  47. 47

    Quicky 35. The Murder of Kitty Genovese

    A comedic true crime podcast covering murder, mayhem, and mystery with sarcastic and chaotic commentary.

    Feb 5, 2021·29m
  48. 48

    45. Alice Crimmins & Betty Lou Beets

    Feb 3, 2021·1h 31m
  49. 49

    Quicky 34. The mysterious death of Vera Stone

    Jan 29, 2021·27m
  50. 50

    44. Dr. Michael Swango & The Murder of Jason Bass

    Jan 27, 2021·1h 38m